You should absolutely be very careful about working for an early-stage startup as an employee and taking options or equity in lieu of part of your salary. You should feel that you trust the founders. You should insist that they've figured out a.) who their customers are b.) why they want the product and c.) how to make money, and have some concrete evidence that the customers do in fact want the product. You should ask about the cap table, and liquidation preferences, and anticipated future dilution, and know what percentage of the company you'll own and how much you'll make under a variety of exit scenarios.
But if the numbers look good and you have solid evidence that people want the company's product, oftentimes taking more equity is the right move. Equity aligns your incentives with the company and ensures that if it does well, you do well. Under capitalism, taking cash is a loser's bargain, not in the sense that you always make less money (you often make more), but in the sense that cash dominates equity only if you've picked a losing organization. To the extent that most organizations lose, this can be rational, but to the extent that you're an independent economic actor trying to maximize your returns, it's often worth putting in the research to try and maximize your chance of picking a winner, particularly given the other career benefits of having a hot startup on your resume.
The optimal long term strategy for managing a portfolio of independent investments is to always pick a mix that maximizes the expected value of the log of your net worth. This leads to a more conservative investment strategy than the naive "maximize your expected value", and explains such things as why money-losing investments into buying insurance can be a really good idea.
In general this is probably not a bad life strategy.
Let's use the back of the envelope that of VC backed companies, 10% are great successes, 60% die, and 30% will last a good amount of time but don't recoup the investment. The average employee in a successful startup will get a nice payday, but not exactly a life changing amount.
This is doubly true for people capable of being software developers. Your expected income from work is already sufficiently high that a million dollar payday does not change the log of your net worth by that much. Having worked in a hot startup is good for your salary, but usually not by a factor of 2 let alone enough to really change the log of your net worth.
The end result is that it is economically irrational to give up, say, 5% of your salary in return for a chance at hundreds of thousands if the startup sells for hundred's of millions.
Now there are lots and lots of reasons to be an employee at a startup. If you do, there are lots and lots of reasons to pick one that you think has a good shot. But the hope of becoming rich off of options is only one of them if you derive great entertainment value from it.
I get that your utility function from money is non-linear, but I would expect a more accurate model to be a step-function, with large steps at "out of debt", "can tell a bad boss sayonara", "can buy a house", "can pay for kids' college eduaction", and "never have to work again". Equity payouts from a typical startup exit often line up nicely with the middle three, and if you hit the Google/Facebook jackpot, sometimes the last.
As others have mentioned, maximizing log is equivalent to maximizing the underlying.
But when considering returns on accruing capital, a 20% loss is much worse than a 20% gain is good, and similarly a 100% gain is much less good than a 100% loss is bad. This is correctly captured by taking the log. In the case where money is simply accrued from some external source, and their is no proportional return, log isn't necessary.
Independent investment opportunities generally have the effect of multiplying your value by a random amount over a specified interval. When you take logs, you are adding a random amount instead. From the strong law of large numbers, after enough intervals, it is statistically certain that the sum of the logs of those random numbers numbers will converge on the number of intervals times the expected value of the log of your investment strategy.
Therefore maximizing the expected value of the log maximizes the long term rate of return that you (with 100% probability) will observe.
I think you just answered your own questions - log is continuous.
I still quibble about the use of log for this purpose (and even if you do, what base?), but I see his point. A non-linear utility function penalizes low-chance but high-value outcomes.
If log is the correct mapping for you, it actually doesn't matter what base you use. It just comes out as a constant factor on the expected utility.
Sum_d P(d) U(d) = Sum_d P(d) log_b(d) = Sum_d P(d) log(d)/log(b) = (1/log(b)) Sum_d P(d) log(d)
(In reality bankruptcy laws give a way to reset negative net worth to a situation where you can again go positive.)
These same folks will balk at a few points of stock, will backload options so folks're basically handcuffed to a desk for a few years until vested, and will buy into the rubbish pushed by Scott Kupor that explicitly views early employees as obstacles to be stripped of their equity to fuel later growth ("Are there any other management practices where one would optimize for former employees at the expense of current employees?").
This exploitation is slowly getting the results it deserves.
> Equity aligns your incentives with the company and ensures that if it does well, you do well.
There is not a strong correlation between how well the company does and how well you personally do. You can be relieved of your options through contractual shenanigans, you can be put (even with this bill) in a place where you can't afford to exercise them within their window, you can be burned out or injured to the point where you have to leave and then the company reaps the benefits of your work and you don't.
Moreover, your incentives are never aligned with the company, because companies are utter sociopaths and fear no backlash from screwing you over if it makes economic sense. You will almost never legally be in a strong enough position to fight the company with its resources if you find yourself in a bad place--unless the company has grossly fucked up. There can be no meaningful alignment of incentives under such an environment.
