Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by Skunkleton on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:20PM
(#12613778)
At least in this case there are treaties that prevent space based weapons platforms.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by zlatan_todoric on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:24PM
(#12613810)
Well, that would work if people/government don't break treaties of all kind on daily basis. Solution must be in roots not a patch on top of pile (of bullshit we created over time)
Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by cstross on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:36PM
(#12613892)
a) it's kind of hard to hide a launch system where the fueled-up booster stack on the pad weighs two and a half times as much as a Saturn V and the launch is visible with the naked eye from a hundred miles away.
b) There is a reason we don't use Trident D-5 SLBMs (or the Russian equivalent) for precision conventional explosive strikes on targets which otherwise require long range bombers with intricate in-flight refuelling arrangements to hit: something about not scaring the other folks with strategic nukes into thinking we've initiated a first strike and hitting the big red end of the world button.
TLDR: even the big guys don't mess with space-based or sub-orbital weaponry. The risk of a misunderstanding is non-trivial and the perceived costs are far too high.
Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by philippnagel on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:25PM
(#12613812)
That's nice but treaties have been broken and what can be done will be done eventually. It all comes down to power.
Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by blacksmith_tb on Friday September 30, 2016 @02:26PM
(#12614259)
Are we trusting the militaries of the world won't make gray goo or 100% lethal bioweapons because those would kill everyone, or will that just happen because it can, no point in even talking about it?
Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by philippnagel on Friday September 30, 2016 @03:36PM
(#12614725)
Of course we can and should talk about it. It's important to at least theorize what others might realize in order to be prepared. That's all I wanted to add.
Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by 2AF3 on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:36PM
(#12613896)
"we are so dominant in space I pity the adversary who would come against us" Lieutenant General Franklyn Blaisdell, Deputy Chief of Staff of the Air Force for Air and Space Operations
Re:What else can you do with an Interplanetary Transport Sys...
by throwaway1974 on Friday September 30, 2016 @01:40PM
(#12613930)
The system I described apparently does not contravene these treaties, see wiki someone posted above afterwards