News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by abalone on Monday October 10, 2016 @09:48PM (#12681337)
It sure sounds like Schiller's team screwed up here and should reinstate his account forthwith.

In short, Kapeli helped a relative open an account years ago but has otherwise been unassociated with that account. He technically shouldn't have used his credit card to help his relative, but this is Romania and it's just a nominal $99 fee, so he probably didn't think much of it. Apple's stance is they now look at them as "linked" accounts due to the use of his credit card and old devices, so they were justified in shutting down his account for fraudulent activity on the other one.

Problem is Apple never contacted Kapeli's account before shutting both of them down. They didn't do any extra due diligence for a top developer. Their notices only went to the other account, apparently, and Kapeli never had a chance to see them. He just woke up one day and his account was banned.

Now, that's just dumb. If the accounts are linked, why not notify both accounts?

Kapeli's an extremely well-respected app and has oodles of credibility. That alone should have triggered a deeper investigation before shutting him down. That fact that they know what happened here and still refuse to reinstate the account is shameful.

Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by carterehsmith on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @01:13AM (#12682010)
> "In short, Kapeli helped a relative open an account years ago but has otherwise been unassociated with that account."

That's what Kapeli claims. How exactly do you know that the above is true? As opposed to, you know, himself creating two accounts.

Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by abalone on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @01:41AM (#12682102)
Logic. Apple called him and conceded that the reason they thought they were the same "entity" is simply because both used the same credit card number. If Kapeli wanted to be deceptive and create another account to commit a bunch of fraud on that appeared unassociated with him, he'd use another credit card, bundle ID, etc.
Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by dpark on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:25AM (#12682215)
Of course, because no one committing fraud ever makes mistakes.

I have no idea if Popescu was really involved in the fraudulent activity or not. But dismissing it as too dumb to be possible is no better than dismissing the possibility of Apple making a detection mistake as too dumb to be possible.

Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by abalone on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:22AM (#12682376)
I didn't say it was dumb to think it "possible" for him to be the culprit. I said it was dumb to shut down a top developer account without warning.
Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by dpark on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:32AM (#12684177)
I'm referring to your claim that he would have used a different credit card and ID as if this is obviously true. It's neither true nor obvious since he didn't realize by his own admission that the accounts were linked.
Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by abalone on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @01:36PM (#12686562)
Even that doesn't make much sense. It is obvious that Apple would know that the accounts are linked.
Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by dpark on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:29PM (#12687174)
You're misunderstanding the entire point of my comment. I was specifically addressing the assertion that Popescu would have used a different card for the other account if he were trying to commit fraud: "If Kapeli wanted to be deceptive and create another account to commit a bunch of fraud on that appeared unassociated with him, he'd use another credit card, bundle ID, etc."

This claim is untrue. Per Popescu's blog, he didn't know using the same bank/CC info would link the accounts. So no, he likely wouldn't have used a different card. So the implication that because he didn't use a different card, he therefore wasn't trying to commit fraud is invalid.

The reference to Apple being dumb was merely for comparison.

Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by abalone on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @03:22PM (#12687671)
I get what you're saying, but it still doesn't make sense. It is obvious that providing bank information will tie your identity to both accounts. That is utterly obvious. Ergo, by "linking" what he is referring to is being personally responsible for the behavior of the other person, even though they have a different name etc., not that Apple would be unable to see the common bank info.
Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by dpark on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @04:15PM (#12688134)
> It is obvious that providing bank information will tie your identity to both accounts. That is utterly obvious.

It's clearly not obvious to Popescu per his own statement on the matter. Asserting repeatedly that it's obvious doesn't make it so.

> Ergo, by "linking" what he is referring to is being personally responsible for the behavior of the other person

This is a distinction without a difference. "Linking" the accounts is pointless unless it creates a meaningful relationship between them. The only reason to link accounts is to establish that they be somehow treated as a unit.

Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by abalone on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @07:22PM (#12689319)
You are claiming that Popescu does not understand that handing his credit card info over to Apple for the other account, amongst other things, would reveal to Apple that he has a connection with it. That is an absurd claim.

Your evidence is his statement, which refers to a more specific technical use of the term "linking", namely responsibility for fraud as a combined "legal entity", the phrase that is used in the cited phone call. I will let the downvotes on your comment speak for themselves here.

Re:Apple Responds to Dash Controversy by dpark on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @07:43PM (#12689406)
I'm making the much more charitable claim that he didn't realize Apple would track the connection between the accounts. This is in line with both his actions and his statements. Your continued attempts to force your specific narrow interpretation onto his statement is absurd.

Your appeal to downvotes as some form of proof that your interpretation is correct is also absurd, partly because downvotes don't mean that much in general, but mostly because I have exactly one in total. So as with the rest of the thread your self-satisfaction seems rather unjustified.