You can claim "users rights" all you want, but knowing people are using your service to break laws, and just refusing compliance, well gets you to exactly the position they are in.
[1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023034803045795759...
That wouldn't convince me that Google should turn over thousands of user records without a fight.
It's important that prosecutors have some sort of burden or proof before obtaining personal information, not after. I hope all companies push back on such requests, even when it's not in their financial interest to do so.
Google is an index of the web, and allows folks to search that index.
Google has a process to remove search results that would links to sites that host copyright material.
We're not talking about protecting a political activist. We're talking about illegal rentals.
But regardless, if an attorney general asked The Pirate Bay or Mega for all personally identifying user data, I imagine people would be singing a different tune. Or, similarly, if an attorney general asked Google for everyone who had searched for "piratebay" or "mega".
> The legal strike comes just days after AirBnB CEO Brian Chesky tried to appease state lawmakers by agreeing that its users should collect the normal hotel occupancy tax and promising to work with pols to root out bad hosts.
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/state-airbnb-articl...
The appropriate summary is: AG specifically wants information about people who actually owe hotel occupancy taxes. They aren't trolling for every AirBnB user.
The difference compared to your hypothetical examples is that merely visiting the sites doesn't necessarily constitute illegal behavior. Searching for "mega" in and of itself is not an illegal activity, just like how searching for "marijuana" is not illegal (especially now that certain states have legalized recreational use). The true analogy is asking the torrent trackers to release IP information for connections pertaining to a specific torrent.
Whatever negligible externalities are introduced by Airbnb, they are vastly outweighed by positive effects like making travel more affordable and busting up the hotel oligopoly.
I felt compelled to point how ridiculous this is. There are tons of lodging options. You can see for yourself with a casual search on any price comparison site.
I travel quite a bit for work, and I've stayed at 30+ hotels over the last 2 years. All of them, with the exception of a couple independents in NYC, were owned by Marriott or IHG.
Why only them?
I wonder why they keep disregarding the safety of NYC residents when they can go to Union City, NJ?
"For clean, affordable, convenient, hotels when visiting NYC, don't use AirBnB, use the hotels of Union City, NJ"
Have you ever been to NYC? In 2016 it's far from dangerous. It's probably one of the safer cities in the US.
Additionally, AirBnB guests aren't typically dangerous (otherwise AirBnB would be out of business).
I've lived in NYC for most of my adult life. Do you live in NYC?
The homicide rate has declined, but it is still 3 times that of London, per-capita. Moreover, there are other threats besides homicide.
People who want affordable hotels can go to Union City, NJ for $60 a night (Priceline) 15 minutes by transit from Times Square.
The city is less safe for them than a non-elderly adult male. The homicide rate in NYC is 3 times per-capita than London. There are also other forms of violent crime and property crime. Since you've been in NYC for years then you know that many residential buildings that keep people other than residents and their guests out. We value our safety and that of our children, elderly and women who are at higher risk of crime than men.
Women are also harassed.
Why don't you ask some of your female friends whether they would want the security when in their apartment buildings?
[1] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/feb/...
In that study 1 in 21 men reported being forced to penetrate someone, 4.8%. A further 1.4% of men reported being raped which is defined only as being penetrated, not being forced to penetrate. That's a stupid definition of rape. So it's really more like 6% of men have been raped, which puts the stats at women being about 2x more likely to be raped than men (only 11.5% of women experienced a completed penetration attempt).
Fear is an important thing and we do need to address it, but public policy should be based on factual risks, not irrational fear. Only 7% of rapists are strangers. That means those transients at the AirBnB are the less likely to rape a woman than basically anyone else they know.
And even that includes some murkiness over things like "too drunk to consent".
If you want real rape statistics then look at sexual assault charges, not surveys.
• "Attempted forced penetration," 6.4 percent.
• "Completed alcohol- or drug-facilitated penetration" without the ability to consent, 9.3 percent.
Source CDC referenced in link provided.
1 in 9 completed forced penetration. Another 1 in 15 attempted forced penetration. Almost 1 on 5 for either.
Only 31% of rapes and sexual assaults against women are committed by strangers. [0] An estimated 10% of female murder victims were killed by a stranger. 29% of male murder victims were killed by strangers. [0]
But sure, move the goalposts again. I'm confident you can find a good factoid to support keeping the "wrong sorts of people" (if you know what I mean!) out.
AirBnB didn't want to solve this problem, so NY solved it without AirBnB's help. It's a predictable outcome, and one that AirBnB was hurtling towards once they stood in the path of any other solution.
But eBay profits from people selling stolen goods.
A telco profits when people conspire to commit crimes via email or phone.
A pharmaceutical company profits when an addict buys drugs under a fake prescription.
But the companies aren't specifically commit a crime just because those things happened and the company received income from it.
Companies are expected to do take reasonable steps to limit those sorts of activities, and to appropriately assist law enforcement when they seek to investigate or curb such occurrences.
Surely if there were landlords renting out entire apartment buildings then the sequential addresses would show up in AirBnB's data as mystreet 1a, mystreet 1b, mystreet 1c and so on? It must have been pretty obvious to the point that a routine check against illegal activity should have carried out.
Depends on whether the activity they're engaging is legal or not.
http://www.theverge.com/2016/2/25/11116426/airbnb-report-dat...
Companies that take their customer's privacy seriously should be lauded, not condemned.