News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by byrneseyeview on Friday April 16, 2010 @12:13PM (#1270990)
This is a novel legal theory. Goldman is being sued because they did not disclose that people on the opposite side of a trade had opposing opinions. Basically, they facilitated a transfer of wealth from the stupid to the smart, and now they're getting punished.

If Goldman made some kind of material misstatement about the quality of the products, that's a different matter. But so far, there's no indication of that. They helped execute a deal between two consenting, informed parties; suing them is like suing a condom manufacturer because they facilitated the one-night stand that turned into an unpleasant relationship.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by lhuang on Friday April 16, 2010 @12:26PM (#1271027)
The SEC alleges that GS committed fraud by not informing investors that the "3rd party objective manager" who cherry-picked the assets that were packaged in the CDO was at the same time betting against the very assets he picked.

That, and recorded conf calls show that GS analysts as trying to convince rating agencies to inflate the ratings of the underlying assets in the CDO.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by nearestneighbor on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:22PM (#1271202)
> That, and recorded conf calls show that GS analysts as trying to convince rating agencies to inflate the ratings of the underlying assets in the CDO.

What happened to winking, nods and understanding looks on golf courses?

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by byrneseyeview on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:29PM (#1271227)
That's just plain stupid. If you're buying, don't count on the seller having your interests at heart.

That's part of Goldman's job. They want the transaction to happen; if they can get a good rating, they should. The entity that's responsible for making the rating agencies rate things well is... the rating agency.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by dandelany on Friday April 16, 2010 @02:33PM (#1271451)
There is a massive difference between expecting the seller to have your best interest at heart, and expecting that the seller will give you accurate information regarding what product they are selling you.

The first is naivete. The second is Federal securities law.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by billjings on Friday April 16, 2010 @12:30PM (#1271038)
If this is indeed similar to the ProPublica report (referenced in another post in this thread), then this isn't a case of someone in the "opposite side of a trade". The trade would not have existed without the hedge fund committing to buy the worst parts of it - the party buying the worst tranche was called the "sponsor" for a reason.

Not only that, but the sponsor wasn't short on just their portion of the trade. They were short on the entire CDO. They've got a bet that pays off if you crap out. Without that bet, you don't even get the prospectus - you don't even know about the security in the first place.

I recommend reading the ProPublica article.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by byrneseyeview on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:37PM (#1271269)
I've read the ProPublica article. This is even more of a stretch.

Deals exist when there is demand on both sides. There can only be demand for both sides of the deal when there's disagreement about how the deal will perform. Goldman is being sued because one of their customers was right, and one of their customers was wrong. If the mortgage bubble had not collapsed, would credit default swap sellers and CDO buyers be penalized for profiting from the shorts' demise?

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by siavosh on Friday April 16, 2010 @02:40PM (#1271476)
The issue wasn't a disagreement in valuation, this is totally valid as you point out. The fraud allegation is because they were an advisor to their clients, and supposedly they misrepresented the valuation of products when then knew the value was something else.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by billjings on Friday April 16, 2010 @03:18PM (#1271613)
If they had misrepresented their deal, then yes. If Goldman Sachs lied about matters material to the valuation of the deal then they've committed fraud.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by prodigal_erik on Friday April 16, 2010 @03:51PM (#1271716)
Deals also exist when the parties have different risk tolerances or time preferences for money. If I sell you my car because I need a down payment for a condo, that doesn't mean I think the car isn't actually worth what you're paying. If I know it isn't worth what you're paying because evil mechanics swapped all the working parts with bad ones, and I hide that from you, that's fraud.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by billjings on Friday April 16, 2010 @04:42PM (#1271876)
Or deals can exist because the stuff being traded is simply worth different amounts to different people. Like the gentleman who made his money selling ice to India in an article earlier this week.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by apsec112 on Friday April 16, 2010 @12:19PM (#1271004)
No, that's not the problem. The problem is that the mortgage securities were, in large part, designed by people who would benefit if they failed. It's like selling someone a lock that was designed by burglars.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jamiequint on Friday April 16, 2010 @12:41PM (#1271067)
Thats the definition of any zero sum bet though. Puts are also designed by people who will benefit if stocks drop in price, that doesn't necessarily make it wrong or bad. The counterparties had access to all the same info Paulson & Co. did, they just didn't analyze it correctly or in as much detail.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by btilly on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:31PM (#1271235)
The counterparties had access to all the same info Paulson & Co. did, they just didn't analyze it correctly or in as much detail.

