News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by DannoHung on Monday April 19, 2010 @10:23AM (#1276748)
Why should you "avoid leaderboards"? No explanation under that bullet point. I like leaderboards that let me see how I've done in real games against my friends (XBox Live Arcade has a great implementation of this). What's wrong with using them in an app?
Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by wortiz on Monday April 19, 2010 @11:06AM (#1276848)
It depends on whether you want your users to compete against each other or not.

Take in example reddit trying to avoid becoming digg and hacker news trying to avoid becoming reddit, what is everyone trying to avoid? Competition for points and essentially leaderboards.

However for something like games leaderboards are essential as they can provide an incentive to keep playing.

Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by derefr on Monday April 19, 2010 @01:13PM (#1277255)
A qualification:

> However for something like games leaderboards are essential as they can provide an incentive for achievement-oriented players to keep playing.

Leaderboards will do nothing for other types of players, and may actively repel some (explorers who are given too "transparent" a view into the system through an itemized leaderboard score.)

Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by jeff18 on Monday April 19, 2010 @01:30PM (#1277306)
HackerNews has leaderboards though. http://news.ycombinator.com/lists
Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by hugh3 on Monday April 19, 2010 @01:36PM (#1277336)
Though interestingly there's no longer a link to the leaderboard on the top bar.
Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by sachinag on Monday April 19, 2010 @10:40AM (#1276788)
I get into this in some level of detail in the presentation, but the PVP mechanic of leaderboards inhibits new players/users because it's another barrier to entry. Remember why Digg killed their leaderboard - you end up with a hypercompetitive top slice. Lastly, unlike with "real" games, there's not an easy way to cordon off and on-ramp newbies.
Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by bmalicoat on Monday April 19, 2010 @10:48AM (#1276811)
Why not just show how you compare against your friends by default and have an option to change the filter to global?
Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by lotharbot on Monday April 19, 2010 @01:56PM (#1277385)
My wife and I are both hard-core gamers. We play games for all they're worth, often inventing new challenges, and on a few occasions impressing either the game designers or the relevant game communities. We both recently picked up a viral Facebook game, did some analysis and testing to create a near-optimal design, and quickly moved to the top of our local leaderboard. Most of our friends quit playing soon after.

One of the major problems with leaderboards is that they can discourage those who don't have the time, resources, or sk1llz to compete with the top of the (local or global) food chain. Restricting leaderboards to "just your friends" only resolves the issue if everyone on your local list plays at a similar level of seriousness.

Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by DannoHung on Monday April 19, 2010 @12:16PM (#1277042)
Yeah, that's the sort of leaderboard that I like. Not the global ones.

Also, it should be pretty easy to make it newb friendly: Just don't make any of the stats lifetime stats. Monthly or Weekly should be good.

Re:Don't be a douchebag: Best practices for game mechanics i... by imp on Monday April 19, 2010 @10:58AM (#1276833)
There's some discussion on that on the website for the book Building Reputations:

"Leaderboards Considered Harmful" http://buildingreputation.com/writings/2008/12/leaderboards_...