The problem in NYC is that there's just too much band crowding; adding more access points is only going to provide an improvement (if any at all) until everyone else does it, too, and then it's going to be worse for everyone.
We really need better solutions for extremely high-density deployment of competing WiFi networks.
http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB126221116097210861
My SF apartment is the same -- well under 1,000sqft, need an enterprise router and a substantial repeater to get signal on the end opposite from the cable modem.
The downside is that you might need more access points to achieve equivalent coverage. Forming a mesh, like these Google APs do, is useful for avoiding additional wiring.
The beam-forming features present in 802.11n and 802.11ac also help reduce interference.
The problem in NYC is that there's just too much band crowding
802.11ad will help there: runs on 60GHz. Certainly won't penetrate drywall. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11adBut to your point, I'm sure it's all interrelated and if I had concrete walls with no neighbors it would be significantly better.
If I lived in a less dense area, in a wood-framed house of the same size, I have no doubt my wifi would be just fine. But with all the interference from neighbors and all the reinforced concrete, my home wifi definitely has a problem that requires something more than the simplest, cheapest router to solve.
This Google product might work very well for my use case, though I'm happy enough with my current solution.