News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by WhitneyLand on Friday October 14, 2016 @07:46PM (#12711877)
I don't agree with the ban, but it seems like the risks of kratom are not discussed, and in fact even downplayed by saying hey, it's just a plant.

To help me be an informed reader I would like WaPo to mention:

1) If you search kratom withdrawal there are a ton of anecdotal reports that sound pretty unpleasant if not debilitating.

2) What is the frequency of severe side effects, as best as can be known?

3) That "natural" substances or "plants" are not always safe. This misconception is so common and dangerous it shouldn't be used to mock the ban (real logic will suffice). https://web.stanford.edu/~jpc/overture.htm

There are plenty of valid reasons to argue against a ban. For example the chill on research, the low rate of fatalities, the likelihood it will make use more dangerous, and the probability a ban would have no net benefits.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by rms on Friday October 14, 2016 @08:15PM (#12711990)
Kratom withdrawal is unpleasant. Debilitating withdrawal is uncommon in people that aren't taking heroic doses to self medicate their addictions to other opiates, therefore punting the withdrawal symptoms down the road. Acute kratom withdrawal is shorter than for long acting pharmaceutical opiates, but post acute withdrawal syndrome (PAWS) can be dragged out because kratom has some poorly documented and poorly understood non-opiate-related antidepressant actions. It has unusually complicated pharmacology with interesting combinations of conflicting, competing, and synergistic mechanisms.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BwMPT92bOJKdZWM2bzlLeU5DdDg... is the letter from the American Kratom Association to the DEA, which compares the number of kratom related calls to poison control centers to calls related to supplements. Kratom seems to be at about the same level as ginkgo biloba and better tolerated than St. John's Wort.

This is surprising, and has resulted in weird errors in literature reviews on kratom, that I've spent dozens of hours trying to unpack during my efforts to improve the Wikipedia article.

Kratom seems to have a really surprisingly low incidence of severe side effects. The state of the information out there is weird. Something like someone said "Kratom is a mu opioid agonist and mu opioid agonists cause respiratory depression" in a peer reviewed paper, which then got cited in a medical textbook as "Kratom causes respiratory depression". However, primary research in mice shows that kratom causes dramatically less respiratory depression than poppy derived opioids. No case of kratom related respiratory depression has actually been documented in a human. In my comprehensive review of the literature, there was someone who had a seizure and was intubated but still had respiration in the normal range. Someone else suffered aspiration pneumonia in response to (inhaling?) kratom, but aspiration pneumonia is not respiratory depression.

Basically, kratom does have side effects, and real side effects, but when looked at as a population level public health problem, is profoundly safe for how powerful of an effect it actually has.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by darpa_escapee on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:20PM (#12712229)
I, unfortunately, have extensive experience with kratom and kratom extracts. Today, I am 5 years clean of kratom and all narcotics.

I bought the "kratom is non-addictive and can improve your life" line fully as a teenager. What ensued was indistinguishable from a full blown opiate addiction. I ended up in in-patient detox to finally quit and, five years later, have not regained all that I had lost during that time.

Just because kratom has a high threshold for overdose does not mean it is not an opioid.

Edit: Keaton != Kratom

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by rms on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:25PM (#12712255)
Absolutely. Propaganda from both sides of the debate results in confusing and sometimes harmful information. I don't claim that kratom is without harm. I claim that from a public health perspective, kratom reduces harm by trading off with drugs that cause more harm.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by spaces_____ on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:34PM (#12712297)
I only have about 4 years off and on experience with powdered leaf but would never touch the extracts. It is similar to the difference between having a single beer and drinking vodka straight from the bottle.

Kratom has helped me a lot with sticking to an exercise routine and sleep. I try to never exceed 8 grams of powdered leaf a day. When I hit that, I taper off and take a break for 1-2 months.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by M00n_Sl47r on Saturday October 15, 2016 @09:47AM (#12713896)
how does your tapering schedule work? If you don't mind me asking.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by spaces_____ on Sunday October 16, 2016 @07:48PM (#12721757)
When I take kratom I dose 2x a day. Drop by .25 or .50 grams for each dose. When each dose is 2 grams, I switch to dosing 3 grams 1x a day. Right before bed. Then I just taper that down at the same rate.

