News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by dasil003 on Saturday September 24, 2016 @10:23PM (#12573581)
What kind of infantilized nanny-state fingerpointing scapegoat culture are we living in here? It is beyond ridiculous to say phone makers should be responsible for fixing this problem. Not just because of the impossibility, but because of the slippery slope of impossibility for all the other things that all the hand-wringing in the world won't put under the control of major corporations' safety initiatives.

How about this: texting while driving is as dangerous as drinking and driving yes? How about giving it commensurate penalties and drivers license revocation?

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by mjevans on Saturday September 24, 2016 @10:49PM (#12573646)
Only it's /not/ the same.

A driver 'under the influence' can't sober up in ~5-10 seconds.

A driver 'under the influence' can't /plan/ when they're going to dedicate a few seconds to interacting with a radio, or a GPS, or opening up a voice input prompt to something.

What WOULD make it safer, however, is if the UI guidelines for a platform followed common sense. If they realized that OF COURSE drivers will click through some annoying popup. That it would be SAFER if they STREAMLINED interaction and gave a more astronaut glove friendly interface.

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by saurik on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:24PM (#12573774)
Thankfully, both of these are temporary problems: in another five years we will start transitioning large numbers of people to self-driving cars (whether privately owned or simply self-driving taxis), and this problem will go into decline.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by ars on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:31PM (#12573795)
No we won't. There will not be in-city self driving cars for decades.

There will be self driving cars on the freeway in specially marked and instrumented lanes made just for self driving trucks (cars will come later).

But not in-city. Not till there is general AI.

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by asdfologist on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:39PM (#12573818)
This is one of those comments that people will dig up and mock on HN in about 5 years.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by ars on Sunday September 25, 2016 @02:47AM (#12574286)
Google started in 2009, it's now 7 years later. We (they) are no closer to success than they were when they started.

(The cars can only drive on pre-programmed roads with a human marking any changes such as temporary traffic lights.)

What makes you think that they will succeed in 5 years if they have not solved the hard problems in the last 7?

No. Self driving cars (trucks actually) will only drive on limited access roads AKA freeways. Those roads are controlled, and any changes can be easily programmed in.

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by Teever on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:21AM (#12573942)
Or maybe yours will be.

I give it 50/50.

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by tempestn on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:59PM (#12573883)
I except reality will fall somewhere between their two responses myself.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by mozumder on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:10PM (#12573726)
Or we could have the phone makers fix it directly.

There. Problem solved.

And we didn't even need to get thousands of local government agencies involved in enforcement! We just fixed the problem at the source: the cell phone manufacturers.

Would you rather fix a million separate problems - the millions of texting drivers - or one problem at the cell phone manufacturer?

How much would your solution cost vs my solution?

Systematic solutions that remove human judgement from the solution will always be better than any solution that's dependent on human judgement to work.

The nanny state exists because people are dangerous idiots. And they need to be nannied.

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by mjevans on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:16PM (#12573752)
The correct point to remove people from the equation because they're idiots is operating the car.

Fully automated driving, without human supervision being necessary.

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by mozumder on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:18PM (#12573759)
Or better yet - a rail system.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by ars on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:32PM (#12573798)
You didn't solve anything. You did the equivalent of yelling and crying and saying "you fix it".

Unless you also have a suggestion of how to do it?

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by tempestn on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:01AM (#12573891)
The Apple patent mentioned in the article describes how it could be done. It wouldn't be as simplistic as disabling phones in moving cars, but would also sense whether the operator was sitting in the driver's seat, among other things.

That said, I would still rather police my own behaviour than have my phone do it for me. (I also would prefer phones have an official rooting procedure, for that matter.)

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by mozumder on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:51PM (#12573859)
The solution is to force phone manufacturers to disable phones in moving cars.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by DanBC on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:48AM (#12574766)
How do they tell the difference between passengers and drivers?

How do they tell the difference between cars and buses?

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by mozumder on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:34AM (#12575741)
> How do they tell the difference between passengers and drivers?

> How do they tell the difference between cars and buses?

You don't. You disable it for all people in moving vehicles.

Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by ars on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:34PM (#12577826)
And how do you propose to convince people to buy such crippled phones?
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by mozumder on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:49AM (#12579304)
They won't have a choice, since all phones would implement this crippling.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by __david__ on Saturday September 24, 2016 @11:58PM (#12573881)
So passengers phones are disabled, too?? No thanks.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by dredmorbius on Sunday September 25, 2016 @04:54AM (#12574492)
How many dead souls per passenger phone call are you willing to trade off?
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by __david__ on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @01:51AM (#12633548)
All of them. Making the world 100% safe is a fools errand. There are always risks. I think the current state of risk is just fine, and I'm not willing to lessen my convenience just to reduce a risk that I don't perceive to be very high.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by dasil003 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @01:27PM (#12591320)
You say that in a shocked tone as if we don't already accept a huge number of motor vehicle deaths for the convenience of driving.
Re:Phone Makers Could Cut Off Drivers. So Why Don’t They? by dredmorbius on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:33PM (#12594205)
That doesn't exactly answer the question now, does it?

Tu quoque fallacy.

It also presumes my lack of awareness of the additional problems.

As I'd commented and cited in this thread: mobile-device distracted driving is a factor in 25% of motor vehicle accidents.