The whole way the court was set up was a mess. The 2005 Mental Health Act was shoddy legislation, and created the Court, which was also set up shoddily. Labour almost immediately lost an outrageous ECR case and had to amend the the Act in 07 or 08. I think there might be another going through the ECR.
There have been endless complaints about it's operation, with reports going back years, in all political flavours of the media. So I for one welcome what the Telegraph, Christopher Booker and the judge are doing. The Telegraph is not my usual choice of view or politics.
All the cases except the most recent have been extensively reported.
Were it on climate change or one of the other Torygraph axes being ground, I'd agree with your critique, I don't think it really fits here.
The Mental Capacity Act. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2005/9/contents
There are some problems with the mental health act, but they are different bits of law.
In any case source caution is also worthwhile. I welcome that more investigators and actors are interested in this.
If you want to challenge the story, present other sources with the other view point. Don't go after one messenger, and use prior bad or not-bad acts to cast the journalist in a negative light. That's very not helpful.
Yes yes, a series of bad journalism can show a pattern and that's how prosecutors go after organized crimes and serial killers. But don't pretend there are bias and unbias journalists. Everyone has a bias. Most of what we see is propaganda and not news.
I really hate to do this, but this one drives me nuts (and I have no idea how people make the mistake): it's biased and unbiased.
It doesn't have anything to do with liberal or conservative. It has to do with being educated and drawing reasonable conclusions about the world.
Such as that you believe that climate is changing not because of CO2 levels but rather due to other atmospheric gases or pollutants, or the sun's emissions, etc.
Or maybe you believe that the models being used are politically driven (which is a provable fact BTW).
You can still agree that there is a problem, but you just don't agree on the causes 100% or the solutions 100%.
So unless you know the specifics of what this person is not agreeing with you on, it is a meaningless and non-relevant label.
We're not all good liberals, here.
And even though I'm diametrically opposed to their politics, I don't discount stories which appear in the Manchester Guardian, just because they're in the Guardian.
This really isn't a liberal or conservative thing; while it's not a Daily Mail I'm often skeptical about The Guardian as well. Actually I was a little surprised to see the Wall Street Journal in the OP list because I thought they had a pretty decent reputation for quality reporting. The main complaint I've heard about Mr. Murdoch's ownership is more that he tried to add too much general interest stories in an effort to attract non-business readers, not that he's tabloid-ized the Journal.
For this article, it was pretty easy to Google a blog of a family lawyer / barrister who added quite a number of counterpoints to one of the cases. (http://www.pinktape.co.uk/cases/i-am-calm/). Whether you agree or not with her counterpoint and what happened within the cases, I personally found the blog article more sober and with more data backing it. You knew you were in trouble even with the headline of the Telegraph article. (Britain's "most secret court"? Citation needed!)
The problem I've found with most sensational articles is this sort of pattern: light on facts, heavy on emotion, many weasel words designed to tug your heartstrings that probably aren't justified. They usually aren't worth reading.
People need to be aware of biases no matter what their personal politics are.
[
There are a decent number of factual refutions of Booker's claims in several past cases.
I'm merely curious - can you explain this reference to a US native?
Colnels. How to explain. It's the kind of person who flies a Union Jack from a pole attached to their garden shed. They probably think it's ridiculous political correctness that we don't still celebrate Empire Day.
As with all such derogatory epithets, the wielder either doesn't realise how powerfully and instantly doing so undermines their chances of changing hearts & minds, or doesn't care because they only wish to preach to their own choir.
This is not true. If you care about truth, stop spreading this myth. If you care about science, stop spreading this myth--it is like a termite eating away at the foundation of science itself.
In this case, some of his cases (and there are many articles, and they are worth a read) appear to be for good reason, and rthere will be some substance to some of them; but we don't know - which is partly why he rails against them. However, it is clear that he doesn't bring all the facts to our attention (like why the authorities may have had courts rule against unfit, manipulative and dangerous family members). Nonetheless, there is likely significant merit in at least some of his qualms.
Dig deeper using other sources, before coming to premature judgements. These stories are designed, DailyFail-style, to tug at your heartstrings. It's also worth knowing that The Daily Telegraph has always been the UK Rightwing broadsheet, but has since its change of ownership in recent years, turned more to Daily Mail-like reporting and sensationalism. IT has also taken a hard turn to the neoliberal Far-Right (think Brexit), and so you should take its stories with as much caution as perhaps the 'Washington Times', and worse than Murdoch's WSJ. It's not yet as bad as Beitbart, as it still advertises to octogenarian Colonels in Tunbridge Wells, but that may change.