News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by h4nkoslo on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:17AM (#12675197)
Nope. The wonderful thing about rent-creation schemes (in the economic sense, not just "rented housing" although it's obviously a canonical example) is that they create built-in constituencies. Make the built-in constituency powerful enough to crowd out the competition and it is extremely difficult to dislodge.

Examples: rent control, copyright law, professional certifications (eg law or medical license), government contracting standards, direct access to money supply...

Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by crdoconnor on Monday October 10, 2016 @05:55AM (#12676110)
Rent control is an ineffective band aid over the gaping wound caused by proposition 13, ZIRP and San Francisco's landed gentry working day and night to kill all forms of new development.

America has a weird obsession with ripping off these ineffectual band aids while pretending the gaping wound doesn't exist.

Absolutely coincidentally the 1%'s propaganda mouthpieces would have you believe that your real problem is rent control and occupational licensing for cat groomers:

http://www.cato.org/blog/occupational-licensing-it-isnt-just...

http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-274.html

... but you've gotta be "fair" to the people who extract eye watering rents:

http://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/property-ownersh...

Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by wtvanhest on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:29AM (#12675233)
I don't have rent control, but in my opinion it is fine to stay in the older buildings as long as we keep constructing new units. Once the percentage of units with rent control is high enough, it won't be as much of a factor.
Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by Kalium on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:47AM (#12675292)
When the number of old units full of rent-control tenants grows high enough, they can become a constituency in their own right. At this point, like any good constituency, they seek to preserve their position against dilution. Construction of new, un-controlled units would threaten such a dilution.

Some believe this has already happened in SF and has been a major driver of the current housing crisis.

Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by crdoconnor on Monday October 10, 2016 @06:05AM (#12676146)
It's property/land-owners who fight new construction - they're protecting the value of their investment. People in rent controlled apartments have no dog in that fight.

Some believe it's nice attempt to scapegoat the poor and vulnerable for the sins of the rich though.

Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by geebee on Monday October 10, 2016 @10:46AM (#12677337)
Not necessarily. Keep in mind, property/land-owners own, as you mentioned, the land beneath their house. That land might be worth far more if it were rezoned for multi unit dwellings.

Property owners in SF are often opposed to new construction, but I don't think that they are motivated by the desire to maximize the dollar value of their real estate assets. They're happy with where they live, they often bought long ago so their costs and taxes are low, and they just don't want change, especially in medium density neighborhoods that have been stable for 75+ years. Their opposition to rezoning probably goes against their economic interests measured purely in dollar signs.

People in rent controlled apartments have a similar motivation. Their costs are very low, they don't want the disruption of new construction, and they are often concerned that there wouldn't be a place in the new construction for them. Why take that risk? The difference is that people in rent controlled units are more vulnerable than property owners. If they do find themselves out of a rent controlled apartment and on the general market, competing for the few new units that become available, they'll be displaced.

Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by hx87 on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:39PM (#12678180)
Grandma doesn't want to fight new construction because she wants to "protect her investment". If she actually wanted to maximize the value of her property she would take out a home equity loan, demolish her house, build an apartment in its place and rent it out (and maybe live on the ground floor). She just doesn't want the neighbors to be able to do that and "ruin the character" of her neighborhood.
Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by wtvanhest on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:56AM (#12675320)
The people in rent controlled units do not have enough power to stop construction. They delay projects, they even block and reduce some projects, but as time moves on, sf will build units and their power will shrink rapidly.
Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by resonantjacket5 on Monday October 10, 2016 @02:15AM (#12675371)
The problem is that for every unit that is built.. then the new dwellers then become in support of rent control. Even worse for each developer that is able to build, right after building the development they then start supporting rent control to prevent their prices from falling.

Basically everyone who joins the club essentially tries their hardest to shut the door once they get in.

Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by GeneralMayhem on Monday October 10, 2016 @03:11AM (#12675560)
San Francisco's rent control only applies to buildings constructed before the law went into effect in 1979, so in principle that shouldn't be a concern.
Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by omgbear on Monday October 10, 2016 @02:49AM (#12675478)
In SF at least, new buildings are not under rent control
Re:Class-Divided Cities: San Francisco Edition by resonantjacket5 on Monday October 10, 2016 @06:00PM (#12680091)
Yes... and it doesn't apply to my point.

Let's say a piece of land costs 1 million normally and 2 million under rent control.

I buy land for say 2 million (which would be 1 million without rent control) and estimate over 20 years I can earn 2.5 million or whatever as long as its above 2 million.

If rent control and building restrictions are removed, as more houses are built then rent will go down back to 1 million throughout the city and effect my own earnings.

Hence every person who owns developed land in San Francisco is for rent control, while if their land is just one small house their against it. However, once the person develops their own land they also start supporting it.