News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by mcphage on Saturday October 15, 2016 @12:08AM (#12712660)
Getting rid of all organizational secrecy seems like a pretty bad goal—it makes negotiation impossible.
Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by dmix on Saturday October 15, 2016 @12:57AM (#12712773)
Bad for whom? Those benefiting from the negotiation results?

The problem is that with secrecy the latter has historically tendend not to be the public who the negotiators are supposed to represent. See TPP or if you're from EU/Canada see CETA for the rewards of secret negotiations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comprehensive_Economic_and_Tra...

Once trust erodes in the state these leaks tend to happen such as in the Iraq war post WMD debacle with the Manning leaks, or NSA preceding Snowden leaks, outcry over TTP negotiations, etc, etc, there is a real positive incentive in transparency over the benefits that come from secrecy. Otherwise the government has a habit of losing sight of whose interests they are supposed to be representing.

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by smallnamespace on Saturday October 15, 2016 @01:17AM (#12712831)
> Bad for whom? Those benefiting from the negotiation results?

Bad for everyone involved. Not every deal is bad, and deals often can happen only because good gets packaged with the bad.

If every negotiation happened in public, no nations would ever be able to sign agreements with one another. That's a recipe for paralysis and disaster.

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by rlucas on Saturday October 15, 2016 @11:51AM (#12714384)
The Assange thesis isn't a binary option, secrets or no secrets. It's raising the cost of pervasive and wide ranging secrecy.

A wikileaks world doesn't mean you can't keep your nuclear launch codes safe, something for which you are presumably ready to spend major resources with tight control in a small circle.

It just means that you now have to spend more effort keeping all your petty graft secret at the low end, and it reduces toward zero the probability that a large manpower intensive conspiracy can work, in the more important democidal case.

So, the thesis holds, the powers inclined toward malfeasance will have a little nudge at every choice point, toward the option they won't mind being discovered. Like a surveillance camera pointed at the minimum wage cashier's hands, except at the people who control nation-states.

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by smallnamespace on Saturday October 15, 2016 @02:44PM (#12715160)
> It just means that you now have to spend more effort keeping all your petty graft secret at the low end

The problem is that secrecy doesn't purely serve 'petty graft', but also allows politicians to actually make deals and get things done.

The thesis that 'raising the cost of secrecy' is always a good thing is unproven. Plus, Assange et al are less a neutral information source, but rather an active participant in politics with their own, hidden motivations.

Over the last 30 years, we've repeatedly seen the reform of politics in the US aimed at eliminating graft and taking power away from politicians and putting it in the hands of voters. Over the same period of time, politics here as gotten more and more dysfunctional.

Relevant: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/07/how-amer...

I submit that voters are often unable to effectively make compromises and form voting blocs with others. It used to fall to politicians to negotiate behind closed doors to hash out a deal. In Assange's secret-less world, that won't be possible.

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by rlucas on Saturday October 15, 2016 @06:25PM (#12715908)
Agreed, of course that even relatively mundane secrecy can serve a public interest; nuclear codes are not the only legitimate secrets.

And it's very fair to say that it's unknown if the Wikileaks cost-of-secrecy effect is a net good one, especially when you're starting with reasonably good institutions, civil society, and rule of law.

But it's a straw man argument to wrap up with reference to "Assange's secret-less world". My original point holds, this isn't a binary switch that flips, it's an incremental effect.

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by dmix on Saturday October 15, 2016 @02:42AM (#12713001)
> only because good gets packaged with the bad.

Particularly when the packaging is done without scrutiny. Or waiting for scrutiny until after the fact where it becomes a black or white proposal... past the negotiation stage where details are debated. The public is left to mearly accept or deny it.

Just look at CETA, a particularly harmful clause was dropped only after they were called out for lacking transparency and decided to respond to the public uproar. Even with that minor revision the whole deal is at risk of totally failing because it contains too many controversial sections to pass each EU legislatior. Had they considered and included the public years earlier, rather than focusing just on the vested parties in backroom negotiation, this could have been avoided.

The public shouldnt have to fight tooth and nail be listened to.

If they were capable of making good deals in secret in a way that maintained the public trust then I'd otherwise completely agree with you. Because it's inefficient otherwise. But given the string of policies that came out recently, trust clearly has eroded and these types of deals are a good example of why.

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by dingaling on Saturday October 15, 2016 @08:22AM (#12713717)
> If every negotiation happened in public, no nations would ever be able to sign agreements with one another.

I don't see that as a definite conclusion.

At present, the status quo for most nations is that they secretly negotiate an agreement and then either (1) put it to public plebiscite or (2) pass it into law through legislative assembly.

Both cases usually result in the details of the agreement being made public before they become law, including the "bad bits", so for what reason would moving that public visibility back in time scupper all negotiations?

There would be media interest in and hype around the negotiations, naturally, but if the existing systems already prevent public intervention in those stages then it's just making them "read-only" instead of "encrypted".

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by smallnamespace on Saturday October 15, 2016 @02:37PM (#12715123)
In practice, small interest groups mobilize much more quickly and effectively than larger groups.

Imagine there's a that would weakly benefit 95% of society, but negatively impact 5%, but the net tradeoff is positive.

It's already somewhat difficult to pass these sorts of agreements, because if that 5% is an organized interest group with broad public sympathy, they will blast the media with negative media coverage.

Now imagine that a negative provision for that group was being considered while the agreement hadn't even been finalized. Then everyone only sees the downside for that group, without seeing that the final agreement is generally positive.

Public negotiations will effectively magnify the veto power of small interest groups, making agreements much more difficult to pass.

Note that this also applies to laws in general, since they're often a negotiating between parties or within parties. Do you think it would be beneficial if every private communication between legislators was made public?

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by enraged_camel on Saturday October 15, 2016 @01:35AM (#12712882)
"People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public."

- Adam Smith

Re:Want to Know Julian Assange’s Endgame? He Told You a Deca... by DominikR on Saturday October 15, 2016 @03:39PM (#12715355)
I believe it is about hiding illegal actions. (Whistleblowing) I don't think WikiLeaks has ever dumped data that exclusively contained irrelevant info about normal and legal actions.