News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by danso on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:50PM (#12730893)
It speaks to the clusterfuck that NMS became that this detailed blog post is written by a fan reverse-engineering the code/content, rather than someone from Hello Games doing a post-mortem on Gamasutra who can speak with more authority. I'm not knocking the author's attempt at reverse-engineering -- in fact, it's awesome on a geek level because reverse-engineering is an additional technical hoop to understanding a game's core. It's just that when a game has as much hype and sales as NMS does, usually the creators would be the ones to do a technical post about how clever they were.

But the mention of the diplodocus is just one example of how much of a clusterfuck NMS is: The diplodocus and other beautiful dinosaurs were part of the E3 demo that was presented to fans as NMS's procedural code in action. And, as the author notes, it doesn't appear to be something that actually was procedurally generated, but was hand-designed to make the E3 demo footage look good (and, to Hello Games's shame, they used this footage as the official advertising for NMS, even after release).

Here's one of the canonical parodies of the shady shit Hello Games pulled: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RvAwB7ogkik

edit: grammar fixes

Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by randomacct44 on Monday October 17, 2016 @08:10PM (#12730983)
The utterly stupid thing is that the hype is what killed the game. Of course, then I guess they wouldn't have been able to charge AAA price for it and get away with it :/

I'm a fan of the space sim / massive universe concept and pretty much ignored most of the NMS hype, so I had no expectations going in. What I found when I did go in was an immediately recognizable game that I'd describe as Elite + Noctis with modern graphics. Which is fine, really. Particularly, anyone that loved playing Noctis would love playing NMS.

The problem is that price tag and the hype though. The game just doesn't have the staying power. I'd feel a bit better about the price tag if the studio communicated what they're doing more. I don't mind paying that price for a game in and of itself - games are expensive to make and I kinda hate the race-to-the-bottom that gives us things like freemium. However at this point, NMS feels abandoned by the studio and that's disappointing.

Jim Sterling did two excellent videos exploring the gaming hype culture and what everyone's roles were in this mess (the studio, Sony, the games press at large and the gaming public). They're worth watching in order for anyone that hasn't seen them:

Sky Hype (The Jimquisition): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_HEI8ZfDbM&t=847s

A Video Discussing Whether Or Not Hello Games Lied About No Man's Sky (The Jimquisition): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2qKAX_QaoI&t=72s

Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by gambiting on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @04:28AM (#12732900)
As someone who works in the games industry - what is shown at E3 usually doesn't even exist in the game yet, and is usually directed by hand, unless the release of the game is like a month away(in which case, the game was already sent to submission some time before). In some cases whole features only exist as a design draft, but are still in the E3 demo because that's what we want to achieve in the end. So showing "procedural content" that was assembled by hand is not really dishonest if that's what you want your procedural code to generate after you are done with the game. It's a bit like showing a new model of a car, but cars shown at car shows are almost always assembled by hand, because the factories are not set up to build them yet - which means that once the actual assembly process kicks in, the final product might look different than what you saw at a car show. Doesn't change the fact that the model shown at a car show is what the manufacturer wants to achieve.
Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by supercoder on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @09:07AM (#12733962)
The 14 year olds on Reddit have really been struggling with this fact
Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by ClassyJacket on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @09:35AM (#12734145)
No, it's a perfectly valid criticism. Saying "well we intended to make that!" isn't an excuse for not delivering what you advertised.
Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by gambiting on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @10:11AM (#12734450)
I don't know if it is. If something is shown on the box or TV ad, but isn't actually in the game, then yeah, fair enough. But a presentation at E3, which is basically saying "hey, this is the game we are working on" is not really an advertisment.

It's the same as watching early trailers of any film - some scenes are removed, some changed, sometimes dialogue is re-recorded, effects added, and the final film looks differently to the trailer. It's not false advertising - it's just that either technical or political reasons get in the way.

Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by shepardrtc on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:54PM (#12736383)
You're absolutely correct for 99% of games, but for this one they really talked it up at E3 that that was exactly how the game was going to be. They repeatedly and pointedly said over and over again that everything you saw was legit and randomly generated. I'm almost 100% positive they even said specifically that it wasn't scripted.
Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by soft_dev_person on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @10:11AM (#12734453)
It's almost surreal reading this. I've been mostly out of the gaming scene for years, just sporadically playing some Kingdom Hearts and Final Fantasy.

I just recently got a gift card and bought myself the PS4. Got No Man's Sky for an OK price, and had absolutely no expectations since I haven't followed game news whatsoever.

The result is I really love NMS. Its pace is perfect for me (I usually hate FPS, or first person games in general). It's about exploration and seeing new things and getting that sense of freedom to travel wherever you want in a massive space. I think they do that very well.

Yet, it's apparently a "clusterfuck". So weird.

To be critical, there is mostly two things that is somewhat of an annoyance, and that is too limited inventory space, making inventory management a too large part of the game, and the apparent lack of variety in buildings and structures. I say apparent, as I haven't explored that much of it yet, but until now all spacestations have had the same entrance interior, which is a bit boring. So yes, some things are repetitive.

But, still a good game. If anyone has skipped it due to negative reviews based on hype, please take another look and make up your own mind. Maybe your expectations will be more appropriate now.

Re:No Man’s Sky – Procedural Content by shepardrtc on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:50PM (#12736330)
I was like you, and at first I enjoyed it a bit. But then I realized that the game only has one goal: get resources to fly to the next planet. That's it. Nothing else. And then you start to see how 90% of your time is simply getting resources to the fly to the next planet to get resources to fly to the next planet to get resources to fly to the next planet, etc. Its a procedural terrain generation tool with heavy-handed resource gathering. Your ship can only lift off the ground a few times before needing to be refueled. Its absolutely ridiculous. All of my time spent was getting fuel to get more fuel. The creatures are a joke. The weapons and gear are a joke. There's no point to bothering with that. The ships are a joke. You don't really fly it so why bother? If you could really fly through the planet on your own and not have to worry so much about fuel, I could totally see your point. But the game is just so heavy that I can't take time to enjoy anything. They literally put your ship on rails when you get to a planet.

If anyone has skipped this game because of negative reviews, be grateful that you didn't waste your time or money. Its a terrible game after a few hours. The dev team absolutely lied about it.

Oh and as a side note, before the first patch, you could use your "afterburners" to fly quickly over a planet from place to place. But then Hello Games shut that down so you have to either take your time or fly out into space and then fly back down. Its a time sink.