News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mindcrime on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:01PM (#12536137)
I honestly can't understand how anybody is considering voting for Clinton or Trump. If this world was anything close to reasonable, Gary Johnson would win in a landslide. shrug
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by losvedir on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:12PM (#12536208)
As a Gary Johnson supporter myself, I freely admit that he has some extreme policies that can turn off a lot of voters. But what really frustrates me is how many people I've heard from that do prefer him but are afraid to vote for him because of the spoiler effect.

I keep (wishful thinking) envisioning a scenario where he gets just enough votes that all of a sudden everyone on the fence realizes that maybe he could win and joins in, and then he launches ahead

Wishful thinking and politics aside: there's a term for that phenomenon on the tip of my tongue, but I can't quite place it. Can anyone think of one? Where there's a slow growth until you get just enough of something and then it takes off?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by matt_m on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:48PM (#12536390)
Rather than just hoping for critical mass for one candidate, it would be nice to switch to something like ranked-choice voting (it's used at the local level already in some places like San Francisco I think). It's hard to advocate voting for 3rd parties with our current system, where causing the least-preferred candidate to win is by far the most likely outcome.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by bcg1 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:41PM (#12536357)
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by soemoea on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:24PM (#12536266)
Isn't this called a tipping point?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by FragenAntworten on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:33PM (#12536313)
Critical mass?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by losvedir on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:42PM (#12536361)
Aha, yeah, that was it! Thanks. soemoea's "tipping point" is close, too.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mindcrime on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:17PM (#12536231)
But what really frustrates me is how many people I've heard from that do prefer him but are afraid to vote for him because of the spoiler effect.

Yeah, I know what you mean. It's just that this time around, BOTH "major party" choices are SO bad, that you look at it and think "who cares whether Gigantic Douche or Turd Sandwich wins?" Ya know?

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by minikites on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:33PM (#12536314)
The world is reasonable to reject him as a candidate.

https://www.jacobinmag.com/2016/09/gary-johnson-libertarian-...

Prisons:

>Johnson accepted at least $9,000 in campaign donations from a prison company that ultimately won a state contract. By the time he left office, New Mexico led the country in for-profit prisons, housing 44 percent of its inmates in private facilities. Only Alaska, with 31 percent, came close.

>In 2000, after four inmates and a guard were killed in private facilities, Johnson vetoed an oversight bill and startled reporters by insisting that New Mexico had the best prisons in the nation.

Poverty:

>Within just a few months, the state had knocked more than 16,000 people off its welfare rolls, and its poverty rate had risen to first in the nation, according to a report from the state’s legislature.

Schools:

>For Democratic legislators, the trouble wasn’t just that Johnson wanted to divert money from the public system to private institutions. It was that his plan would privilege rich families in the long run, said Charles Bowyer, who served as government-relations director of the teachers’ union during Johnson’s tenure. Tuition at the most prestigious private schools often cost around $8,000 or $9,000 — meaning low-income families could never afford them, even with vouchers. And private schools would still be able to reject special-needs students.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by tanderson92 on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:48PM (#12536394)
Worth mentioning that Jacobin approaches things from a very left of center perspective. There may be many HN readers who are Libertarian and disagree ideologically with the Jacobin view of the world (I happen to agree with it)
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by int_19h on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:28PM (#12536293)
Realistically, given how little exposure third party candidates get, there's no chance of any third party winning this year. Most voters don't even know they're running.

Thus, it becomes a choice of 1) making a symbolic vote for a third party to "show them", 2) helping Clinton win, and 3) helping Trump win.

Given the potential outcomes of Trump vs Clinton, a lot of people believe (rightly, IMO) that this electoral cycle is not a good time to make symbolic gestures or long-term strategic voting games. Too much is at stake. Status quo sucks, but is still infinitely better than the alternative.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jotux on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:47PM (#12536898)
>there's no chance of any third party winning this year.