When I get to 0.5 grams per day, I just stop. I may sleep a little less and feel a little irritable for a few days but then it's back to normal. Working out every day and abstaining from sugary foods eliminates any remaining withdrawal symptoms in my experience.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by PostOnce on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:08PM (#12712174)
A whole bunch of plants can kill you, we haven't banned nightshade, most mushrooms, poison ivy, green potatoes lol.

Let's ban poison ivy.

Let's ban going outside without sunblock on.

Let's ban walking around without a bicycle helmet on.

Let's have the govt come into my office every two hours and remind me to get up and walk around and stretch.

At some point, people have to take care of themselves.

How many kratom addicts have you ever had a problem with? And how many problematic interactions with a drunk? We aren't banning alcohol either.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by toss1941 on Saturday October 15, 2016 @01:59AM (#12712932)
And there is strong evidence that Kratom curtails alcohol addiction. Kratom is amazing. It has anti-depressive effects that once fully understand I believe will usher in a new and vastly superior wave of anti-depressants. To schedule 1 this plant is beyond insane. Banning it is the bunny brained idea of a lunatic. The DEA is completely out of touch with reality or some special interest is pulling their strings.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by WhitneyLand on Saturday October 15, 2016 @06:46AM (#12713506)
Strong evidence? Citations please.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by GordonS on Saturday October 15, 2016 @08:02AM (#12713671)
On mobile now, so can't give examples, but do a search on Google scholar and you really will find plenty evidence there
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by rms on Saturday October 15, 2016 @08:27AM (#12713730)
Really? I tried doing this search and can't find much. I'm pretty up on the state of the scientific literature on kratom, because I'm in the industry, curious, and have been actively working at improving the dreadful wikipedia article.

There's this case, http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0924933811... , but it's a case of one. There are some cases of simultaneous kratom and alcohol dependence, but that's not the same thing.

Even the peer reviewed evidence for kratom working for opiate withdrawal is quite weak, despite boatloads of anecdotal evidence. There are studies in mice and some observational studies, but nothing that meets the standards of an FDA clinical trial. Kratom has just not really been seriously studied.

If I'm missing some papers or a body of research, please let me know.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by GordonS on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @05:37AM (#12733082)
Sorry, I thought I was replying to a thread about kratom's efficacy on pain, not alcohol dependence. Not sure if I hit reply on the wrong thread or just misread it!
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by M00n_Sl47r on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:10PM (#12712187)
Long term kratom use can cause a dependence, and the withdrawals are very very similar to heroin/morphine withdrawals.

regarding your second point, I cant find any hard sources, but my experience has been that unless one is doing WAAYY too much kratom, both per dose and over longer periods of time. Unless you are already an opioid addict trying to use kratom to maintain and kick a harder habit (the well known use is as a transition from dope), you should NOT be doing kratom every day.. unless you're trying to become one of the aforementioned addicts.

On 3, definitely, it's a ridiculous misuse of the conception that natural is healthy. What if I told you to go out and do datura (Stramonium, iirc), or nightshade (makes you so pretty!). Both just as natural, arguably moreso considering you have to process kratom leaves, whereas you can go from finding a datura or nightshade family plant to eating it in seconds.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by Stanleymilgram on Saturday October 15, 2016 @03:56PM (#12715428)
This is ridiculous! First, please become informed before posting on a subject you clearly know little about. Second, in your "aforementioned" comment, you did not differentiate between uei and plain leaf kratom. This means you are either a "plant", or just a complete m. I know first-hand that coming off daily use of plain leaf kratom is a cakewalk compared to pharmaceuticals like methadone. Kratom is very similar to stopping your daily cup of coffee. You do not have 2 weeks of severe withdrawal nor do you have years in a state of PAWS. Also, if you think man made drugs like methadone are safer than natural substances like kratom, you need to head back to your big pharma office. Kratom is safe when taken in moderation. It will not kill you DEAD because when you take too much, it induces the users to vomit. It does not cause a complete shutdown of your cns! And when used daily for anxiety or other ailments, it is much safer than big pharmas "non natural" poisons. All big pharma concoctions can kill you and "accidental" overdoses occur every minute in the US on a daily basis. You are wrong and I question the sincerity of your comment.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by GordonS on Saturday October 15, 2016 @08:00AM (#12713665)
> withdrawals are very very similar to heroin/morphine withdrawals

Source please.

