News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An apology... by razerbeans on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:29PM (#1278543)
Seeing the name-drop of the Apple engineer on Gizmodo made my jaw drop. I couldn't believe that they would do such a thing. This no doubt casts a shadow on his career and life. It's a reckless attempt by what appears to be a subpar site to make itself somewhat legitimate. In this respect, they've failed miserably.
Re:An apology... by jonknee on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:50AM (#1279539)
It may have saved his job since it sounds like it really was an honest mistake and now if he's fired everyone will be on his side. There's no way Steve can fire him without looking like a heartless bastard. Google would hire him in a second and get a huge PR win.
Re:An apology... by flatline on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @09:33AM (#1279341)
> This no doubt casts a shadow on his career and life.

It's no doubt going to suck for him until this blows over, but it will blow over, and I doubt that his career and life will suffer too much in the long run if he just rides it out. Any rational person looking at this will think it an honest mistake that they could easily have made, as Gizmodo points out tirelessly. Apple would be crazy to fire him.

Re:An apology... by Confusion on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @01:40AM (#1278747)
This no doubt casts a shadow on his career and life.

I think you're overestimating the impact this has. People generally don't remember a name in an article they read at some website some time ago. Secondly, the number of people actually reading this is quite small. For instance, suppose someone lost a Nokia prototype in the same way and the engineer later applied to Apple. How large is the chance that the responsible guy at Apple HR would have heard the story and remembered the name?

Re:An apology... by reitzensteinm on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @01:47AM (#1278757)
Sorry, but you're completely wrong about this. Anyone searching his name for the next 50 years will find this amongst the top 10 unless he ends up with the web presence of someone like Leo Laporte or Joel Spolsky (or someone with the same name does).

The question is not whether hiring managers will find out about this - they will - it's whether they'll care.

Re:An apology... by confuzatron on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @05:42AM (#1279019)
All the chap did was accidentally leave his phone in a bar. Presumably he had it out for dog-fooding style testing. Gray Whoever (I've forgotten already) is hardly a name that will live in infamy.

Unless the next time we see him is in a grainy beheading video featuring Steve Jobs wielding a large machete.

All this 'OMG STOLEN' drama is totally over the top - I think some people are just looking for an angle at which to get outraged at a newsworthy product leak.

Re:An apology... by CWuestefeld on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:09AM (#1279413)
All this 'OMG STOLEN' drama is totally over the top

+1 for that.

I haven't even looked at the Gizmodo page in question. That's not for any moral outrage, but because I just don't care. A new Apple product is not going to change my life by one iota. Hearing about an Apple product under development makes even less difference to me.

I have to say: Apple's marketing -- and this is part of it, make no mistake, even if it was precipitated by accident -- are the masters. That they can get the press into such a tizzy, and have such a legion of fanboys, for nothing but a handful of tech products, is what's truly remarkable -- and makes me kind of sad.

Re:An apology... by njharman on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:13AM (#1279427)
> 'OMG STOLEN' drama is over the top

Unless it is happening to you. Empathy, geeks are known to lack it, you should at least learn to fake it.

Re:An apology... by confuzatron on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:25AM (#1279456)
Okay, but empathy towards a /corporation/ for something secret being leaked? Not so much.

Maybe you're talking about Gary Wotsit being outed - I wasn't referring to that.

Re:An apology... by protomyth on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:47AM (#1279530)
If an HR department can google his name, then it will close career paths to him.
Re:An apology... by boredguy8 on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @01:44AM (#1278752)
Where have you applied lately, that doesn't Google your name?
Re:An apology... by stretchwithme on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @03:19AM (#1278867)
And if you do it enough times, you realize everybody's got something to be unproud of.

"Forgot my cellphone" has got be way down on the list of engineering failures.

Re:An apology... by protomyth on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @10:49AM (#1279532)
Not for a high tech company on the cutting edge who would test their machines in public. If he worked for someone else and was now applying at Apple, would he be hired?
Re:An apology... by fairramone on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:34PM (#1278553)
Not entirely true. I ask EVERYONE I interview what their biggest screw up has been career wise. If they don't have anything interesting to share, I don't want them working for me. This guy has a great story to tell and a real lesson learned.
Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:43PM (#1278567)
As much as I hate to defend Gawker I don't think you can blame them for the negative impact on his career. Say what you will he is guilty of what they claim he did. I would hope future employers would be willing to look past it and realize it was an innocent mistake but they have a right to know. In the end this incident is relevant to how much you trust him with prototypes in the future.

