Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by maxerickson on Friday September 23, 2016 @05:55PM
(#12568257)
It's kind of ironic to write participation in public discourse is growing so perilous in one of the most prominent papers on the planet. She apparently does not feel particularly stifled.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by reitanqild on Sunday September 25, 2016 @09:27AM
(#12575213)
Or she chose to speak up anyway, knowing full well how this might backfire but still choosing to do the right thing?
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by maxerickson on Sunday September 25, 2016 @01:49PM
(#12576368)
That's perfectly in keeping with my second sentence. Someone who felt stifled would not choose to face the potential backfire.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by RileyKyeden on Friday September 23, 2016 @05:40PM
(#12568178)
The reactionaries on the side I lean to have mostly settled down, but the reactionaries to the reactionaries are still primed to explode.
One can't even gently suggest that a person's words, probably said with good intentions, support an -ism or -phobia without getting a tirade about censorship in response, and an accusation of being a "social justice warrior."
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by hyperdunc on Friday September 23, 2016 @05:58PM
(#12568268)
Such tirades are a necessary correction to the insanity that "social justice" has become. Once the influence of these so -called warriors declines then hopefully the discourse will settle down.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by rhapsodic on Friday September 23, 2016 @08:03PM
(#12568776)
> Such tirades are a necessary correction to the insanity that "social justice" has become. Once the influence of these so -called warriors declines then hopefully the discourse will settle down.
Well put. I think the only thing that will curb their ambitions to become the thought/speech/culture dictators of the world will to use all of their own tactics against them, in spades. They might not be so eager to destroy the lives and careers of others if it incurs the risk of having their own lives and careers destroyed.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by RileyKyeden on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:11PM
(#12568320)
On my side, it calmed down because people criticized call-out culture.[1] How does one criticize reflexive fury toward social justice activism without being lumped in with the "warriors"?
[1] For example: http://everydayfeminism.com/2016/05/call-out-accountability/
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by hyperdunc on Friday September 23, 2016 @06:40PM
(#12568458)
We can remind people that there are "sides within sides" and that we should allow people's positions to change.
Re:Will the left survive Millennials?
by int_19h on Saturday September 24, 2016 @01:26AM
(#12569580)
Thing is, accusation of some -ism or -phobia can easily blow up. You may not have that intention in mind, but in the age of social media, such things can be very hard to contain, especially once the Internet mob forms. And consequences can be pretty severe (say, losing one's job). So, while any particular interaction might not involve this directly, it's always something that's part of the picture.
> In an era of weaponized sensitivity, participation in public discourse is growing so perilous, so fraught with the danger of being caught out for using the wrong word or failing to uphold the latest orthodoxy in relation to disability, sexual orientation, economic class, race or ethnicity, that many are apt to bow out. Perhaps intimidating their elders into silence is the intention of the identity-politics cabal — and maybe my generation should retreat to our living rooms and let the young people tear one another apart over who seemed to imply that Asians are good at math.
> But do we really want every intellectual conversation to be scrupulously cleansed of any whiff of controversy?