News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:12PM (#12541800)
So, there's no new features that anybody asked for, save the clipboard thing, which has unfortunate security implications, and there's a ton of nonsense none of us will ever use, as the Mac platform gets increasingly complex ("the computer for the rest of us" is now anything but), moves away from Unix compatability, and doesn't do anything useful with this additional complexity, but does cause emacs to crash.

I'd wait until they stabilize it a bit before upgrading. Or just don't upgrade.

Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:48PM (#12542142)
>So, there's no new features that anybody asked for

Many asked for tabs in every app, shared clipboard, more voice control, improved Photos app and better iTunes, picture in picture, and more full featured Messages app. Plus few would ask Apple to take back the ability to save space (up to tens of GB) through iCloud/Desktop integration and more.

In the meantime, there's also a new filesystem on the way, already in early public developer versions.

>and there's a ton of nonsense none of us will ever use, as the Mac platform gets increasingly complex

Like? I can't possible thing anything that got made more complex, save for a couple of trivial things (with an equal amount of other stuff or more becoming easier).

>moves away from Unix compatability

In what way it had moved one iota from Unix compatibility?

>and doesn't do anything useful with this additional complexity

What complexity? What exactly did you find more complex compared to 10.10, or 10.7 or 10.5 or whatever?

Besides something like "sandboxed apps make it difficult to piss all over the filesystem, like old apps could".

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:13PM (#12542381)
>Like? I can't possible thing anything that got made more complex, save for a couple of trivial things (with an equal amount of other stuff or more becoming easier).

UI complexity: Apple keeps moving the goalposts on its UI focus, and it shows: The new interface is WAAY more complex.

EC did some interesting unix things, which broke some stuff IIRC.

The new FS will be nice, but it's not there now.

Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:30PM (#12542553)
>UI complexity: Apple keeps moving the goalposts on its UI focus, and it shows: The new interface is WAAY more complex.

What would be a concrete example?

(And is that example major and/or indicative of lots of changes towards difficulty, or just a random example, among other things that got easier and some that got harder?)

>EC did some interesting unix things, which broke some stuff IIRC.

Well, even Linux might break some UNIX stuff ocassionally (systemd anyone?). But is there anything specific and important in EC or Sierra regarding that?

>The new FS will be nice, but it's not there now.

A developer version is included with Sierra, but yes, it's no there fully formed and default.

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:23PM (#12543036)
Systemd is crap, but it broke little.
Re:MacOS Sierra by schwap on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:02PM (#12542283)
> Many asked for ... more voice control,

Colour me skeptical

Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:27PM (#12542525)
Well, let's start with immobile and impaired users, of which are millions...

Then, let's check all those media pundits lamenting for the lack of something like Cortana on the Mac...

Re:MacOS Sierra by h1d on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:15PM (#12541840)
Funny I don't particularly find anything interesting after Snow Leopard. After Jobs left, they decided not to decide on anything and just sit on what was already there. At least they're free. Perhaps the most interesting thing these days is what kind of new name they come up with.

It seems to only break apps.

Re:MacOS Sierra by pfranz on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:48PM (#12542705)
Feel free to continue using Snow Leopard if you're happy with it. Here are a few things I've liked in subsequent releases (sorry if some are actually in Snow Leopard and I forgot):

  * Notifications
  * Air Drop
  * Face Time
  * Native Full Screen apps
  * Multi-touch gestures (mostly use with multi-desktop and  fullscreen apps)
  * Mac App Store (I like it better for OS updates)
  * Recovery Partition
  * App Resume
  * Terminal improvements (I stopped using iTerm)
  * Air Play mirroring
  * Notes (and syncing with phone)
  * Compressed memory
  * Full Disk encryption
  * Improved multi-monitor support
  * Spotlight improvements
A few things I'm looking forward to when I do upgrade my hardware:

  * updating while asleep
  * hi dpi monitor support
Re:MacOS Sierra by h1d on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @05:19PM (#12543530)
Maybe it upset you but apparently keep using Snow Leopard would not let me use any of the recent third party apps and it is totally useless to do so now.

- Notifications : Had Growl, nothing new.

- Air drop : Perhaps but personally in no need.

- Native fullscreen : This is crazy. I turn iTunes fullscreen on secondary display and somehow it blacks out the primary screen for no good reason. Never using this feature.

- Multi touch gesture : Customizability is a joke. BetterTouchTools is what is keeping my sanity by applying custom trackpad gestures.

- Mac app store : Apparently this is big.

- Recovery partition : One of the great invention was network recovery but not like I use it often at all.

