This misses the point. Skinning - in the Winamp model of 'same functionality but different look' - is not the same as effective visual storytelling and usage of animation.
I'm not talking about just how Movie OS looks, but how it behaves as a whole. I agree that sticking a Star Trek skin on Windows 98 reduces usability.
Well, then why do all the examples in the article look like those horrible skinned apps?
I have a feeling that what the author proposes leads us down the road of pretty but ridiculous interfaces.
Re:The Future is Movie OS
by pavel_lishin on Friday April 16, 2010 @04:34PM
(#1271850)
Do you remember Winamp 2? When people tried to make "fancy skins", and failed even more miserably?
And iTunes is highly functional? Since when?
Does anyone remember Neoplanet? The skinnable browser?
Vaguely. It was around in about '99 or 2000? If I remember correctly it was the IE COM (Webview was it?) object embedded in an app?
Also I remember it being pretty useless outside of looking nice. In retrospect it probably didn't even look that nice, I can't recall.
Who remembers Winamp 3, with its fancy skins[1]. I know I breathed a sigh of relief when iTunes with its simple, yet highly functional, interface came out.
1. As an example: http://www.thg.ru/technews/images/winamp_skin-270206.jpg