Beyond that Gawker is a news source. It's their job to report on stories. So while it was dishonest to buy the stolen prototype this post is just reporting the story and I'm not sure it's out of the bounds of what a news organization should do.

Re:An apology... by gr366 on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:48PM (#1278571)
After this event, I'll bet you can trust him with future prototypes more than anyone else on this planet.
Re:An apology... by winterlightning on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:10AM (#1278609)
Yet no one ever would want to
Re:An apology... by rrhyne on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:38AM (#1278646)
Only a boss who is not worth working for would think this guy is incapable of learning this lesson after all that.
Re:An apology... by ZachPruckowski on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:29AM (#1278635)
Showing the guy's name, photo, and facebook page is gratuitous and wrong. Dude's already having the worst week of his life, and now they're splaying "this guy was the idiot who lost an iPhone prototype" all over the web? I buy that celebrities should get that treatment because they signed up for it going in[1], but this is just some average guy in a normal profession who was just trying to keep his head down.

[1] - unless your film or music career literally pre-dates Charlie Chaplin, you knew what you were getting into.

Re:An apology... by mustpax on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:58PM (#1278580)
Guilty? As in, culpable? I am baffled by your willingness to burn someone at the stake for an honest mistake. Have you never misplaced anything valuable, left something behind by accident?

Also, Gawker could have easily reported on this story and kept the engineer's name private. For example, read the NY Times article re-reporting the story, you won't see the engineer's name. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/20/technology/companies/20app...

Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:43AM (#1278655)
No. I've never misplaced something that could cost my company thousands of dollars and I'd like to believe I wouldn't be foolish enough to even bring something like that into a bar with me.
Re:An apology... by mustpax on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:59AM (#1278684)
I did not ask if you ever misplaced a top secret prototype device, and quite honestly I'm a little appalled that you feel you would be above making "foolish" mistakes.

I asked if you ever misplaced anything valuable or anything that mattered to you. A wallet could be something valuable, or your keys. Most valuable, however, would be your sense of compassion, which right now you have clearly misplaced.

Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @03:07AM (#1278849)
There's a difference between what is valuable to me and what is valuable to someone else (like my company). Yes I've misplaced things that are valuable to me but when I did I only hurt myself. I did not have an obligation to someone else that I did not fulfill.

This engineer had an obligation to his company that he disregarded and his only excuse is "I was drunk and thoughtless" (which really isn't an excuse at all).

Again, I'm not advocating he be fired because I think people should have the right to make mistakes but I find it appalling that the attitude in this comment thread has been that being drunk makes it ok to be derelict in your duties.

Re:An apology... by bad_user on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @04:46AM (#1278977)
> Yes I've misplaced things that are valuable to me but when I did I only hurt myself.

What a responsible human being you are. You probably don't have kids though :)

People lose their kids in places like supermarkets all the time ... I haven't (yet) but it's a possibility (because kids by definition don't stay put) and I'd appreciate that if you found my child instead of stealing it from me to sell it to the highest bidder, you'd return it to me, because otherwise I might just burn down your house with you in it :)

Yeah, it's a bad analogy because for most people a phone is not equal to a child, but for passionate engineers the line is kind of blurry, isn't it?

> the attitude in this comment thread has been that being drunk makes it ok to be derelict in your duties

No, the attitude is that it's not OK to steal property, even if that person you're stealing from is drunk ... and to make matters worse the buyer also made the story public, for no public good whatsoever.

Re:An apology... by eventhough on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @06:26PM (#1280787)
> People lose their kids in places like supermarkets all the time ... I haven't (yet) but it's a possibility (because kids by definition don't stay put) and I'd appreciate that if you found my child instead of stealing it from me to sell it to the highest bidder, you'd return it to me, because otherwise I might just burn down your house with you in it :)

Please, let's not compare our children with iPhones. Maybe choose a better analogy?

> Yeah, it's a bad analogy because for most people a phone is not equal to a child, but for passionate engineers the line is kind of blurry, isn't it?

Yes, it is a bad analogy, so why did you use it? If you are going to claim that passionate engineers equate products to living humans, at least qualify that by saying "a small proportion".

> No, the attitude is that it's not OK to steal property, even if that person you're stealing from is drunk ... and to make matters worse the buyer also made the story public, for no public good whatsoever.

The guy who had the phone tried to return it. He did more than most people would. On top of that, he was unable to get any contact information off the phone because they wiped it.

Yes he could have returned it to the bar but who knows how trustworthy those bar owners are?

