By doubling the resolution, they avoid a whole lot of problems by allowing old apps to run at their current resolution without any visible quality loss, something which a 1.5 bump would not achieve.
From the prototype, you'll notice that the battery is much bigger. You can expect that Apple will put a faster chip (similar to the iPad) in the new phone, and that memory and CPU speed will not be an issue.
http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3905
Apple likes 960 width x 540 height (see AppleTV), because it's easy to get to 1/4 1080p by dropping every other line and every other pixel, or to line double back up to 1080p from iFrame.
I mean, remember, Apple was willing just recently here to risk the incredible backlash of 3.3.1 for the sake of platform direction. I think they'll gladly risk developers complaining about redrawing UI bitmaps.
With the iPad, Apple didn't force developers to recode their iPhone apps, instead it allowed the older apps to run at native or double resolution. Granted, the double resolution doesn't look pretty, and Apple is strongly encouraging developers to produce iPad native apps, but they definitely seem to be taking advantage of their 185,000 app head start, and 1.5x would presumably look even worse on an iPad than 2x.
That seems like the opposite of their developer strategy to me. They've resisted making any substantial changes to the basic hardware profile of the iPod Touch / iPhone lineup ever since it was released, presumably to save developers from having to target multiple devices (and this is still a point raised as a complaint against android all the time).
They have also never made a music player. Right until the moment when they made one.
The parent post is not questioning whether Gruber believes his sources, but arguing that the information seems implausible. Your reply is that Gruber believes his sources are correct - yes he might state it because he believes it, but it could be wrong.
It might be an appeal to authority, but there isn't any circularity. If you're going to play fallacy bingo, at least get it right...
It isn't circular, is it? I'm mixing G's belief in his correctness and this poster's belief in G's correctness.
Erm, that's a very odd way of putting it. I think the OP was just saying "Gruber's specific claims have been reliable in the past, and hence are quite likely to be correct now." That is perfectly reasonable and it's not circular. (It is, of course, an inductive form of appeal to authority, but there is nothing wrong with that.)
He thinks he is right therefore he is specific, because he is specific I think he is right.
That's what I was trying to say in my awkward earlier post. That does seem appealing to authority - thinking Gruber is right because of what he says and how he says it, rather than considering why he says it.
Actually, what riled me more was the interpretation
"He thinks he is right therefore he is specific, because he is specific I think he thinks he is right."
Which conveys absolutely no information and adds nothing to the discussion, just repeating that G thinks he is right, which is a given, and was still getting upvotes; so I tried to attack the post to feel better, banking on pedanticism being good for a few karma points around here anyway.
:/
With the iPhone, they're presumably addressing the software aspects of the resolution change in addition to just bumping the pixel count.
There's just no precedent for Apple doing this. They've never played the resolution game. Remember 15" laptops a few years ago? While Sony and other higher-end makers started cramming more pixels in each year, Apple slowly went from 1280x854 to 1440x900 and stopped there. Only in 2010 have they started to offer (and only as a BTO option!) the 1680x1050 res that you've been able to get on Vaios for years. Apple just prefers to concentrate on their antialiasing algorithms than to pump pixels.
I think a much more likely resolution bump would be 1.5x each dimension for 720x480. It'll be a little short of HTC and Motorola's 852x480, but if Apple doesn't cut the color resolution with a Bayer pattern, their display will still look better. And most importantly, it'll use less memory and run faster than a full 960x480.