Re:On Phone Numbers and Identity
by mikeash on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:55PM
(#12600772)
That number is around 1%, which may or may not qualify as "significant" depending on how important you think that is.
In any case, we seem to have no problem requiring ID for a lot of stuff. You need one to open a bank account or check into a hotel. Requiring one to reset a password would be fine.
It's problematic for voting because voting is seen as a much more fundamental right than getting a bank account, and because politicians deliberately make it more difficult for voters on the opposing side to obtain an ID if it's required.
Re:On Phone Numbers and Identity
by kalleboo on Thursday September 29, 2016 @06:06AM
(#12604243)
Trying to research this reveals the controversial nature - reported numbers range from the 1% you quote to up to 16% (with one survey saying 95% said they had ID, but further investigation showed 10% of them were expired or invalid)
In any case, we seem to have no problem requiring ID for a lot of stuff. You need one to open a bank account or check into a hotel. Requiring one to reset a password would be fine.
It's problematic for voting because voting is seen as a much more fundamental right than getting a bank account, and because politicians deliberately make it more difficult for voters on the opposing side to obtain an ID if it's required.