I am with you on this one. No iPhone/iPad for me and I try talk anyone out of it if I think they do not know yet what the AppStore-necessity means for customers and developers. But I would still recommend Macs until Apple decides to make an AppStore mandatory for them too. When that happens I will have to switch (probably to Linux). That makes me sad.
> boycotting the company completely might have been more effective
Effective at what? Making you less productive?
They don't give a shit about whatever "message" you're trying to send them. No company actually listens to the histrionics of their customers like that, least of all Apple.
Still, when I needed a new laptop, I purchased a recently-refreshed MacBook Pro. Though boycotting the company completely might have been more effective, I still think that my decision to get the MacBook over the iPad (or over nothing at all) sends a message that customers still appreciate the openness of the Mac platform.
And it is open - the author of the article talks about installing Linux on his MacBook. If the Mac line were not open, this wouldn't even be possible - just look at how little progress has been made on getting Linux/Android on the iPhone hardware. And on Mac OS X there's also a complete lack of an app review process - I can install any app no matter if it's interpreted or compiled, written in Objective-C or not, and whether or not Apple personally approves of it.
It's important to let Apple know what they're doing right in addition to admonishing them for what they're doing wrong.