Also, jumpers are cheap. Just set the jumper to enable writes, and download the update.
Are you happy with it being unknowable which of your appliances are compromised or not? Would you pay $1 more for a disk drive with firmware in ROM? I would. If you were running a banking system, would you pay extra for code in ROM that cannot be compromised?
As for IoT devices, I can't imagine average Joe or Jane prying off their smart whatever, destroying the pretty plastic casing it's hidden in, and manually setting jumpers to flash firmware.
I don't think the current scheme is working very well. Even worse, there is no way to tell if your appliance has been compromised or not. There are a lot of companies that care whether their machines are infected or not.
I think in all honesty the regulation sounds best, requiring the router makers to disable features such as UPNP would prevent massive attacks like these.
But then the device would be 'hacked' again within minutes of it coming back online.
As for the IoT, the appliances could have their firmware in ROM instead of flash. Then, the malmare would not survive a reboot. Many customers are large scale enough (Microsoft, Google, governments, etc.) that they can demand it of vendors and vendors will deliver. Really, how often do you desire to update the firmware on your hard drive, your USB stick, etc.?
(Another way to do it is to have the write-enable line controlled by a physical switch or jumper.)
The only thing I can figure is everyone has forgotten what ROM is.