News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by mohamedattahri on Monday September 26, 2016 @03:45PM (#12584943)
> "Job destruction caused by technology is not a futuristic concern. It is something we have been living with for two generations"

If American thought leaders such as Larry Summers think that technology destroys jobs and that it's a relatively recent phenomenon, then America is truly screwed.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by SEJeff on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:05PM (#12585097)
I do suspect some industries, such as trucking, will get hit with a severe blow. Many truckers make decent money without many skills to transfer to alternative industries. It will be really rough for them even if it will make shipping safer and cheaper.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by jdhawk on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:16PM (#12585171)
In the interim, I imagine that long haul truckers will be decimated - and short haul trucking (last 20 miles) will flourish. That should soften the blow through the transition period; where AI is good enough to drive straight out of a loading facility, down the highway, and straight into another facility, but not quite good enough to back down an ally in a congested city and get the paperwork stamped by the right person.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by SEJeff on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @12:35AM (#12587455)
But the fallacy with that train of thought is that last mile truckers already exist, and are flourishing. More often than not long haul truckers drop loads at regional depots where last mile drivers pick them up and deliver things. You'll see increased competition between last mile drivers due to less trucking jobs overall with a constant demand for work. The one law which is hardest to break is that of supply and demand.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by tuna-piano on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:20PM (#12585196)
I'll leave this here for those making the "technical unemployment" argument.

After hundreds of years of virtually the same argument being made, I think the burden is on you to say why this time is different.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_unemployment#Pre...

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by drewcrawford on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:47PM (#12585410)
It's not actually any different; "technical unemployment" has caused many problems that are clearly visible from a cursory examination of the historical record.

The obvious place to start is the horse: the horse population in the US peaked at 26M in 1917 and had declined to 3M by 1960, almost 1/10th of its peak value [0].

When those horses were unemployed by the automobile, we did not retrain them in new lines of work. They just died. It got so bad that conversation societies were established to protect endangered breeds.

Eventually we created a handful of new jobs in the recreational sector for them, so the population of horses is rising now, but it is nowhere close to the peak value, and of course we did not create those jobs within the lifetime of any displaced horse.

In fact what the historical record shows is that massive technological shocks produce long-term unemployment. It doesn't seem to matter if it's a horse, because of course they're just resources to be exploited in the furtherance of human goals. But then again, so are you.

[0] http://www.humanesociety.org/assets/pdfs/hsp/soaiv_07_ch10.p...

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by mohamedattahri on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:04PM (#12585543)
I'm sorry, but the horses example is really terrible.

Technological disruption is not new. It's been around forever. If your theory stands true, then how come that overall, the global economy is growing? Doesn't it mean that we've created more jobs that we've destroyed?

What about the other important element no one seems to care about in this conversation: the jobs created - very often - require a higher level of skills and specialization.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by drewcrawford on Saturday October 01, 2016 @02:38PM (#12619250)
> If your theory stands true, then how come that overall, the global economy is growing? Doesn't it mean that we've created more jobs that we've destroyed?

The number of jobs does not correlate to GDP growth [0]. So whether "the economy is growing" is not terribly related to whether jobs are being created. This is somewhat puzzling under Adam-Smith-Wealth-of-Nations ideas about economics, but it's an empirical fact.

> Technological disruption is not new. It's been around forever.

You seem to be misunderstanding the argument; I'm not arguing for something new. I'm arguing that negative effects of technological shock are well-attested in the historical record: you can look back at historical data and plainly see them.

[0] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/18/business/economy/us-growth...

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by tzs on Monday September 26, 2016 @06:10PM (#12586038)
Because this time the physical technology replacing jobs is not really new. It is largely old physical technology with better non-physical technology (e.g., software) added.

A self-driving car, for example, is just a regular car (old technology) with some servos attached (old technology) and a few sensors added (old technology) and a computer (old technology), with self-driving software (new technology).

Put a million drivers out of work with self-driving cars, and you don't open up a million jobs building self-driving cars. The number of cars needed doesn't go up much. The demand for servos and sensors goes up, but making those is largely automated already. Maybe some servo or sensor companies have to add another shift...so they hire a handful of humans to watch the machines on the new shift.

Before, when we replaced a human we were generally replacing him with a new machine. Now we are more just making the old machine that the human was operating operate without the human.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by csallen on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:06PM (#12585563)
Well, the chart at the top of the article suggests that this time, it really is different. Between 1970 and 2016 we really have seen technological unemployment that has yet to be compensated for.

As the Wiki page you linked to says, stopping unemployment depends on "compensation effects ensur[ing] there is never a long term negative impact on jobs". So, by default, technology will put people out of work, and there's no guarantee that some counterbalancing factor will always materialize. The amount of meaningful work that humans can engage in is certainly not infinite.

Of course, it's not a guarantee that technology will continue to improve either, at least not at a faster rate than the counterbalancing factor. As it happens, it's very hard to predict the future. But it's not unreasonable to try. And right now, it looks very much like tech will keep marching forward, and jobs outside of tech will not.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by nabla9 on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:40PM (#12585369)
1) If you are climbing the S-curve, most of the journey looks like exponential growth.