You have to separate issues here. Paulson & Co. were counterparties on a credit default swap with Goldman Sachs. That is fine. Goldman Sachs failed to disclose information to investors about Paulson & Co's role, and lied about their position. That is what the SEC is upset about.

You are right that the credit default swap was a zero sum bet between equally informed counterparties. It so happens that one side analyzed the deal better. (Actually that is questionable. The bankers on the Goldman Sachs side knew that they would get large personal bonuses no matter what happened to Goldman Sachs. So they may have analyzed it correctly and done what was in their best interest. But let's not get into perverse incentives.)

The issue that the SEC has with the scenario is that not only did Goldman Sachs fail to disclose Paulson & Co's involvement (instead saying that ACA had selected all of the bonds), they told investors that Paulson & Co had $200 million in equity in the deal, without disclosing the credit default swap position that meant Paulson & Co were actually significantly net short. This was a lie, and that is why Goldman Sachs is in trouble here.

Edit I had the parties wrong. Fixed.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jamiequint on Friday April 16, 2010 @02:10PM (#1271392)
OK, yes there was clear misrepresentation of who put together the CDO, that seems to be obvious from the available information. What I just don't see is why it that is material. By nature of buying a Synthetic CDO the buyers had to know someone was short, why should it matter who it was?

They should have been buying based off the assets in the investment not based off of the counterparty.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by dandelany on Friday April 16, 2010 @02:48PM (#1271509)
> By nature of buying a Synthetic CDO the buyers had to know someone was short, why should it matter who it was?

Because the party who was short on the product was the same party who created the product, and Goldman did not inform investors of this fact. It's not a matter of just buying and selling. The RMBS's underlying the CDO were packaged by a party who had significant interest in seeing the package blow up.

An Oversimplified Analogy:

Imagine that I come to you and say, "I have a document that represents 100 mortgages and I'd like to broker a sale. If you buy this document, as long as less than ten of these mortgages go into default, you make money. If more than ten of them go into default, your counterparty in the sale (not me) will make money."

"Okay," you say, "that sounds interesting. So where did all these mortgages come from?"

"Oh, we got an independent company to pick a bunch of mortgages that they consider fairly safe and that they believe are a good representation of the overall U.S. mortgage market."

"Great!" you say, and you buy a billion dollars worth. More than ten mortgages end up defaulting and you lose a shit ton of money. Imagine your dismay when you learn that the mortgages were not packaged by some third party as I claimed, but hand-picked by the very counterparty you were betting against. OBVIOUSLY if they were going to benefit from more than ten mortgages defaulting, they would have filled the entire document full of mortgages they expected to fail! This is fraud in its most basic form!

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jacquesm on Friday April 16, 2010 @04:36PM (#1271856)
That's an excellent explanation of the underlying issues. Now let's hope the prosecution does as good a job as you just did of explaining this to the jury, and that they make it a criminal case in stead of just a civil one.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by ZachPruckowski on Friday April 16, 2010 @09:24PM (#1272410)
Suppose you're making a sports bet on an American Football game. You bet $10 that the Griffons will beat the Hydras by 3 points or more. It doesn't really matter to you if George or Bob are the ones to take your action, since they're both trustworthy friends of yours and they can't affect the outcome.

But if you're betting against Hank, who manages the Griffons, that's something you want to be made aware of. Even if he can't directly influence the game, knowing that your opponent picked the players for the team he's betting against, he's got a lot of information that you can't easily come by, and it'd be a bad move to bet against him. It's a bit of a bait and switch to say that you're betting against another neutral party when you're in fact betting against someone involved in the game.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by btilly on Friday April 16, 2010 @02:57PM (#1271533)
The assumption with securitization is that the people securitizing the deal are attempting to aggregate risky assets then slice of tranches with different levels of risk/reward. When they are telling you that these slices are relatively safe, the presumption is that there isn't grounds for disbelief.

