News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No, self-driving cars are not a substitute for a function... by M_Grey on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:22PM (#12694223)
It seems like it might be actually. A dedicated smart-lane without ped access, running road-trains of trucks seems a lot easier to maintain than a rail network.
Re:No, self-driving cars are not a substitute for a function... by GeneralMayhem on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:12PM (#12694700)
Cars/trucks are way less efficient than trains in terms of fuel and vehicle overhead per passenger or ton of cargo. The article is a bit rambling, but the environmental argument seems the strongest to me - tiny little combustion engines are disastrously inefficient and polluting, and electric just isn't there yet for true long distance. An electrified rail network is the high-throughout, bulk-process solution.

I'm also willing to bet that trains are much easier to maintain in aggregate then the same amount of capacity in trucks, due to there being fewer individual engines/motors needed. Track maintenance is slightly harder than road maintenance, but probably not harder than roads plus whatever solution you'd need for an automated truck to make it across the country (charging stations, electrified roads, etc.).

Re:No, self-driving cars are not a substitute for a function... by undersuit on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:02PM (#12696012)
Those are very good arguments for long distance travel, what about in city distribution?
Re:No, self-driving cars are not a substitute for a function... by M_Grey on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:13PM (#12694709)
EV's, and automated road-trains would hugely boost efficiency... hence the dedicated smart-lane.
Re:No, self-driving cars are not a substitute for a function... by justanotherbody on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @07:49PM (#12697317)
The Seattle area already has decided bus lanes (with non - bus right turns). Basically, at-grade transportation that interacts with traffic fails during the peak periods of travel, particularly at turning points, because of other traffic. During the off peak it would work well, but then you've failed to solve the commute problem

If you operate dedicated routes that have limited interaction with traffic you found achieve higher efficienct, but now people are being dropped off at what is functionally a bus stop and have to walk to work. This could actually work really well, except choke points like highway ramps will wreak havoc.

Building an entire extra set of lanes everywhere is prohibitively expensive, and even then is only feasible in the outlying areas

It's a very challenging problem in terms of space utilization and management, even if the technology magically worked in the best possible way. AV only solves some of it

Re:No, self-driving cars are not a substitute for a function... by M_Grey on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:11PM (#12697651)
We're talking about an alternative to new railways, so the issues are already on the table in terms of space and money.