Re:Schiaparelli descent data: decoding underway
by pinewurst on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:04AM
(#12752909)
I'm not sure I agree with that argument. At least comparing specific impulses of Proton and Soyuz vehicle engines with (older, pre-Russian engined) Delta and Atlas shows the latter are often significantly higher.
That's not to say the Russians haven't done good engines but RD180 for example is derived from the Energia engines which didn't have (at least publicly) lots of trials/failures.
Re:Schiaparelli descent data: decoding underway
by mturmon on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:05PM
(#12754649)
Some of those failures happened during the faster, better, cheaper era at NASA, in which taking on more risk was not a deal-breaker. The pendulum has swung back. For more context, see: http://www.thespacereview.com/article/35/1
Re:Schiaparelli descent data: decoding underway
by btilly on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:29AM
(#12753164)
Well, SpaceX is taking the rapid prototyping/incremental improvement idea to a new level, and intends to land on Mars. Their first attempt or three are likely to fail. But would you care to bet on whether SpaceX or the US government will have successfully landed more spacecraft on Mars within 30 years?
(Elon plans to be living there long before then.)
The problem is that you can't do rapid prototyping on Mars landers, each iteration is just too expensive. This is where the US approach works better.
As for the ESA, I have no idea. Hopefully they got enough data out of the lander before it crashed to figure out what went wrong exactly.