The fact that the people structuring the deal were short on the deal is evidence suggesting a far, far more involved analysis before getting involved. That's a red flag that should cause significantly more due diligence. The entire purpose of the SEC is to make sure that such material information is not lied about.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by apsec112 on Friday April 16, 2010 @12:53PM (#1271114)
The key difference between the two is that the idea behind a put is extremely simple, while the ideas behind a mortgage-backed collateralized debt obligation are extremely complex. Hence, a counterparty to the put could be reasonably expected to know what they are getting into, while the same does not apply in the Goldman Sachs case.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jamiequint on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:18PM (#1271186)
If you buy something you don't understand (when all the info is clearly available to you) its your own damn fault. The organizations buying this stuff were required to have ISDA contracts (not easy to get). Their money is managed by professionals.

If you want a place to put blame the most apt place would be Fitch, Moody's and Standard and Poors. The ratings agencies were far more complicit in perpetuating false understanding than GS was.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by apsec112 on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:32PM (#1271240)
"If you buy something you don't understand (when all the info is clearly available to you) its your own damn fault."

Suppose I sell you a word processing program. Inside the program, I include a snippet of code that will cause the program to stop working in thirty days, without telling you anything about it. By your logic, you would not be within your rights to demand a refund, since it is "your own damn fault" that you didn't understand the ten megabytes of assembly code that I sold you.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jamiequint on Friday April 16, 2010 @06:52PM (#1272191)
That analogy doesn't work. They were selling bonds to financial professionals, who had to have complicated ISDA agreements to even enter into these purchases. Part of their job is to analyze the assets they are buying. Its reasonable to expect them to do so.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by btilly on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:33PM (#1271250)
Read the complaint again. Goldman Sachs failed to disclose Paulson & Co's role, and then actively lied to investors about Paulson & Co's net position in the deal.

This is material information that was not available to investors in the CDO. Hence the complaint.

Edit Got the players wrong. Fixed.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jamiequint on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:44PM (#1271300)
@btilly (won't let me reply directly to your comment) I realize what you're saying is true, but most of the arguments being made are about being made about whether the trade itself (under normal circumstances) were unethical, I'm trying to counter those.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jacquesm on Friday April 16, 2010 @04:38PM (#1271861)
You keep doing that @ thing, there is a reason why you can't respond directly to the comments that you want to reply to, HN is set up to discourage flame wars by only showing the reply link when a comment is a little older.

So be patient and then when the thread has cooled down a bit you can reply directly.

If you really must reply there is always the 'link' link to the comment, the page that leads to does have the reply box. But beware of fanning the flames.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by jamiequint on Friday April 16, 2010 @06:57PM (#1272199)
I don't need you to teach me about HN man, I've been here for over 3 years. Your suggestion that I stop replying though is well taken, the misinformation/misinterpretation in this thread is rampant and off-putting.
Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by yummyfajitas on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:07PM (#1271152)
As we all know, hedge funds, pension funds and investment banks are completely unable to evaluate complex investments.

Note: CDO's are not sold to retail investors.

Re:SEC Charges Goldman Sachs With Fraud by byrneseyeview on Friday April 16, 2010 @01:33PM (#1271245)
So? When buyers push a deal, they design it so it's underpriced. When sellers push a deal, they want it overpriced. In other words, everyone is in this market to profit.

You're acting like the motives are criminal, here. But if two people take opposite sides of the same trade, they will both have the sinister motive of picking the other side's pocket. That's why there's a big, detailed disclosure agreement. You can read it right here: http://tinyurl.com/y7rnyh3 .

The lock/burglar analogy is flawed, because stealing destroys wealth. Inefficient asset allocations destroy wealth, and asset allocations can only be efficient when people with the same data and different interpretations are able to trade.