Re:An apology... by Maktab on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @04:30AM (#1278958)
There is a vast difference between believing that the guy did nothing wrong and believing that he didn't deserve to get his identity made public even though he made a serious mistake. I think most people responding here would understand if Apple decided to fire the guy, as he was clearly negligent. What many of us are upset with is Gizmodo's revealing of his name which will cause the guy harm that's far in excess of the severity of his mistake.
Re:An apology... by sree_nair on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @04:05AM (#1278928)
Then the Question is how many times in your Life you had something in your hand which was of great loss to saomeone if you misplaced it?.
Re:An apology... by anthonyb on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:56PM (#1278577)
Bullshit. There's a big difference between making a mistake, and having that mistake sprayed across the internet for all to see.
Re:An apology... by adora on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:08AM (#1278604)
I agree. They had their story. At worst but acceptable they could have said that it was an Apple employee. They completely went over the line by naming said employee.

The question they should have asked themselves first was: "Does naming this person CONTRIBUTE to the story?" This is clear Journalism 101. The answer was and is clearly "no." The best line of defense for them is they have none.

Sometimes I hate the internet and its cache. This is one of those times. Anyone can ruin anyone. The really good news is that it appears he has many people on his side.

Re:An apology... by randallsquared on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @09:03AM (#1279283)
There's a big difference between making a mistake, and having that mistake sprayed across the internet for all to see.

Less and less difference. This is an outlier at the moment, but having your entire life, mistakes and all, laid out for anyone to view... that's just going to be normal.

Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:41AM (#1278652)
Simply put once a news source starts omitting facts based on what they think is relevant that's the beginning of the end. News sources should report the facts in as complete a fashion as they are capable of doing. To do otherwise is to open the door to abuse. What's to stop a reporter from leaving a friend out of a story while reporting his coworkers were involved in some malfeasance? In that case the coworkers then look more guilty in comparison to their unmentioned friend who appears innocent because he wasn't reported in the story. That's just one example of how omitting facts can lead to dishonesty in reporting
Re:An apology... by fhars on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @01:54AM (#1278761)
Omitting irrelevant facts is the whole point of news publishers in the informaton age. You don't pay them to find information, you pay them to filter information.
Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @03:03AM (#1278843)
The mistake you make is in assuming your judgement of what is irrelevant is sacrosanct. Again I give an example...

Let's say a Conservative reporter is in Iraq and for whatever reason he's the only reporter allowed there. Let's say he finds out that there were no WMD but says to himself "That's irrelevant because President Bush thought there were WMD so there's no reason for me to report on that". Would that be right?

Of course not. But the reason we have rules against reporters using their judgement to omit details is because it leads to situations like the above.

Now back to this situation. I'm not saying this is true I'm just putting forth a possibility. That said what if this is a person who serially does things like this? What if he could be linked to several leaks over the past few years? Wouldn't his name be relevant then? But how could you know if that was the case if reporters decided to omit his name every time he was involved? That's just one example of how this one fact that you think is irrelevant could in fact be very relevant

Re:An apology... by ugh on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @04:32AM (#1278962)
There are many journalists in Iraq. And you know why that is? Because if there were only one of them, he might make wrong judgments. Yeah, there might be wrong judgments when humans are involved, no one could disagree with that. The way out, however, is not to force journalists to report everything, the way out is to make sure there are always a good many journalists writing about the same stuff.

Journalists have to make judgments all the time, they have to decide which parts of a story are important and which parts are irrelevant. If they didn’t do that – if they weren’t allowed to do that – they wouldn’t do their job. Reporting whatever you hear and see is not what being a journalist means.

You can have nice arguments about which judgments are the right ones, which are the wrong ones. Saying that Gizmodo should just report whatever they know is not such a argument.

(You actually start to make the right kind of argument in your last paragraph which is nice but I don’t see how there is any evidence at all that hints at the scenario you are describing. There are always many things which are possible but that’s hardly a convincing argument. Evidence is what’s needed.)

Note please, that the New York Times [1] doesn’t mention the name. Apple engineer is all they write.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/20/technology/companies/20app...

Re:An apology... by Maktab on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @04:25AM (#1278951)
The question is whether naming the guy contributed anything to the story and was in the public interest, or whether it was a purely vindictive action by Gizmodo. Considering the fact that the main story is the existence of the prototype and that it's authenticity has already been confirmed by Apple's response, I'd say it was the latter. Revealing the guy's identity added nothing to the story, unlike in your example where the lack of WMDs would be the story.

Gizmodo have chosen to not only imperil this guy's current job with Apple but also his future career prospects. First by providing a market for stolen Apple secrets and being a willing buyer and publisher of the prototype and its details and second by splashing his name all over the internet. Count me amongst those who will boycott Gizmodo and all other Gawker sites from now on.