- Terminal : It was ok back then. Perhaps better if you say so. I do use SSH all the time. Never needed third party terminal.

- Air play mirroring : Don't have experience.

- Notes : Calendars, notes, reminders, stickies... What's coming next for note taking app? It's just cluttering my app folder.

- Compressed memory : Sorry I don't know what this is. Does this help you daily?

- Full disk encryption : Important feature.

- Multi monitor support : It was fine back then. As said above, part of it is a joke now.

- Spotlight : Maybe. I keep my files and mails all tidy, so I don't need a search helper.

I mean, Leopard brought Time Machine, grid view folder display from dock, quick look just to remember from top of my head which are all vastly useful and Snow leopard perfected it by making it lighter than previous OS. And today they boast they added like 100 new stuff which almost doesn't matter and I doubt things ever get lighter than previous OS these days.

Ever since they thought merging iOS feature into OSX was a good idea, it keeps adding useless pieces and they call it the best release ever.

Back then I thought Windows had tons of crapware on newly bought machine but funnily lately OSX is almost a victim of that from the vendor itself...

I love using OSX because of high quality third party apps. And in my opinion frankly Windows is still far worse.

And for OSX naming... I thought Apple is an international company. Tiger, Leopard etc was easy to read and understand as a word for us foreigners and now what? El capitan? I must think their vision is just getting narrower naming a OS to some local name they thought was cool.

Re:MacOS Sierra by pfranz on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:27PM (#12543926)
> Maybe it upset you I only said that because I didn't want my comment to come off as goading you into upgrading for the sake of it. I know a bunch of people using older versions of software and are very happy doing so. I was just pointing out a few things off the top of my head I've liked in newer versions in case you weren't familiar with them. Many of them were better integrations with things like iPhone and AppleTV, which might not apply to many people.

a few sporadic replies:

  * Notifications:  very few things apps supported growl and I like the integrated implementation better.  Growl also started charging money, which is fine, but yet another thing to juggle licensing and that friction drove me away.

  * multi-monitor:  People complained about multi-monitor handling in OSX /a lot/ until the last few years.  I haven't heard of any problems recently (maybe I've missed it).  I don't deal with it that much, but I still have problems with Windows and Linux...dialog boxes popping up straddling two windows, for example. 

  * Native fullscreen: Fullscreen API was added in 10.7, then changed in 10.8 and again in 10.9.  It sounds like because of a limitation at the time of the initial implementation it was integrated with Spaces which blanked out the second monitor.  If I remember, there was an option to have each screen use separate "Spaces" to avoid this and in recent version it works out of the box.  I think some apps like VLC or iTerm still use their own fullscreen implementation--but now all apps can be fullscreened without developer intervention.  I just pointed it out because as it exists today, it's a new feature like to use.

  * Compressed memory: compresses RAM when it can.  Improves performance on lower-end hardware.  I don't know about this specifically, but I've seen this kind of thing actually increase performance where i/o is more of a bottleneck than compressing.

  * Spotlight:  I rarely use it for file search (that in itself hasn't changed since SL), but I use it all the time as an app launcher and calculator.
My beef with Windows crapware was always applications that run on boot, or something that would throw pop up notices after they expire in 30 days. OSX has always had a bunch of application I never use: Automator, Calculator, Chess, Dictionary... just hide them, delete them, or ignore them.

The reason your new applications require new versions of the OS is because the frameworks got better. If new versions of the OS were just adding new applications you don't use, then people would still write their applications with the older, better APIs.

Re:MacOS Sierra by h1d on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:10AM (#12545804)
> just hide them, delete them, or ignore them

At least in El capitan, I can no longer even touch any of system files even with root privilege. And then I could put shortcuts of the only apps I use in a separate folder but they add arrow badge at the bottom corner for each icons which is visually annoying, and I try to find out how to remove it, searching reveals I could rename the image file for that arrow but turns out I can't touch system files. No, I don't want to turn off that security feature just for this.

Next iOS feature that needs merged into macOS is, hide first party apps.

Re:MacOS Sierra by sdkmvx on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:24PM (#12543912)
> And for OSX naming... I thought Apple is an international company. Tiger, Leopard etc was easy to read and understand as a word for us foreigners and now what? El capitan? I must think their vision is just getting narrower naming a OS to some local name they thought was cool.

It's not just foreigners. Even us on the opposite side of the United States have no idea what El Capitan or Maverick is or means.

Re:MacOS Sierra by k2enemy on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:29PM (#12541976)
Yep, I'm already planning my eventual switch to full time linux. In previous releases there has been at least one thing I look forward to, but this one has nothing. Just features that I would rather not have included.

