News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How YouTube recommendations work [pdf] by JoshTriplett on Saturday September 24, 2016 @01:27AM (#12569585)
I've found that the YouTube recommendations do a good job of picking a "next" video to watch, but an exceptionally poor job of constructing the front page.

If I watch "Some Video (part 1)", the recommendations reliably pick "Some Video (part 2)" next, with the other parts as the other related videos and similar content further down. If I watch a random video from a particular channel, the recommendations show more videos from that channel. If I watch a video of a particular game or a reaction to a given episode of a show, the recommendations show more videos of that game or more reactions to that same episode. If I listen to music by a particular artist, the recommendations show more music by that artist.

On the other hand, the front page consistently shows me 1) old videos I've already seen, 2) collections of highly viewed content that I have no interest in even if I've already hit the "not interested" X on it, and 3) popular videos by channels I already subscribe to (I don't want to know what's popular, I want to know what's new.).

Re:How YouTube recommendations work [pdf] by doh on Saturday September 24, 2016 @03:14AM (#12569847)
They do a semi good job with related videos. But even those go south quickly when you go through couple of them.
Re:How YouTube recommendations work [pdf] by posterboy on Saturday September 24, 2016 @09:40AM (#12570869)
exactly

> If I listen to music by a particular artist, the recommendations show more music by that artist.

I've had disappointing experiences of that, where the recommendations try to know what I'd like even better.

Re:How YouTube recommendations work [pdf] by therein on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:13AM (#12570019)
Yes, the front page curation is exactly broken in the ways that you've described. I've seen people who are working on this write on threads like this on HN. I really wish our voice is heard. Youtube could be infinitely better with improvements addressing these points.
Re:How YouTube recommendations work [pdf] by posterboy on Saturday September 24, 2016 @09:44AM (#12570881)
The main page is the main stream and diverting from the main stream would probably be a loosing bet in most cases.