2) It's less of unemployment argument than reduced value argument. Unemployment is result from the lower limit for the living wage. People in India can find work for $1 per day even in automated society. If we are willing to reverse wage increases, remove laws regulating working conditions and remove all kinds of welfare, we can keep people employed for very long time.

3) In the past people could just leave menial jobs and pick a new job that required more intellectual capacity. We are reaching the limit where average Joe has no intellectual capacity that would increase their value in economy.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by mohamedattahri on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:08PM (#12585583)
Totally agree. I think the real issue is that education is not catching up.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by sn9 on Monday September 26, 2016 @11:43PM (#12587300)
There's also the issue of paying people to work 60+ hours when you could just hire two or more people to work ~30 hours per week.

You'd have more rested people being more productive and have more people employed while giving an opportunity for improved work-life balance.

That and on-the-job training seems to have gone the way of the dinosaur.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by mohamedattahri on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:54PM (#12585459)
I don't think someone can argue that technology does not destroy jobs in the short term. There's a reason why Joseph Schumpeter called it Creative Destructions.

It's hard to accept because the people hit are not necessarily those that will benefit from the newly created opportunities. But if History is clear on one thing, it's that the number of winners outweighs the losers.

Every economy that resists creative destructions in favor of short term social peace ends up watching prosperity pass by.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by daviddavis on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:17PM (#12585177)
I think you miss the point of the article. It's not that technology destroys jobs but that in the next century, technology could potentially destroy jobs at a faster rate than it adds new ones. That would be an unprecedented event in American history.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by candiodari on Monday September 26, 2016 @09:36PM (#12586962)
I think the point of the first graph in the article is that this is not true. Technology is destroying jobs faster than creating them for ~45 years now.

The thing people forget when comparing to past technological advances is that for the largest part of history unemployment was 90%+ at the best of times, ever since a few hundred years into the Roman Empire, if you count subsistence farming as unemployment (and since people didn't do that unless they had to, you should).

I think this is what's really happening. The economy is reverting to it's natural state. Of course for most of us that's not a good description of what's happening. Better would be to say "conditions are returning to what they were in the middle ages".

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by tdb7893 on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:12PM (#12585148)
It's all just this century's Luddites
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by knieveltech on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:25PM (#12585241)
Nonsense. I encourage you to point out a single industry that has cropped up in the last 50 years that generates large numbers of high paying jobs that aren't subject to being automated away. In 1985 people freaking out about computers and networking was luddite behavior. Where are the 3.5 million currently un-filled jobs waiting for the truck drivers who are about to lose their careers en masse?
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by Raphmedia on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:32PM (#12585302)
> Where are the 3.5 million currently un-filled jobs waiting for the truck drivers who are about to lose their careers en masse?

Space colonies? That or war.

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by tdb7893 on Monday September 26, 2016 @06:18PM (#12586089)
I don't know. So far unemployment due to more efficient technical advances hasn't lead to overall structural unemployment so I'm not too worried in the long term. For example if we can ship goods much more efficiently it could lead to increase in production of goods, mining of raw materials, even the service industry as people have more disposable income and that's not even counting the jobs running and maintaining the autonomous fleet. I'm not saying the short term might be kinda hard but long term the economy will adjust.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by knieveltech on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @01:57PM (#12591546)
Like it's been adjusting for the last 40 years? Do we need to review graphed data for labor force participation, real wages, and income inequality?
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by mohamedattahri on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:06PM (#12585565)
That's exactly the point. People fail when they look at what exists today. Technology opens opportunities people did not imagine before.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by knieveltech on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @01:56PM (#12591526)
Demonstrably incorrect. Technology reduces labor force participation. Some portion of that void has been filled with McJobs in the last 15 years but that isn't sustainable.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by 2AF3 on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:33PM (#12585785)
plus millions who who support truckers, truckstop workers etc
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by PhasmaFelis on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:54PM (#12585462)
You should actually read up on the Luddites. Their main goal was better treatment of workers; smashing machines was just their preferred means of protest. The image of the backwards anti-tech fetishist was a propaganda smear by the industrialists at the time, which was so successful that people are still buying it now.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by tdb7893 on Monday September 26, 2016 @06:08PM (#12586023)
I have already been told this many times in the past (firstly when I learned about them originally from my history teacher). I need a new word for people that irrationally fear technology but technophobe just looks weird to me.
Re:A disaster is looming for American men by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @12:22AM (#12595405)
So you know it's wrong, but you keep doing it?

Aren't you doing exactly the same thing as the industrialists who slandered the Luddites? You're reducing the real welfare of thousands of workers and their families to "oh, they're scared of technology, just ignore the silly primitives."

Re:A disaster is looming for American men by kharms on Monday September 26, 2016 @04:32PM (#12585298)
The ludites were of a generation that got screwed by progress. Their kids were better off though.