Anecdotal evidence from those that have gone through both heroin and kratom withdrawals generally say coming off kratom is extremely easy by comparison.

It's also worth noting that, anecdotally (and I include myself here), for many people coming off kratom is easier than stopping drinking coffee.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by nikcub on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:12PM (#12712197)
Most modern nations accept opiate substitution therapy (OST) as the most effective way to treat opiod addiction. The entire premise of OST is that you substitute a bad opiate for a "less bad" opiate - and Kratom is looking like one of the best "least bad" candidates we've ever seen.

Nobody is delusional about the effects of Kratom or downsides - all drugs have downsides. I've never seen it mentioned or recommended outside of opiate substitution and for opiate addicts - it has no value as a recreational drug.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by zild3d on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:41PM (#12712331)
Your first paragraph I completely agree, Kratom is promising to be safer than the leading opiate substitution medicines (ie methadone)

But

> it has no value as a recreational drug.

is completely wrong. See the erowid page [1].

Some of the positive effects (Simultaneous stimulation & sedation, Feelings of euphoria, Useful with physical labor, Low doses can result in a lasting "glow" in some people, increases sociability and talkativeness) have high recreational value. Personally I find it great as an alternative to harsher stimulants for getting a lot of work done.

[1] https://erowid.org/plants/kratom/kratom.shtml

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by nikcub on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:53PM (#12712366)
You're right - it's not "no value" it is "little value" - altho of the people I know who have used kratom to get off stronger painkillers all referred to a natural tapering effect that kratom has where you don't want to keep taking it outside of withdrawal

Seems that for some people the downsides of kratom outweigh the positives outside of treating withdrawal.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by kristopolous on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:38PM (#12712314)
Do you think it's the Subutex and Methodone manufacturers using legal muscle since they can't patent and monopolize this alternative? Reckitt Benckiser, maker of Suboxone has fought hard against generics being available.

I will save my criticism of the moral implication of such a position because the English language doesn't provide me enough words to express it.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by nikcub on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:45PM (#12712343)
Think if Reckitt had any sway they'd want loosening of the restrictions on doctors to prescribe suboxone. Currently only 10,000 of the 800,000 doctors in the USA are prescribing suboxone - wait lists are long and the per-doctor cap is rising very slowly.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by kristopolous on Friday October 14, 2016 @10:11PM (#12712418)
Yeah, those restrictions are a completely insufficient response to the growing problems.

I had a friend fighting heroin addiction live on my couch for a year while I tried using my money and time to help him through.

The biggest problems (now we are getting off topic) are

* lack of recovery groups for atheists. The conventional twelve step programs claim they'll work for atheists but the act of faith plays such a crucial and fundamental role, that someone who is faithless really won't work in the program.

* an unspoken internal conflict of process. Institutions of rehab strongly disagree on methodology and there's this culture where most seem to have one elaborate and very specific process. Using multiple resources can be mutually exclusive and impossible.

* rehab in general is structured terribly. The reality is that someone serious about recovery ends up living with a bunch of strangers who may not be. It's like a zombie movie, one bad apple can spoil the bunch. There has to be a better way.