I was recalling the other day that I switched from Windows to Mac as my primary operating system because Windows kept popping up notifications for things I didn't need to see. Now OS X is doing the same thing with all the automatic update notifications that need user input to dismiss.

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:39PM (#12542060)
Mac has a larger binary footprint, but Linux has Wine, which helps with that a lot. But I've been linux-only for years.
Re:MacOS Sierra by rch on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:19PM (#12541884)
You'll be more or less forced to upgrade at some point. Chrome, Slack, and pretty much everything else stopped supporting 10.8 this year. Even CLI apps like Keybase refuse to run.
Re:MacOS Sierra by baldfat on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:24PM (#12541933)
AS an outsider looking in. What is holding a developer from moving to Linux? I don't understand the draw of OS X for developers especially the past few years. These yearly updates seem to break everyone's workflow for a while.
Re:MacOS Sierra by rch on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:35PM (#12542022)
I've been actively looking for a MBP-quality laptop that shows up on my doorstep running Fedora for about 2 years, but at this point all I'd need is a significant uptick in hardware to justify starting fresh.

I'd also point out how frustrating it is that Linux laptops tend to be on the cheap side (on par with a 13" Air), or generally massive, plastic, and loud.

Re:MacOS Sierra by nimbleDT on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:51PM (#12542166)
I have both the latest Dell XPS 13 and the Dell XPS 15, either of which would meet your requirements.
Re:MacOS Sierra by rch on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:18PM (#12542422)
Possibly... Do you have Fedora running on the 15? ...not required, just curious.
Re:MacOS Sierra by nimbleDT on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @10:05PM (#12544906)
Yup, works flawlessly on both, although I just got the 15 and haven't messed around with switching between GPUs.
Re:MacOS Sierra by itchynosedev on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:06PM (#12542326)
I don't need the latest and the greatest, but a good 4:3 or 16:10 screen and linux compatibility.

I haven't found the good combination and bought a new MBP and still happy with it.

Re:MacOS Sierra by baldfat on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @05:24PM (#12543565)
https://system76.com/laptops I like these ALOT. They look much better in person.
Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:07PM (#12542327)
>AS an outsider looking in. What is holding a developer from moving to Linux? I don't understand the draw of OS X for developers especially the past few years

I've used UNIX for ages, started on Sun OS (pre-Solaris), HP-UX, have used several early Linux distros, RedHat, SuSE, Debian, Mandrake (!), FreeBSD for a year or so, and now I use Ubuntu for personal stuff and Centos professionally.

I wouldn't use a Linux loaded laptop.

What OS X has?

Great hardware (Linus himself used to praise the Air for example -- which he used as a personal machine until 2014, and complained why no other company could make something like that -- he now uses a hi-end Chromebook).

No messing to get it to sleep, work with external monitors, including dual 4K, import camera photos and videos, work with new RAW formats, external peripherals etc. And by no messing I mean "an order of magnitude less messing that those things take in Linux".

Certified UNIX with full terminal access, bash, classic userland, etc.

Several package managers (brew, macports etc) to get 99% of anything one will need in Linux. And make && make install etc usually just works too, if one is so inclined.

Runs Linux on a VM just fine -- why would a developer pollute their OS with development environment stuff like installing DBs, compilers etc directly? And if you don't run it directly, then OS X is as good as Linux to host your developing VMs -- or SSH to some remote host.

A full, well thought out UI, even if it's not perfect. Even from 10.1 to 10.12, it never has the sudden "let's change everything and break everybody just because we can" turns that Gnome and KDE have had (I've used KDE but stopped with the 3 to 4 transition -- now I just run bare Linux or when I need a UI Linux whatever comes with Ubuntu).

Ability to run basic proprietary apps: Adobe Creative Suite, MS Office, etc. Lots of developers need those too, and I, for one, sure do for my sideprojects.

>These yearly updates seem to break everyone's workflow for a while.

No, it's just the vocal minority. Have used OS X since 2003, using it for programming (JS, Python, Java, Go, PHP, some C), video editing and music (various DAWs), and never had my workflow break, and I usually jump at a new OS the first day it comes out. The worst case was having to wait 1 month for Cubase 8.5 to support 10.11 -- but that's the fault of Steinberg for milking their customers, as other DAWs I have worked just fine, or had updates within the week or so.

Linux changes break just as many workflows (percentage wise) but there are so fewer (1/10 or so) Linux desktop users and even they so fragmented (different DEs, desktops, WMs, etc) that their laments are not really heard. Of course most major tech outlets hardly ever publish Linux related stuff in the first place, in contrast with Apple stuff that helps get eyeballs...

