It's a globally integrated supply chain, and cannot be otherwise. There is no way countries are going back to a blast-furnace-to-car vertically integrated manufacturing world. It costs far too much and you couldn't even do it back when Ford tried it. He needed to import rubber, modern cars need to import chips.
The only non-globalised manufacturing chain is defence, which is instead prohibitively expensive.
Manufacturing is popular because it's percieved as a source of blue-collar jobs. Not only has that declined due to automation, but I think that one of the reasons for the decline in Western manufacturing in the first place was union-busting and labour relations issues. Part of the reason Germany has retained its manufacturing reputation is avoiding that failure mode.
For whom?
>It's a globally integrated supply chain, and cannot be otherwise. There is no way countries are going back to a blast-furnace-to-car vertically integrated manufacturing world.
The most competitive manufacturing though is "blast-furnace-to-car vertically integrated", just not within the same factory (which it wasn't even in Ford's time as you said) but within the same country. That's why China is so much better at it, because it has the whole manufacturing supply chain next door to the final assembly line. Of course you need materials (rubber, metals, oil, etc) but that's something different and at a lower level than manufacture.
Is China better, or just cheaper, due to starting from a low wage baseline in a blank slate with few environmental or worker protections?
Is it just an advantage from not having yet depleted its natural resources? The UK steel industry was built near iron and coal mines, almost all of which are now closed.
The US still has a lead in things that are heavily automated and meant for domestic consumption, and in super design intensive things- machines with engines, maybe Intel's fabs.
If you buy into the philosophy that it is something other than an elaborate global Ponzi scheme.
It actually is globalised. Things may be assembled in the US, but many components are imported from France, UK, Germany, Taiwan, etc.
> Manufacturing is popular because it's perceived as a source of blue-collar jobs
Totally agree. I would add that in the case of Germany, the manufacturing of industrial machines is very different in nature and volume from that of consumer products, etc.
People are disconnected by a lack of jobs that they want to do, jobs that provide tangible value, and need to blame that on something. So generally go with immigration, because it's a problem they can (try) and do something about and it must be that the immigrants who took the jobs.
Truth is the country as a whole decided that they'd outsource those dirty manufacturing jobs to a lower class in another timezone. Without really considering what value they'd provide now that they don't actually make anything anymore.
The country goes into decline, no longer producing anything of value, trying to suck money out of the marketing, economic and other forms of lockin they put in place (many of which would be called "service industries). Slowly, the countries actually doing the manufacturing wake up to the fact that they don't actually need that stuff.
The value of stuff made in America reached a record high in the first quarter of 2016, even after adjusting for inflation.
It's not that the U.S. doesn't make things anymore, it's that there aren't endless jobs in making things.
So those politicians speaking to old people in steel towns are misleading them and giving them false hope. Bringing manufacturing back isn't going to do much to reduce unemployment . That seems to be the point of the article.
(There's an aside in Huxley's 'Brave new world' about new sports being invented with elaborate equipment requirements simply to soak up surplus manufacturing capacity)
1. http://www.marketfolly.com/2016/05/stan-druckenmillers-sohn-... 2. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2015/04/29/dont-bl...
> your previous friendly third world manufactures give you the finger
Countries are not kids on a playground. If a country's economy does a lot of trade with the U.S., cutting off that trade is the last thing they are going to want to do, especially in the midst of a downturn.
Think the government of Venezuela has liked the U.S. over the past 2 decades? But they haven't disliked us enough to stop selling us their oil, or buying our planes and construction equipment.
And, of course, the U.S. today remains one of the top manufacturers in the world. To the extent we are growing services, it is on top of manufacturing, not displacing it.
That said, manufacturing jobs have disappeared--and that's why politicians are obsessed with it. Because they get elected by people who want good jobs, and no one has yet discovered a new industry that will pay millions of high school graduates enough to buy a car and a single-family home, the way manufacturing used to.
But the article even points out that these jobs are not being moved overseas, they are being automated away. Thus, it will be an American manufacture giving you the finger.
> but being able to produce the actual shit your businesses design and sell/export, matters.
Good thing we are producing more "shit" than ever before in history.
> From an economic perspective, however, there can be no revival of American manufacturing, because there has been no collapse. Because of automation, there are far fewer jobs in factories. But the value of stuff made in America reached a record high in the first quarter of 2016, even after adjusting for inflation. The present moment, in other words, is the most productive in the nation’s history.
From an economic perspective, however, there can be no revival of American manufacturing, because there has been no collapse. Because of automation, there are far fewer jobs in factories. But the value of stuff made in America reached a record high in the first quarter of 2016, even after adjusting for inflation. The present moment, in other words, is the most productive in the nation’s history.
If the bottom falls out, the US may find that there are no customers for their comparative luxury goods and no US citizen willing to work for little enough to be competitive with anything else.
I am, of course, an random guy on the internet and my observations are worth slightly less than that, so who knows ;-)
Because when the shit comes to shove and the global economy takes a nosedive or your previous friendly third world manufactures give you the finger, having a "service industry" is worth nothing, but being able to produce the actual shit your businesses design and sell/export, matters.
Of course for the US this might be less so, because they can always force, by diplomacy or might, those developing world manufacturers to comply.
Another question would be why are people like the author of the article not particularly hot for manufacturing?
Because they are upper middle class pundits, have worked all their lives in the culture/media/academic etc industries, and could not care less for lost manufacturing jobs and other such stuff.
That's how we get books about the world being flat, industry doesn't matter, it's all "information" and "creativity" now, from people that could not suffer a day without electricity (and the hard work that goes into producing it), or without their car, etc.