* a lack of reliable or convenient access to medication. These people know how to get street drugs. When they have to travel 30 miles and show up between 6 and 7:30 am to get methadone while heroin is an SMS away and gets delivered, there's a problem.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by tpallarino on Saturday October 15, 2016 @01:21PM (#12714785)
I used it as a recreational drug... and surprise! I'm a perfectly functioning member of society.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by WhitneyLand on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:42PM (#12712335)
>Nobody is delusional about the effects of Kratom or downsides

Not true. There are many articles being written in the same spirit as the Washington Post. They are using a headline to discourage caution because something is a plant - that's false and delusional.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by cmdrfred on Friday October 14, 2016 @07:58PM (#12711924)
In medicine, you have to show a drug is more effective (or as effective) and is as safe as existing drugs for a purpose in order to get FDA approval. Why not take a similar stance on drugs for recreational purposes? If it is as safe or safer than alcohol or tobacco, approve it.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by unethical_ban on Friday October 14, 2016 @08:13PM (#12711985)
Au contraire, a substance should only be banned from consumption if it is shown to be highly addictive, and life-threatening if overconsumed. Or something like that. I don't believe something should be banned until presumed completely safe.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by slowmovintarget on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:45PM (#12712342)
>>highly addictive, and life-threatening if overconsumed

You mean like caffeine or nicotine?

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by eutectic on Saturday October 15, 2016 @08:16AM (#12713702)
Little known fact: pure nicotine is hardly addictive. The Mono-amine oxidase inhibitors in tobacco really ramp up its addictive potential.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by unethical_ban on Saturday October 15, 2016 @12:20AM (#12712696)
No.

1) Addictive as in, one "normal" dose causes high physical addiction.

2) Lethal, more specifically that it is easy to overdose, or that the difference between "normal" and LD50 is low.

You don't get hooked on caffeine after one coke, and it's hard to kill yourself drinking too much coffee.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by Broken_Hippo on Saturday October 15, 2016 @05:00AM (#12713301)
It is pretty rare for anyone to get addicted to a drug after one dose. Even for things like heroin. I think I've read that at most, there is a 25% chance of addiction. Still high, but still below the thresh hold. But admittedly, it is rather hard to sort out fact from propaganda here. (and heroin does have that second one, I'm guessing).
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by scottmf on Saturday October 15, 2016 @02:11AM (#12712961)
Which drugs cause "high physical addiction" with one dose?
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by drivingmenuts on Friday October 14, 2016 @10:45PM (#12712501)
Make them all legal, tax the hell out of it, and put that toward substance abuse programs.

The ones who can't handle their addictions will cease to be a problem soon enough.

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by GordonS on Saturday October 15, 2016 @08:16AM (#12713701)
This has been done. Mitragynine and 7-OH-mitragyine (the primary alkaloids in kratom) do not recruit β-arrestin[1], which os what causes typical opioid side effects - including respiratory depression. It is this that kills when you overdose on almost every other known opioid drug. This really is huge deal.

Less importantly, but still relevant, it also doesn't cause anywhere near the level of constipation that pharmaceutical opioid drugs cause.

It also activates both mu and delta opioid receptors, which is perhaps why I personally find it is so much more effective for neuropathic pain than the more common mu-opiod pharmaceutical drugs.

[1] http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jacs.6b00360?journalCode...

Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by rms on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:03PM (#12712156)
Tobacco and alcohol are unusually dangerous in the scheme of drugs. I don't disagree with your intention to relax restrictions behind drugs, but if this logic was followed, nearly every drug would be legalized, which is not the goal of the government of the USA.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by cmdrfred on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:26PM (#12712260)
If that is true, and your end goal is truly safety, why doesn't the FDA and DEA advocate for the criminalization of those drugs as well? I have been told that the argument is that prohibition caused violence and crime, but so does the prohibition of heroin so that logic doesn't seem to hold.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by alexbecker on Saturday October 15, 2016 @12:03AM (#12712644)
Because it would be politically impossible? (I would also argue that the DEA's goal is not safety.)
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by csours on Friday October 14, 2016 @08:28PM (#12712041)
I upvoted you for adding to the discussion.
Re:The DEA is withdrawing a proposal to ban another plant ci... by BurningFrog on Friday October 14, 2016 @09:11PM (#12712190)
If that rule is so great, can we afford not to use it everywhere?

Let Pepsi, Toyota and Apple prove they're better than Coke, Ford and Microsoft!