> Under capitalism, taking cash is a loser's bargain, not in the sense that you always make less money (you often make more), but in the sense that cash dominates equity only if you've picked a losing organization.
This is a gross over-simplification. If you are unable to maintain a large enough equity chunk, you may not make more than a salary would've provided. If the company stock tanks, you may not make more than a salary would've provided. The idea of "a losing organization" just isn't very useful here, because a lot of organizations "lose" for any number of reasons--unless the definition here is being picked as "an organization whose equity is worth more than salary", which is a cop-out.
But if you do, you might as well go all in and mix your salary with options, work your ass off for a couple of years, learn as much as you can, build a network, and then if it pays off, great. If it doesn't, don't have regrets that you "lost" a larger salary during that time. Be thankful for the opportunity.
Obviously some situations can unravel in a highly negative manner (the partners sell, but disavow all options, the partners fire you before paying out options to other employees, etc), but those are just normal risks in start-up land. Buyer beware.
But if I were actually in my twenties right now, I would bust my ass at a start-up, have a blast, kick-ass writing code, learn a shit ton of technology, and be grateful for the opportunity.
A salary comes with no trap. You can ensure every month that you got the money.
If your boss wants to fuck you over, there are plenty of ways for them to do so, in career-ruining ways, even at a salaried job.
That's what everyone is saying: knowing all of that stuff, the reasonable thing is to take salary. You're just choosing to ignore that that line of reasoning makes sense because you'd prefer yours.
Have you ever been on either side of this sort of thing when it's gone down, or are you just regurgitating the party line?
I'm arguing that the reasonable thing to take is not salary, the reasonable thing to do is get a different job. It's not worth fighting over the scraps of a company that's going nowhere. Find someplace where the pie is expanding and then you avoid all the fights and backstabbing over who gets the pie. If you can't find such a place, create one. (That's why I'm founding a startup now; I'm not averse to working as an employee for someone else as long as they have their shit together, but I see relatively few such companies that I'd like to work for right now.)
Off the top of my head I can only think of a handful of companies today, and even with those I'm not sure I would take a six-figure gamble with most of them. If I were a decade or two older things would be significantly different.
More to the point, though - I don't think that the point of a career should be to minimize risk. Or rather, you certainly can choose to minimize apparent risk - but that usually means that whoever owns the least risky option (probably Google, today) will use that as a lever to get you to accept whatever terms they give you, which is its own form of risk. Ironically, very few of the senior software engineers I knew at Google actually had "Work at Google" as a career goal - most of them were ex-startup-founders, or Ph.D dropouts, or had toured in a punk rock band decided they want an office job, or washed out of law school and figured programming looked more interesting. You gain a lot of confidence by failing at something you thought was important to you, and that helps you focus on the next thing that's important to you.
I think that your goal, when you're a 20-something with few connections and little savings, should be to gain experience as quickly as possible. That's what lets you take prudent risks when you do have the means to do so. If you've never failed at something or gotten screwed over when you're 40, you're probably about to start, and your failures will be much more visible, painful, and harder to recover from than if you fail when you're 22.
That seems to have worked out ok, though, if you only had a 1/11ish chance of jumping on a startup being the right decision at that time, anyway. It doesn't dissuade me from the "options are most likely worthless, and akin to a lottery" viewpoint.
However...
> I think that your goal, when you're a 20-something with few connections and little savings, should be to gain experience as quickly as possible.
This is good advice, and I'm no longer in the 20-something bucket myself, but the trap I see friends among that group falling into these days is jumping from the "akin to a lottery" thing into a "I'm going to gather as many tickets as possible" job-hop-every-year strategy.
The downside is they aren't gaining much useful experience, and their "connections" are mainly just to an insular group of VC-funded founders and other inexperienced engineers. Being the most experienced engineer (with 2 years of experience before joining) at a company of 20 people with all the other engineers being straight out of school isn't particularly useful experience. You can make it work, but it's much harder - nobody to learn from, no mentor, etc. And if the projects you're working on are just basic social or game apps over and over, your experience isn't very deep.
So if that tight-knit pool dries up... what are you bringing to the table when you're looking for a job at somewhere a bit larger and more stable?
Really good advice. Which at 40 I will now ignore ;-)
I don't think it's gone far enough.
I'm really not sure that's true.
Its usually a bad idea to take stock options instead of a market rate salary because most options are worthless in the long run. Lots of people do it anyway because they have a fantasy about making it big. As it stands now this is a life lesson that people spend some time in their 20s figuring out and probably walk away with nothing but some valuable experience.
Under the current scheme exercising illiquid options is a bad idea most of the time if you can't pay the taxes on it and this is obvious. This change doesn't make it a better idea but it makes it much less obvious that its a bad idea.
That 20 something that would have walked away with nothing will be much more likely to walk away with a 6 or 7 figure tax debt that may cripple him financially for the rest of his life.