Tangents to marginally related things can be interesting, but the fact that an unrelated essay also uses the word 'creepy' isn't sufficient reason to turn an HN discussion into a flamewar. If the quote had been from the OP it would have been one thing, but BYOE (bringing your own explosives) is not cool.
If the essay called an ethnic or religious group animals, would you still link to it and characterize it as "interesting" and "provocative?"
Suppose I were writing a rant about obesity being unhealthy and visually jarring. I then decide, for comedic dramatic flair, to write "fat people should be eradicated from the gene pool," knowing full well it will anger the reader—who in turn cluelessly gets angry. I'd argue that that doesn't make me deplorable, it makes the joke on the reader. In the grand scheme of things, my gene pool comment obviously isn't serious, even if the rest of my rant is.
Being provoked by people trying to provoke you is the conversational version of slipping on a banana peel, and is itself funny, albeit only ever so slightly.
Just because you feel bad about something it doesn't mean it's false.
Being provocative at least requires starting with an argument that can be defended.
Looks are important to many women just as they are important to many men. There's nothing to be ashamed of and there is no point in denying human sexuality.
Is there an underlying assumption 'women are less visual'? It's seems like a bit of a straw man because no one can and should generalize.
The next bits about 'knowing your place' puts the author in the enlightening company of a cave man teling women to 'know their place'. I wonder how many will be lining up to defend that.
Self proclaiming yourself as 'good looking' is problematic in itself because this is purely subjective beyond a 1% that everyone widely agree on. To then use this self created pedestal to dismiss and reduce others suggests a unnatural degree of narcissism and likely necessitates a large leap from reality.
There is, at least in American culture. It is wrong of course.
I am astonished that any educated person could lend any support whatsoever to an article that uses terms like "genetic superiors." The premise is that only beautiful people are human beings.
Specifically, an ugly solicitor elicits a reaction comparable to a zombie in some women. This is generally a subconscious reaction belying sexual selection. Extreme but it happens. Less extreme version is tied to disgust feeling.
The root is probably the same: detecting contagious people and animals.
Being called ugly sucks, but in the long run it seems better than having an arbitrary, ill-defined adjective like "creepy" thrown around. Ugly is at least constructive feedback. You know where the problem is.
I suppose if you were willing to sleep with any "attractive" person that approached you there'd be no fear of rape, and so no threat or resulting "creepiness." Less shallow people, then, would either find "attractive" people more creepy and/or "unattractive" people less creepy.
In hindsight it's amazing how much young people take this shit personally. Like guy getting angry to a woman for her being fat. Guy getting angry because some random woman is not attracted to him. Gal getting visually disgusted because some guy does not look appropriately attractive. Etc. Etc.
Usually people get over it by their mid twenties. Some don't. Mixing fancy words to it like "feminism" sure does not help.
"Wording aside" is exactly my point. Women might agree with some of the ideas there, but I haven't heard any express them in that way. I have seen men express them in that way.
>It’s not “creepy” if he’s hot. I freely admit it. When a very attractive stranger approaches me and tells me I’m beautiful, it brightens my day. When a guy who is short, fat or balding does it, it makes my skin crawl no matter how tactful he is about it. I just want him to go away. I’m not alone in feeling this way. Most women feel the same, but hide the true extent of it when the guys are around.
http://theplacetorant.com/ugly-creepy-guys/