News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by jerf on Thursday October 27, 2016 @08:37AM (#12804557)
In addition to the other fine points, I'd point out that "anti-abuse" is going to be "not revenue generating". I wouldn't expect that team to be very stable.

The temptation is probably to try to rationalize how obviously important it is, but that's true of everything in the business so it carries no weight. It's not revenue generating. You don't need to convince me it's revenue generating, you need to convince management, who will be looking at a revenue sheet at the time and seeing negative numbers from that department. It may be shortsighted but companies looking at significant chances of failure in the short term get shortsighted. They have to.

That said, as you suggest, the worst case scenario is that you join and then you lose the job, and then you're back to not having a job. If you can tolerate that financially, then it may still be a good risk. But please be sure you can tolerate that financially.

Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by twblalock on Thursday October 27, 2016 @04:23PM (#12809593)
> In addition to the other fine points, I'd point out that "anti-abuse" is going to be "not revenue generating". I wouldn't expect that team to be very stable.

Yep.

The best piece of career advice I ever got was to work in departments that are profit centers, not cost centers.

I've seen the dynamic play out several times: the employees in the profit centers are treated well, and the employees in the cost centers frequently need to justify the existence of their department and their jobs when management decides to cut costs. It's pretty clear who has the better job security and job satisfaction.

Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by hyperpape on Thursday October 27, 2016 @09:23AM (#12804873)
I think that depends. Abuse and harassment was mentioned as a major factor that kept the company from selling in the past several months. If upper management isn't willing to give up the possibility of selling, fighting abuse would be an important goal, whether or not it's a cost center.

That's not a given, and I agree with braythwayt above that assessing the company's commitment is the most important consideration, but there are strategic reasons they could prioritize it.

Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by jerf on Thursday October 27, 2016 @10:24AM (#12805304)
Sorry, but... yes, that's a great example of the sort of rationalization one is tempted to do.

Here's the business reality: On the balance sheet for the abuse team, there are only expenditures. The benefits don't show up on the balance sheet there; there are diffuse, spread throughout the company, and often future-biased (the abuse shut down today may prevent people from leaving next month). It's the same for IT at a bank, customer support staff anywhere, or accountants. No matter how important it may be, it's not revenue generating. And that makes a huge difference in future career prospects. Things that may impact revenue in a year is not important to a company becoming concerned it may not make it to that year.

(In Twitter's case, while there will probably be a business entity called Twitter in a year, the thing that might not make it to next year is Twitter-the-unicorn-dream. Going into maintenance mode or being acquired at unfavorable terms, while better than going out of business entirely, is still a failure for the Twitter of today.)

I say this as someone who is not really directly revenue generating myself; I'm moving ever more into risk mitigation and management. But the company I'm doing it in is not currently contracting and laying off, but growing. I've got my eye on my own situation, too.

Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by firebones on Thursday October 27, 2016 @07:49PM (#12811528)
That's a twist on the kind of quarter-by-quarter thinking that leads companies like Twitter to optimize for the short term (protect the MAUs!) and neglect the work that has to be done for long term growth and value.

Not disagreeing with the point that being employed in a cost center of a struggling company has risk. You always would prefer to be at the competitive edge if you can, and in a role that aligns with the company's main mission. I just suspect that in this case, the recent abandonment of Twitter buyout offers due to the abuse problem has now made curtailing abuse a top priority, and a much more important part of the company's ability to deliver value.

Another example would be a company whistling past the graveyard with respect to security, seeing security as a non-revenue-generating cost center. All it takes to wake up the board to its importance is a major breach that affects the market cap. (Or take quality control in companies that deal with life-and-death systems.)

Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by jerf on Friday October 28, 2016 @08:41PM (#12821963)
Security is actually the specific risk-mitigation regime I've been moving into, and that's part of why I'm not too worried about it as a career move. It seems to be able to pay well, which suggests that the corporate world does have some understanding that it is a necessity and not just a cost center. But only some.
Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by LordHumungous on Thursday October 27, 2016 @11:01PM (#12812685)
Yeah but at Twitter everyone but the ads team is going to be a cost center. You could make the exact same argument about the operations team.
Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by wpietri on Thursday October 27, 2016 @11:40AM (#12806004)
It's an excellent point. My theory here, like hyperpape, is that recent events have shown Twitter the user growth and stock valuation impacts of abuse, so the connection to metrics they care about will have been learned well enough to avoid the bias that traditional accounting introduces here. (I say that in contrast to things like the Lean Manufacturing or Beyond Budgeting approaches to business accounting, which are not as vulnerable to this error.)

But yeah, it's still definitely a risk. As a long-time startup person, I'm more practiced than most at dealing with financial risk, but I appreciate you mentioning it.

Re:Twitter beats estimates, cuts jobs with eye on 2017 profi... by makomk on Thursday October 27, 2016 @06:20PM (#12810825)
Recent events have shown Twitter the user growth and stock valuation impacts of news articles about their abuse problem. You know what makes for bad news coverage? Banning people journalists know. Some of whom really love harassing people who disagree with them, and threatening them with violence, and really blatantly lying about them, and setting their followers on them, and all through it insisting that anyone who thinks there's anything wrong with this is supporting harassment. Oh, and said group of people are decidedly white, those they go after often rather less so, the former get to define what they're doing as fighting racism, and I'm sure you can guess what happens when someone who isn't white disagrees.

Basically, if you read the end of 1984 and always wished your boot could be the one stomping on a human face forever - especially if it was a black woman's face - then this could be the career for you. Otherwise, run away.