Re:MacOS Sierra by tothepixel on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:21PM (#12543011)
Minor critique - Getting a MBP to run with dual external monitors is a complete and absolute nightmare involving propriety standards (thunderbolt), OS lockouts (MST works with bootcamp, but not OSX), and expensive Apple hardware (outdated $1000 monitors only). Apple is no longer the company of simplicity from yesteryear.
Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:20PM (#12543873)
It might be -- I've only got one 4K I've tried.

But Thunderbolt is not "proprietary" is an open standard adopted by the industry at large, including PC makers.

Also the "expensive Apple hardware (outdated $1000 monitors only" is not really apt. It's not that running dual monitors necessitates using old Cinema Displays. It's just that Cinema Display's are old, and Apple hasn't made any new monitors for a few years. But no need to buy/use Apple monitors for that -- and it would be foolish to buy them when there are 4K ones around by Dell etc. Apple even keeps a page with supported and tested third party 4K monitors.

Re:MacOS Sierra by mthoms on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @08:51PM (#12544616)
I had dual 1080p external monitors for my 2013 MBP for quite a while. It always worked perfectly.

Recently, I upgraded to a single 4K monitor and that did require some fiddling (using switchResX) but it still works nicely.

Re:MacOS Sierra by sbalea on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @10:18AM (#12548343)
I was able to hook up my MBP to two external 4k displays and drive those and the internal screen at 60Hz with no problem. 2015 MBP with discrete AMD Radeon graphics chip.
Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:12PM (#12542367)
I run linux myself, but I can certainly understand that.
Re:MacOS Sierra by mackey on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:26PM (#12541951)
This has gotten better since they started public betas. It seems like people that work on developer tools are more prepared.
Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:43PM (#12542087)
Well, the linux Systemd nonsense is annoying, but I just run OpenRC, and ignore it for the most part.
Re:MacOS Sierra by baldfat on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @05:27PM (#12543582)
Wait? What about Systemd BESIDES philosophy conflicts is annoying? Especially for develops. (I don't want to start that war again but I am curious what real world issue someone is talking about. I see systemd as awesome for developers #1 and users #2.
Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @05:58PM (#12543763)
The default kill on logout behaviour is a pisser, and relearning the new, more complicated way to do a wide variety of things (set hostname, automount, timed jobs, etc) is annoying, and the whole thing is a massive attack surface.

But it's certainly not unusable. It's not a good thing, by any stretch, it's a pretty face over a horrific monstrosity, but it's usable.

But the fight between the systemd/non-systemd camps, especially in the form of docker/rkt, is a real pain for both sides.

Re:MacOS Sierra by soccerdave on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:24PM (#12541934)
I would be more concerned about security updates. Does Apple still publish security updates for those old versions or even for 10.10 since El Capitan has been out for a year?
Re:MacOS Sierra by AdamN on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:32PM (#12542005)
I'm pretty sure Mountain Lion no longer gets security patches. They're kind of vague about it. Basically, they only really support the previous release of OSX (macOS) and that's it.
Re:MacOS Sierra by gok on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:29PM (#12541973)
Moves away from Unix compatibility?
Re:MacOS Sierra by pbarnes_1 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:13PM (#12542944)
Probably a whole bunch of unannounced security fixes though.
Re:MacOS Sierra by zeveb on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:33PM (#12542008)
You could always upgrade to Linux. Debian + stumpwm + emacs + Firefox: why use anything else?
Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:08PM (#12542340)
>Debian + stumpwm + emacs + Firefox: why use anything else?

Because it's 2016? What about multimedia? Or an IDE? Or my proprietary apps like Photoshop and Premiere?

Re:MacOS Sierra by zeveb on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:53PM (#12542771)
> Because it's 2016?

Frankly, I find the experience of stumpwm to be far more modern and futuristic than that of macOS or Windows. They both seem very 1980s and dated in their concepts.

> What about multimedia? Or an IDE? Or my proprietary apps like Photoshop and Premiere?

Ummm, Debian plays music, videos and games just fine. Firefox plays music, videos and games just fine.

emacs is my IDE. I could also use Eclipse, IntelliJ or whatever if I enjoyed pain and suffering.

I've no desire to use Photoshop or Premiere, but if I did I'm sure I could run Wine.

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:15PM (#12542398)
PS works surprisingly well in Wine, but that I could understand.

Emacs works better than any IDE.

Your browser is usually good enough for multimedia unless you're talking about creating it.

Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:20PM (#12542443)
>Emacs works better than any IDE.

In the immortal words of Jeffrey Lebowski: Well, that's like, your opinion, man. Good IDEs like IntelliJ and VS have so much better integration for given languages that only result in ad-hoc, ho-hum solutions in Emacs (if one can suffer the millions of key bindings).

>Your browser is usually good enough for multimedia unless you're talking about creating it.

Well, if multimedia we mean "watching web video" or some flash pages. The browser can't even put up with viewing RAW images or playing FLAC files...

But true, I'm talking about creating (which doesn't mean anything at the Michael Bay level -- even something as simple as family vacation video or high school project).

Re:MacOS Sierra by pfranz on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:07PM (#12542894)
Sure, you're swatting down his arguments, but not Linux. IntelliJ works for Linux--I'm not sure why VS was mentioned since this is a thread about moving from macOS to Linux. VS Code works just as well in macOS as it does Linux.

Of course the browser can't play back all multimedia. With its pedigree, I'm sure FLAC was running Linux before it was running on Linux or Windows. I haven't heard of much of an issue with RAW files in Linux either. VLC works better more reliably than anything proprietary for macOS or Windows.

Creating videos is something that seemed "the thing to do" in the early 2000's. IMHO, Apple did have the best consumer tools back then. But I haven't really hear of much use in the last 10 years. Linux might have decent tools? I wouldn't know.

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:26PM (#12543061)
Openshot does the job pretty well, last I checked. It's not exactly polished, but it seems to work okay.
Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:28PM (#12543084)
...And IDEs being better is your opinion. It's all subjective. Don't shove VS down our throats, and I won't do the same for Emacs.

Thanks for the clarification of what you meant by multimedia. VLC, GIMP, Openshot, or an app run through Wine can handle all the things you described.

Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:19PM (#12543866)
>..And IDEs being better is your opinion

Yes, but IDEs being more integrated with certain languages (e.g. IntelliJ and Java, VS and C#) instead of ad-hoc collection of scripts for a language that Emacs offers (except perhaps for Lisps) is a fact.

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @08:23PM (#12544484)
Emacs has some pretty good support for many languages. For languages like Javascript, LaTeX, Python, C/C++, and the Lisps, it's absolutely a solid environment, with good integration with the tooling. You can at least expect basic syntax highlighting for every language under the sun, and ectags means you get code navigation for most of them as well. Java support is meh at best, true but Java isn't my main language, and I'd rather not learn another new, inferior text editing environment every time I learn a new language: Emacs is universal, and is sometimes surprisingly well integrated. Flycheck also covers for another common IDE feature. Besides, how much of an IDE do you really need?

Besides, does your IDE read email, come with an integrated tetris package, and also contain one of the finest tools for outlining, planning, todo lists, writing and publishing, literate programming in any language ever devised (if it wasn't obvious, yes, I'm talking about org-mode)? No? Well then, I'll stick with emacs for now. :-D

Re:MacOS Sierra by coldtea on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @07:34AM (#12547194)
>Java support is meh at best, true but Java isn't my main language, and I'd rather not learn another new, inferior text editing environment every time I learn a new language

Only most of the work we do while programming is not text editing -- we're not courtroom clerks or secretaries -- it's reading code, with a modicum of writing (less than 300-500 lines per day).

For this, a "great text editing mode" is almost of no use, compared to great language-related facilities for code navigation, AST-based autocomplete, intelligent refactoring, integrated debugger and build system, etc etc.

>Besides, does your IDE read email, come with an integrated tetris package

Thankfully, no.

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @08:11AM (#12547419)
You know, you're kinda right. Emacs has most of that though.

>great language-related facilities for code navigation

ectags, Semantic, and various other extensions for various languages

>AST-based autocomplete

Various autocompleters, including Autocomplete (not AST-based, AFAICT), company mode (which is, I think).

>intelligent refactoring

CEDET, Semantic Refactor, and various modes for various languages, provide a good bit of this (although it's not up to Java IDE standards).

>integrated debugger and build system

Check, check, and check. We've got GDB integration, as well as GUD, which can run DBX, SDB, XDB, the perl debugger, PDB, and JDB. integration with make, or any other command-line build tool you want with M-x compile.

So yeah, refactoring aside, we're actually pretty well off.

And you still don't have org-mode.

Re:MacOS Sierra by qwertyuiop924 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:34PM (#12542018)
Well, Macs have a larger software base: If you want a Unix with app support, and Wine won't cut it, OS X does a neat job. But I'm running Arch myself, so I'm not one to talk.