The parent post is not questioning whether Gruber believes his sources, but arguing that the information seems implausible. Your reply is that Gruber believes his sources are correct - yes he might state it because he believes it, but it could be wrong.
It might be an appeal to authority, but there isn't any circularity. If you're going to play fallacy bingo, at least get it right...
It isn't circular, is it? I'm mixing G's belief in his correctness and this poster's belief in G's correctness.
Erm, that's a very odd way of putting it. I think the OP was just saying "Gruber's specific claims have been reliable in the past, and hence are quite likely to be correct now." That is perfectly reasonable and it's not circular. (It is, of course, an inductive form of appeal to authority, but there is nothing wrong with that.)
He thinks he is right therefore he is specific, because he is specific I think he is right.
That's what I was trying to say in my awkward earlier post. That does seem appealing to authority - thinking Gruber is right because of what he says and how he says it, rather than considering why he says it.
Actually, what riled me more was the interpretation
"He thinks he is right therefore he is specific, because he is specific I think he thinks he is right."
Which conveys absolutely no information and adds nothing to the discussion, just repeating that G thinks he is right, which is a given, and was still getting upvotes; so I tried to attack the post to feel better, banking on pedanticism being good for a few karma points around here anyway.
:/