News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by webwielder2 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:22PM (#12599493)
As a designer, I find it genuinely perplexing and distressing that UI design apps continue to get created that don't support automatic layouts. Dragging and nudging things around is horrendously inefficient. The one app that does this – Antetype – has been almost entirely ignored by the design community.

Here's an example: http://bendansby.com/antetype.gif

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by gavinpc on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:36PM (#12599605)
Absolutely. I can't stand precision mousing (or "pointing"). Just watching that demo makes me tense.

There will always be a place for people who want pixel perfection. I think that place is called print. Eventually, we're going to let go of the idea that we control layouts at the concrete level (as opposed to a more semantic level, i.e. describing relationships and constraints), but that future is harder to see.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by barryhoodlum on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:06PM (#12601727)
I've thought about this - the existing method of designers coming up with a couple of static designs ("small" and "large" - "medium" if you're lucky) means the developer is burdened with interpreting these static designs and deriving a set of relationships and constraints between them. It seems obvious that the designer should be considering how the design responsively "breaths" at all sizes, rather than putting this on the developer. It's still design, just an added dimension that isn't present in print.

But how do you give the designer the opportunity to "sketch" but also describe relationships and constraints? You could use code, but then the designer is then also a de-facto developer. And having to consider relationships and constraints too much can lead to those considerations dictating the design, rather than the other way around.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by captain_crabs on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:21PM (#12602412)
The line between developer and designer has been blurring for some time and will only continue to do so (hopefully! if our tools and abstractions keep becoming better). Often I find myself on the other side of what you stated, where the designer leaves me (the developer) as the de-facto designer.

And the main reason why is that the designer is only capable of thinking in their toolset, which happens to usually be photoshop. PS simply doesn't cut it dealing with the complexity of web applications in all the different form factors it needs to work on. This has lead me to believe that if you're a web designer, your medium is HTML/CSS and potentially JS. So you should understand and be fluent in it. The designer is responsible for actually building out the html templates/styling used, and the developer is responsible for bringing those to life, but each has a lot of input at every step. A lot of crossover builds better projects :)

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by pvorb on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @06:18PM (#12601793)
New CSS technologies like formulas (calc) and variables (or Sass, PostCSS) will allow designers to do this without programming.
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by endergen on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @08:18PM (#12602399)
Calc is programming.
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by pvorb on Thursday September 29, 2016 @03:12AM (#12603731)
No, it's just basic maths.
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by pavlov on Thursday September 29, 2016 @06:32AM (#12604312)
And writing HTML isn't programming either, it's just markup.

To the average designer (and almost anyone else) these distinctions don't exist - if you write "code" or something that looks like math, its programming.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by ethanbond on Thursday September 29, 2016 @03:22PM (#12608042)
Figma has constraint based layout though?
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by toddmorey on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:43PM (#12600167)
Yes and ignores the multi-device climate where the designs ultimately will live. Makes me think the pixel-perfect prototype is creating a bit of a fiction. Of course most good designers keep that in mind, but I agree that it's really disappointing that more tools aren't built to have a responsive canvas where you can play with sizing and set how the design responds. The answer I hear is to get to HTML prototypes as soon as possible, but it's not as fast to "sketch" in that medium (thus frameworks like bootstrap), so I think potential ideas are left unexplored.
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by panic on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:49PM (#12599725)
Automatic layout systems can constrain your thinking. Especially early on, you want to be able to tweak things and try lots of different options. Once something is in the automatic layout system, it's easier to explore the space of options the system can handle. But making even a small change outside that space is much harder.
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by webwielder2 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:51PM (#12599746)
Totally disagree. Being able to adjust flow direction, padding, etc. and then perpetuate those changes across multiple elements makes me more likely to experiment.

Also, I'm not necessarily referring to setting up complex constraints and rules, but more just not having to move a bunch of stuff around with the mouse every time I make a change.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by panic on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:41PM (#12600149)
Being able to adjust flow direction, padding, etc. and then perpetuate those changes across multiple elements makes me more likely to experiment.

That's exactly my point. It makes you more likely to experiment in that way and less likely to experiment in other ways. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but I think it's one reason why designers and design tools don't focus on automatic layout as much.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by nip on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:39PM (#12600135)
Affinity Designer [1] will offer a similar feature [2] in the next build, currently in beta [3].

[1] https://affinity.serif.com/en-gb/designer/

[2] https://vimeo.com/169816724

[3] https://affinity.serif.com/forum/index.php?/topic/22644-affi...

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by ageektrapped on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @04:47PM (#12601240)
That resize to mobile form factor at the end of the gif!

Made me watch it twice. I'll be checking Antetype out for that alone.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by dharma1 on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:59PM (#12599793)
Sketch has some plugins for constraints. In fact one of the nice things about Sketch is the plugin ecosystem to extend the features - I wonder if Figma will become extensible.
Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by piotrkubisa on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @02:39PM (#12600138)
Antetype reminds me two tools which are based on SVG/HTML elements:

1. Macaw - http://macaw.co/

2. Google Web Designer - https://www.google.com/webdesigner/

But Antetype provides way better solution for managing padding/margins and moving elements. Thank you for sharing.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by on_and_off on Thursday September 29, 2016 @09:35AM (#12605084)
This. I always bang my head against a wall after getting new mockups from our design team. what happens for small screens ? what happens in landscape ? what happens for tablets ?

are questions they entirely ignore.

They just conceive one screen size (large smartphone) in sketch and can't be bothered to consider any edge case.

Re:Figma 1.0 – Collaborative interface design tool by spdustin on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @01:56PM (#12599768)
Thank you for sharing AnteType. Seems brilliantly done, and I'm downloading a trial right now.