News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by ThomPete on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:05AM (#12743837)
It’s true that many designers tend to look at text more like a texture. Instead of making it large and distinct they will make it small and light colored when it's in fact the only valuable thing on the screen.

It's an unfortunate consequence of so much design today going minimal and more typographic, which makes it's hard to differentiate elements any other way than to start evening out the contrast. If everything that is text was just black you would loose the hierarchy.

There er of course plenty of ways to get around it and most experienced designers know how to deal with it. I don't think it's going to be a lasting problem though.

Also important to notice that retina screens make a big difference between what is readable and not. You can get away with much more finesse when you design for retina screens. And I think a lot of designers unfortunately use only that when they design.

If you look at print typography you will find a lot of small text sizes because print is crisp enough to be readable. So technology will take care of most of it IMO.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by onli on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @12:33PM (#12745263)
> Instead of making it large and distinct they will make it small and light colored when it's in fact the only valuable thing on the screen.

But modern web design is the contrary. Large big webfonts, distinct ones for headlines and text as beautiful as possible. Yes, sometimes the text is then made grey and oftentimes this is just bad design, but I don't think the texture comaprision is accurate.

Here for example, in the appengine dashboard screenshots, the grey text in the menu is used to create hierarchy. I would also argue that the greying of the text has another function here: By making most of the menu labels less visible, you can focus the attention to the parts of the page that are the most prominent. Not sure hat worked very well sincethat does nto seem to be used here, but it sure has another effect than the prior design where almostevery element was screaming for attention.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by flukus on Thursday October 20, 2016 @02:34AM (#12750142)
> Large big webfonts

This can be aggravating too, just because I'm on a desktop doesn't mean I have 19" monitors and the browser maximized.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by onli on Thursday October 20, 2016 @04:31AM (#12750592)
19" monitors are like the smallest you can still buy, and have been for some years. But sure, Browsers are not always maximized, and there are small laptops and tablets and smartphones… but modern webdesign has with responsive design really a good answer here that takes that into account, and that also considers the font size. So yes, that can be aggravating, but not in modern webdesign per se, only in bad design in general.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by liveoneggs on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:22PM (#12745703)
> Large big webfonts

I think you're confusing filesize with font size. :)

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by onli on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @03:12PM (#12746789)
;) That only as well. I mean, just look at https://www.apple.com/iphone/. The page is defined by images and big headlines.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by smrtinsert on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:17AM (#12744520)
Most designers are frankly awful at typography. I would argue most design elements on a page can be simply removed if they properly used hierarchy of text to call out important areas for example.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by ThomPete on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:33AM (#12744674)
Sure just like you don't need insane convoluted frameworks with a billion dependencies to develop 99% of the web-apps out there yet thats what most developers end up with.

This is about self-expression and it's a small price to pay (and easily fixable by just forcing your own style sheet) for getting a vibrant and diverse jungle of content and ways to express it. The rest we can deal with.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by zeveb on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:16PM (#12745645)
> This is about self-expression and it's a small price to pay

Is that a small price to pay for worsening the experience of anyone older than maybe 26? I can't even imagine trying to walk my elderly neighbour through installing her own stylesheet, nor trying to explain why none of her sites look right now, even if they are more legible.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by ThomPete on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:23PM (#12745705)
It's not that simple. If you don't experiment, make mistakes etc. you don't grow.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by digi_owl on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:32PM (#12745795)
At the other end, if we don't learn form history we are stuck repeating it.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by ThomPete on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:10PM (#12746192)
We did learn from history. Go back 15 years the web look wastely different and has actually improved quite a lot.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by Silhouette on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:34PM (#12748659)
Go back 15 years the web look wastely different and has actually improved quite a lot.

It's certainly very different. Whether it has improved a lot is debatable.