Re:An apology... by eventhough on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @06:21PM (#1280779)
I believe the press has the freedom to print whatever they want so long as they are following first amendment rights. I feel neutral to the entire situation. Of course it's crappy that the guy's identity was outed but at the same time it was completely within Gizmodo's rights to do so. For that I am voting you backup.
Re:An apology... by mustpax on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:53AM (#1278672)
So news articles about sexual abuse should include the name, age and address of the victim? After all, who is to say it is not relevant to the story.
Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @03:01AM (#1278841)
There are laws against reporting those names for that very reason. Because there is an ethical obligation by reporters to report all the facts and we as society have decided reporting those details isn't acceptable so we restrict them from reporting those details. Just as we do with the names of children.

But the very existence of those laws proves the point I was making which is that reporters should be bound to report all details. Not the other way around

Re:An apology... by tsally on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @04:09AM (#1278931)
So we've established that there is a continuum between reporting all the facts and reporting none of them. As we've said, legally reporters are bound to stand at one point on this continuum (report most facts, but no names of abuse victims, no names of children in the police blotter, etc). It is a reasonable belief that ethically reporters are bound to stand at another point closer to reporting less facts, including omitting the name of someone who lost company property.

There's no proving or disproving points here, as you seem to think. It is a valid belief that ethically the name of the engineer should not have been reported. You might not share this belief, but it is a valid belief to have and it cannot be disproved. Your ethics are simply different.

Re:An apology... by danieldon on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:59PM (#1279937)
"Simply put once a news source starts omitting facts based on what they think is relevant that's the beginning of the end."

Well, then apparently the beginning of the end was the beginning of journalism. This is done all the time.

Re:An apology... by hristov on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:29AM (#1278633)
I don't buy this. His name is not news. It is not important. If they just said "young Apple engineer" the news value of the whole thing would be exactly the same. If somebody that the public cares about loses an iPhone, the name is news. If it is just a random person, well the news value of the actual name is almost none.

Actual responsible journalists often withhold names of ordinary people that get into news stories if disclosure would be embarrassing or damaging for those people. For example, the names of people that are accused of crimes are usually not disclosed by journalists until these people have been charged. The names of people that are killed or injured in a newsworthy event are also usually not disclosed. The names of victims of sensitive crimes like rape or sexual harassment are usually not disclosed.

Of course Apple know he is the one who lost it, but now every future potential employer will also know. And again there was no reason at all for his name to have been made public.

Re:An apology... by BigZaphod on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:02AM (#1278591)
Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:45AM (#1278659)
Did you even read this before you quoted it?
Re:An apology... by anthonyb on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @01:32AM (#1278734)
Jeez, talk about the pot and the kettle. From a five second skim, the harm minimisation part seems pretty appropriate:

Harm limitation principle ...This principle of limitation means that some weight needs to be given to the negative consequences of full disclosure, creating a practical and ethical dilemma. The Society of Professional Journalists' code of ethics offers the following advice, which is representative of the practical ideals of most professional journalists. Quoting directly:[17]

* Show compassion for those who may be affected adversely by news coverage.

* Be sensitive when seeking or using interviews or photographs of those affected by tragedy or grief.

* Recognize that gathering and reporting information may cause harm or discomfort. Pursuit of the news is not a license for arrogance.

* Recognize that private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than do public officials and others who seek power, influence or attention. Only an overriding public need can justify intrusion into anyone's privacy.

* Show good taste. Avoid pandering to lurid curiosity.

Re:An apology... by TomOfTTB on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @03:11AM (#1278854)
Show compassion does not mean omit facts. In fact, the article you quote says just the opposite.

Beyond that this is not a tragedy. This is someone dealing with the consequences of their actions.

Finally publishing photos off someone's social networking site is not invading their privacy.

Again I point out that you didn't read the whole article you quoted. You zeroed in on the points that you think support your argument and ignored the rest. Maybe you should take more than five seconds and read the whole article

Re:An apology... by anthonyb on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @07:50AM (#1279175)
I think we've already established your level of reading comprehension, so I won't argue any of your points, except to say that publishing photos from someone's stolen iphone is absolutely an invasion of privacy, and how you can think otherwise beggars belief.
Re:An apology... by rrhyne on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @12:39AM (#1278647)
Man, how often is this guy going to hear: So you're the guy who lost the iPhone? That's going to get old.
Re:An apology... by eventhough on Tuesday April 20, 2010 @06:19PM (#1280772)
I am voting you back up. I believe your opinion is sound and deserves to be recognized.