News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by ezequiel-garzon on Thursday October 20, 2016 @06:46AM (#12751190)
As an aside, if you don't mind, how close is Sardo to Latin? Can you rather easily read Latin texts (assuming you haven't studied Latin, and are proficient in Sardo). Thanks!
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by ff_ on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:59AM (#12752200)
I speak Sardo, and I studied Latin for 5 years at High School, and I was very bad at it.

So I would say that "modern" Sardo (defining the "old" as the first written texts some centuries ago) it's close enough to Latin to see where every word comes from, but definitely too far to give you understanding.

I can understand Spanish though :) (context: we've been in the Spanish Kingdom for like 400 years, and the language have been influenced a lot, many shared words.)

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by m_mueller on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:12PM (#12756960)
How close is it to Romansh, the old raetic/latin language still spoken in Grisons, Switzerland? Could you understand them?
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by ff_ on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:12AM (#12758277)
Given that I've never been in Grisons, but I heard it only from YT, I would say that it's not very close with Sardo.

I can understand them though, but mostly because I know Italian. (Romansh also sounds to me somewhat Portuguese and Slavic at the same time, it's a very cool language).

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by m_mueller on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:52AM (#12758415)
Neat, thanks!
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by gpderetta on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:29AM (#12751396)
I do not speak Sardo, as I speak another Sardinian language, but I guess I know enough to comment. Sardo spelling is probably closer to Latin than most other romance languages and some sentences are surprisingly close to their Latin equivalent.

I would say that it still lack many Latin features (for example cases, neutral gender), and sentence construction is generally different enough that native speaker wouldn't have a significant advantage to other romance language speakers.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by phee on Thursday October 20, 2016 @10:23AM (#12752425)
> Can you rather easily read Latin texts (assuming you haven't studied Latin, and are proficient in Sardo).

I guess the statement about "closeness" comes from the study (Pei, Mario 1949) referenced in the Wikipedia page about Sardinian language that somehow developed a metric and tested several languages against their parent one. Apparently Sardo has the lowest distance from Latin among Romance languages.

On a more practical side, I speak Sardo and studied Latin in high school. I cannot easily read Latin texts without a dictionary at hand and a little grammar review. I guess their similarity arises when you compare the written languages but most of us experience Sardo as a spoken-only language and many find it difficult to follow in written form. On the contrary we experience Latin as a written only language. Who knows, probably it would be a lot easier for us to understand spoken Latin.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by SmellTheGlove on Thursday October 20, 2016 @03:51PM (#12755516)
This raises a good point. Even when languages are "close" it usually doesn't mean "mutually intelligible" unless they are really close. I grew up in the US but I have Italian parents who came over somewhat recently in immigration terms - the 1970's. My first language is/was Standard Italian, as my grandmother really pushed my parents not to teach me their dialects. My mom is from Genova and my father from a small town in Abruzzo called Alfedena - since you are Italian, you probably know, very different dialects. Zeneize is considered its own language. Anyhow, to my point, Standard Italian is extremely close to the spoken dialects in my family, probably closer than Sardo to Latin, but I still have trouble understanding either side of the family in dialect. Part of that, of course, is that I was raised outside of Italy, but not entirely as I don't have trouble with the Florentine dialect since I speak pretty close to what they do.

And don't get me started on written versus spoken! Then again, my dad's dialect might look like Welsh if anyone thought to write it down. But on my mom's side, Zeneize does have a sort-of official written form, and if I read carefully I sometimes have an idea of what's going on :)

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by mattrichardson on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:43AM (#12751478)
My girlfriend is Sardinian and speaks Sardo. She's said to me in the past that it's fairly close to Latin, certainly closer than other languages (French/Spanish for example), but Sardo is generally a mix of Latin, Italian, with a few Spanish words.

Also worth noting there are different dialects of Sardo (such as Logudorese, in the north, if I remember the name correctly). And some dialects are closer to Latin than others.

In Italy/Sardinia dialects can be so far apart from one another that it's difficult to understand one another.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by invernomut0 on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:59AM (#12751541)
Some of the dialects are so far apart that they are actual languages distinct from Italian. If you search in the ISO list of languages[0] you can find neapolitan, sardinian as distinct languages different from italian.

[0]http://www.loc.gov/standards/iso639-2/php/English_list.php

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by mattrichardson on Thursday October 20, 2016 @08:50AM (#12751763)
Sardinian (Sardo) is a separate language, not a dialect of Italian. Road signs (town/city names) in Sardinia are often in both Sardo and Italian. You can think of it like the difference between Welsh/English.
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by zeveb on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:25PM (#12754266)
> You can think of it like the difference between Welsh/English.

I don't think that's quite right: Welsh is a Gaelic language and English is Germanic, so they're from different families, while Sardinian & Italian are much more closely related.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by rat87 on Saturday October 22, 2016 @06:22PM (#12770831)
Possibly more like Scots language(not Scottish Gaelic) and English

http://www.ayecan.com/read_scots/burns_museum.html

> Though his position in society wis ower laich for him tae hae the richt tae vote, Robert wis nanetheless passionate aboot politics and made his writin desk his ballot box. Scunnerin the weel-daein and pooerfu, hooanever could prove a fykie business.

> Robert Burns loved the lassies. He fell in love aften an wi ease, and wi mony weemun frae a wheen o backgrunds. The wey he treatit his lovers wis different ilka time, and ilka relationship affected Robert in its ain weys.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by davidw on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:28PM (#12753772)
Sardinian and Italian are much much closer than Welsh and English. Speaking Italian, I can make out written Sardo kinda sorta ok, and I'm not a native Italian speaker. As an English speaker, I can't make heads or tales of Welsh.
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by acjohnson55 on Thursday October 20, 2016 @08:58AM (#12751802)
Italy has only been a united country for about 150 years, so it hasn't been that long since Italian (as we know it today) is widely spoken. Previously, people tended to speak their local Romance language. See the intro and history sections of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian language.
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by davidw on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:06PM (#12753533)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sardinian_language has some information.

Beyond that, it frankly just "looks" a bit more latin, with s's at the end of words for plurals, and more u's than Italian has.

I think it also has fewer loan words, and has staid in some cases closer to older Latin words: 'domu' for house rather than 'casa'.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by bitbandit on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:07AM (#12751840)
Sardo is about as close to Latin as Italian, Castilian, and Catalan.

BTW Sardo is actually not one language, but a set of languages spoken in the island.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by umanwizard on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:17AM (#12751330)
I've never heard of this language, is it specially known for being particularly close to Latin or something? Why would you expect it to be any more mutually intelligible with Latin than any other modern Latin dialect is? (I mean French, Spanish, etc.)
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by mhb on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:23AM (#12751372)
From TFA: Residents here still speak Sardo, the closest living form of Latin.
Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by umanwizard on Thursday October 20, 2016 @08:33AM (#12751679)
Ah, I must have skimmed it too quickly to notice that. Thanks!

Anyway, I doubt it is close enough to Latin to be mutually intelligible, as all modern Romance languages are derived from Vulgar Latin, which is known to be very different form the written Classical Latin.

Re:Italy’s rarest pasta by acjohnson55 on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:07AM (#12751841)
There are lots of languages you've probably never heard of :). I realized the same when I started to read about the family of Romance languages to learn what the concept was all about. Not being an expert, it does seem to me to be a theme that languages of relatively isolated communities tend to me significantly more conservative in their evolution than in more cosmopolitan communities.