This is a crucial point, because it shows GitLab is basically nonresponsive to the key issue; it's the difference between "Here's how to hack Giant Anchor Retailer" (unethical, possibly illegal) and "Giant Anchor Retailer has been hacked, estimated NNN cards may have been compromised" (of public interest, not illegal). In my case, I want to know if I used any of the retailers on the list!
For GitLab to call this "egregious" and that they "will not abide it" suggests that either GitLab is technically incompetent in security matters, or that they've received legal notices and decided that the shortest path to resolution is to throw their users under the nearest publicly-operated multiwheeled passenger conveyance. In either case, poor show, good reason to seriously consider moving off GH and GL.
You may exercise freedom of speech but not on server that belongs to a private company - it is their right to limit what kind of content they like.
But in an essence you are right - companies should exist to benefit society, but it is not how it exactly works right now.
Lots of people are saying "But the sites are already exploited" ... they are probably still exploitable further also, and GH/GL don't want to be at that party.
This is not about whether they are legally required to do anything, but whether what they are doing is responsible behavior.
As for being responsible - that is their motivation.
Should I assume that now you have access to this list that you will be contacting the site owners to notify them their sites are infected & exploitable? Would that be responsible on your part?
Their servers, and their decision on what data is on them.
Want to make it available for every to read? Run your own server and host it there.
tl;dr - you have the right to say what you want, but you cant force anyone to listen.
https://github.com/prettydiff/biddle
This is not a CVS, so you would still need to run something like git locally on your own server, but the idea of self-hosted modules will solve for the censorship of central authorities.
Github/-lab is for projects imho and not a publishing platform. Why don't you publish it on your blog or something? All power to Github/-lab, kick out such stuff!
---
Willem,
GitLab has opted to remove the list of servers that you posted in your snippet. GitLab views the exposure of the vulnerable systems as egregious and will not abide it. While GiLab reserves the right take further action, up to and including termination (https://about.gitlab.com/terms/), we have chosen not to terminate or lock your account.
Please know this decision was not reached lightly and we appreciate your understanding on the matter.
Regards, GitLab
GitLab Support Team GitLab, Inc.