Perhaps more relevant is that I don't think there is any doubt that the web of today is worse than the web of five years ago. The majority of the browser plugins I routinely use today exist entirely to undo some part of that damage, and that includes having a custom stylesheet set up for almost every major web site I use.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by adrianratnapala on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:35AM (#12749938)
15-20 years ago, GUI interfaces tended to suck, generally because you kept having to click through confirmations and do other such mouse dances. Nowadays UIs try to get out of your way more. Good.

But in those days, web-sites were actually better. HTML limited the in-your-face interactivity that spoiled the rest of the desktop.

People who wanted to put truly awful UI on the web had to use Flash. Now they don't.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by digi_owl on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:49PM (#12746566)
Jonstokes' rant further up seems to indicate otherwise...
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by ThomPete on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @03:11PM (#12746783)
It's a rant not the truth. There are plenty of well designed websites out there which doesn't actually make those mistakes and I believe the rant to be saturating the actual reality.

Pointing to a few examples are nothing but anecdotal evidence.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by knieveltech on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:40PM (#12747936)
Check your ageism bub. Some of us have been online longer than you've been alive.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by zeveb on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:11PM (#12748158)
Ummm, I'm sure you're technically correct about there being folks here who were online before I was born (although there almost certainly aren't a whole lot — I'm pretty old), but my comment was against discriminating against folks based on age-related conditions like declining eyesight.

If you're annoyed that I used my elderly neighbour as an example of someone I wouldn't want to explain stylesheets to: she is an actual person, not a rhetorical device; she's a smart person, but not gifted with computers; she has failing eyesight; I help her with computer questions; I honestly wouldn't want to try to explain custom stylesheets to her.

It'd be better if folks would build accessible pages from the get-go.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by knieveltech on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:56PM (#12749115)
Thank you for clarifying your position.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by wott on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:38PM (#12749442)
? They all look the same. White, white, and more white.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by jalfresi on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @12:06PM (#12745030)
"If everything that is text was just black you would loose the hierarchy"

Nonsense. Type weights exist for this, as does size, grouping, placement etc.

Typography IS hierarchy.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by cooper12 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:26PM (#12746322)
Also relevant is the typography concept of "color": http://practicaltypography.com/color.html.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by eriknstr on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:42PM (#12749047)
That website is currently not loading for me.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by cooper12 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:28PM (#12749413)
Ah it seems to redirect HN users to [0]. Sorry, it worked in my search so I didn't know about that. You can just search for "color typography" and read an alternate link or try clicking into that one from Google/the address bar mode since it seems to rely on reading the referrer. On a sidenote, the whole book is great so if you do read it and find it useful, I would pay for it.

[0]: http://practicaltypography.com/graylist.html

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by eriknstr on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:41AM (#12751456)
When I wrote the comment it wasn't even redirecting -- it was plain not loading at all. It's loading now, albeit with the redirect you mentioned. Guy's got a point in a way and he's free to do as he wishes with his own content of course but still I don't like those kinds of redirects, since I am not planing on reading the whole book anyway, just the particular page you linked. Also, if he wanted me to pay for the book, he should provide me with an ePub copy of the book. If I don't get a copy then it is absolutely certain I'm not paying for it. I don't read books on my monitor, I read them on my eReader, and only in DRM-free ePub. Author of the page is never going to see this comment but I felt like expressing this anyway.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by cfjgvjh on Thursday October 20, 2016 @03:09AM (#12750261)
That's one of the most exciting things I've seen all week. Thank you very much. I'm sure I'll enjoy reading it.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by ThomPete on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:22PM (#12745699)
Sure but that doesn't mean it's used as that.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by the_other on Thursday October 20, 2016 @07:35AM (#12751423)
To echo your point, the screen shots from the original article bare this out. The new App Engine interface does express information hierarchy through type, but it does so badly. The side menu uses all three of spacing, text size and colour to indicate hierarchy, to the point where the lower-level items are nearly illegible. Skimming it, I got the feeling the designer was saying "You don't need this", rather than "You won't need this often" or "Y is a specialisation of X" (which was probably the intent).
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by monknomo on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:43PM (#12749050)
Every designer, or UI/UX person should work on a shitty CRT with a flicker and a bad green channel.

