Re:This link says it's from YouTube but it's not
by IgorPartola on Monday April 12, 2010 @04:26PM
(#1260265)
http://voice.google.com/ redirects to http://google.com/voice. Technically different domains, but I would be really annoyed if I had to confirm this every time. I suppose you could add a white list, but now we are just annoying people when they first start using a particular install of a browser.
Re:This link says it's from YouTube but it's not
by chacha102 on Monday April 12, 2010 @08:58PM
(#1260885)
No, I'm talking about seeing something like:
http://voice.google.com/?r=google.com/voice, where the resulting URL is inside the query_string
Re:This link says it's from YouTube but it's not
by IgorPartola on Monday April 12, 2010 @09:42PM
(#1260946)
So then we start obfuscating the URL parameters? Or what if google.com/voice is just one step in a series of redirects? What if some "clever" dude decides to protect against this and say base64 encode the r argument to "protect" his app?
If a browser sees an encoded URL in the query string, and then gets a location header to go to that URL, and that URL is not on the same domain, it would prompt the user that you are leaving that domain.
I can't see many sites that are legitimate, and use redirection techniques that meet all of my criteria.