News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by pjc50 on Thursday October 06, 2016 @04:45AM (#12651017)
"Service industry" includes financial services, which have been hugely lucrative to the West.

It's a globally integrated supply chain, and cannot be otherwise. There is no way countries are going back to a blast-furnace-to-car vertically integrated manufacturing world. It costs far too much and you couldn't even do it back when Ford tried it. He needed to import rubber, modern cars need to import chips.

The only non-globalised manufacturing chain is defence, which is instead prohibitively expensive.

Manufacturing is popular because it's percieved as a source of blue-collar jobs. Not only has that declined due to automation, but I think that one of the reasons for the decline in Western manufacturing in the first place was union-busting and labour relations issues. Part of the reason Germany has retained its manufacturing reputation is avoiding that failure mode.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by coldtea on Thursday October 06, 2016 @05:47AM (#12651245)
>"Service industry" includes financial services, which have been hugely lucrative to the West.

For whom?

>It's a globally integrated supply chain, and cannot be otherwise. There is no way countries are going back to a blast-furnace-to-car vertically integrated manufacturing world.

The most competitive manufacturing though is "blast-furnace-to-car vertically integrated", just not within the same factory (which it wasn't even in Ford's time as you said) but within the same country. That's why China is so much better at it, because it has the whole manufacturing supply chain next door to the final assembly line. Of course you need materials (rubber, metals, oil, etc) but that's something different and at a lower level than manufacture.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by pjc50 on Thursday October 06, 2016 @08:33AM (#12651876)
For whom is manufacturing lucrative? The capital owners. Isn't that why we had all those labour disputes and replacement of labour with capital? As others have been pointing out this is mentioned in the article: "Because of automation, there are far fewer jobs in factories. But the value of stuff made in America reached a record high in the first quarter of 2016".

Is China better, or just cheaper, due to starting from a low wage baseline in a blank slate with few environmental or worker protections?

Is it just an advantage from not having yet depleted its natural resources? The UK steel industry was built near iron and coal mines, almost all of which are now closed.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by krakensden on Thursday October 06, 2016 @10:03AM (#12652500)
China is better. They have a rich, Shenzen style ecosystem for all kinds of manufacturing. They are not perceived as better because of the cultural distance and because of deliberate obfuscation on the part of marketing departments.

The US still has a lead in things that are heavily automated and meant for domestic consumption, and in super design intensive things- machines with engines, maybe Intel's fabs.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by _pmf_ on Thursday October 06, 2016 @05:35AM (#12651210)
> "Service industry" includes financial services, which have been hugely lucrative to the West.

If you buy into the philosophy that it is something other than an elaborate global Ponzi scheme.

Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by digi_owl on Thursday October 06, 2016 @07:09AM (#12651485)
Ol' Marx saw capitalism as a 3 way standoff between workers, industrial capitalists, and financial capitalists. And he lamented that while the industrial capitalists would in the long run be better off siding with the workers, they would invariably side with financial capitalists until it was too late.
Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by piva00 on Thursday October 06, 2016 @08:40AM (#12651901)
Why not go a little further and call it a structured asset-backed Ponzi scheme? It sounds more daunting, novelty and official.
Re:Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? by mohamedattahri on Thursday October 06, 2016 @08:26AM (#12651828)
> The only non-globalised manufacturing chain is defence, which is instead prohibitively expensive.

It actually is globalised. Things may be assembled in the US, but many components are imported from France, UK, Germany, Taiwan, etc.

> Manufacturing is popular because it's perceived as a source of blue-collar jobs

Totally agree. I would add that in the case of Germany, the manufacturing of industrial machines is very different in nature and volume from that of consumer products, etc.