If the design doesn't work under those conditions, it doesn't work.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by dozzie on Thursday October 20, 2016 @12:21PM (#12753698)
Similar thing stands for programmers: they should work on workstations with 1GB RAM and Pentium 4 or older. If their code doesn't work well in this environment, it shouldn't be put into production. Especially if these programmers write for web.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by monknomo on Monday October 24, 2016 @08:24PM (#12784141)
omg, yes
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by mercurysmessage on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:39AM (#12744165)
I'm assuming that by retina screen you simply mean high resolution? Because Retina display is just the apple term for a high resolution screen.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by sthatipamala on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:48AM (#12744249)
Its actually their term for high DPI displays. If you want to be pedantic, at least be correct.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by DavidWanjiru on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:36AM (#12744709)
Speaking of pedantic, what is the difference between "high resolution screens" and "high DPI screens"? Assuming, of course, that screen and display mean the same thing.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by lemmings19 on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @12:04PM (#12745012)
High DPI refers to a high pixel density. High resolution refers many pixels.

If I have one million pixels on a 10cm by 10cm screen, and one million pixels on a 100cm by 100cm screen, they both have the same resolution because they both have the same number of pixels.

However, the 10cm screen has a much higher pixel density because the pixels are much smaller and closer together in order to fit on such a small surface.

The effect of a high pixel density is that you cannot tell pixels apart because they are so small and clustered, even up close. This results in a much more fine looking image.

'Retina' is just a marketing term for high DPI displays.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by adrianratnapala on Thursday October 20, 2016 @01:42AM (#12749958)
> High resolution refers many pixels.

That's correct, but only within our narrow jargon.

In optics, when I say "resolution", I mean the smallest distance (either angular or linear) beween two points that can be distinguished by the apperatus. E.g. "The CCD resolution is 10 microns per pixel". Not how many distinct points there are ("The CCD has 1024x786 pixels").

Sometime in the computer age, "resolution" became used for the latter meaning and so DPI had to be used where "resolution" was previously meant.

But don't blame people if they still use the original meaning.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by jasode on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:54AM (#12744909)
2560x1440 is ~109 dpi when the pixels are arranged to fill a 27" monitor. (This is not considered "Retina".)

2560x1440 is ~500 dpi when the pixels are squeezed into a 6" phone display such as as Google Nexus 6/6P.

The "Retina" description refers to the dpi exceeding 300 dpi and not the absolute # of pixels.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by mordocai on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:52AM (#12744889)
Resolution is how many pixels per the entire screen. DPI is how many pixels per a inch.

For instance, a high resolution 4k TV that is 50" might not be considered high DPI compared to a 4k 15" laptop screen.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by Crespyl on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @12:02PM (#12744994)
"High resolution" could mean any display >= 1080p or so, whatever size (6 inches, or 6 feet).

DPI, being "dots per inch" relates to resolution for a given physical size, so a "low resolution" 720p display that was only 1 inch across would have a high DPI (in this case, 720 dots per inch), but a "high resolution" 4k display at 50 feet across would have a low DPI.

Generally speaking, the higher the DPI the harder it is to discern individual pixels, and the better for viewing fine details.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by andrewmu on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @11:54AM (#12744908)
High resolution screens have lots of pixels and high DPI screens have many pixels per inch.

If you look at an Ultra HD (3840x2180) 40" TV close up versus a 5" phone screen (say 1334x750) viewed from the same distance you'll notice the phone screen is sharper despite having fewer pixels.

Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by mercurysmessage on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @12:19PM (#12745147)
Right, my mistake.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable by andrepd on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @10:34PM (#12749433)
"Retina" screen is an Apple marketing term. Would you care to specify exactly what you mean by that?