There's really never a chance for third parties to rise in the US because we use a crappy voting system (first past the post). We should change our voting system to Range Voting [1].

[1] http://rangevoting.org/

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Dagwoodie on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:51PM (#12536410)
Curious, can anyone comment on how fair NPR is in terms of covering 3rd party candidates? How about covering all candidates during a primary? I'm sick of great candidates being steam rolled in the popularity contest we have in politics and I wonder if we have anyone that covers them all adequately.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mindcrime on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:26PM (#12536800)
Given the potential outcomes of Trump vs Clinton, a lot of people believe (rightly, IMO) that this electoral cycle is not a good time to make symbolic gestures or long-term strategic voting games. Too much is at stake.

And a lot of us believe (rightly, IMO) that both Clinton and Trump are so equally bad, that there's no effective difference.

Me personally, if Gary wasn't in the race, I wouldn't cast a vote for President at all. shrug

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by int_19h on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:35AM (#12537320)
Clinton may be corrupt and sleazy, but the country can survive 4 or even 8 years of that - it did many times before.

Whereas 4 years of a sociopath with megalomania, a definitive authoritarian streak, and a massive populist backing, I'm not so sure about.

Let me put it this way. As a third party supporter, your strategy, presumably, is to slowly accrue vote until your candidate of choice (or really, anyone who's willing to reform the electoral system to make third parties viable) breaks past the barrier. This presupposes that there is such a thing as elections, though. Say what you want about Clinton, but there's no viable threat from her in that regard. She might be prone to skirting the rules, but she doesn't rewrite them. Trump, on the other hand, seems to be a fan of the "strong hand". Last time my country of birth went for that, we ended up with a dictator in all but name. And the parallels between what I heard people say there then, and what I see people in US say now, are making me very nervous.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by ars on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @03:04AM (#12537704)
Interesting, because I feel exactly the opposite.

Corruption is the #1 thing that destroys countries. Nothing else comes close.

A "sociopath with megalomania" on the other hand can't really do much to hurt the country (no one would let him). And I don't see how "a definitive authoritarian streak, and a massive populist backing" are a problem.

i.e. secret damage to a country is much worse than open damage.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by int_19h on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:51PM (#12542159)
> Corruption is the #1 thing that destroys countries. Nothing else comes close.

Really? Militaristic jingoism has historically been a pretty popular choice to commit national suicide, for example.

The thing about corruption is that it's not violently destructive. It slowly erodes the system, but it takes a lot of time, and the process is reversible at practically any point.

> A "sociopath with megalomania" on the other hand can't really do much to hurt the country (no one would let him).

That seems to be a common retort that I've encountered among reluctant Trump supporters - that checks and balances would prevent anything really damaging.

I don't feel like it's particularly well supported by experience. Just to give a simple example, not only Japanese-American internment during WW2 was found to be legal and constitutional, but the corresponding SCOTUS decision (Korematsu) still stands. Which means that the president can sign a similar EO, and it'll be in force per existing precedent until SCOTUS gets a chance to overturn - and even then there are no guarantees.

And then there's a slew of accumulated post-9/11 precedent, which, in the hands of someone who thinks that torture is a good idea, among other reasons, "because they deserve it", could blow up big time.

> And I don't see how "a definitive authoritarian streak, and a massive populist backing" are a problem.

I'm not sure how to respond to that.

If you mean that you don't see it as desirable, but also don't think that it's dangerous, I would like to remind you that this is something that has repeated many times in history in the past 100 years alone, and pretty much every time resulted in authoritarian societies, with all that entails - political dictatorships, massive human rights violations, and often, wars with neighbors.

If you mean that you actually see it as desirable, I don't think that we have sufficient common ground to meaningfully discuss this subject.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by foldr on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @09:23AM (#12539288)
>And I don't see how "a definitive authoritarian streak, and a massive populist backing" are a problem.

I can see how someone might have said that before the 20th century happened.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by goatlover on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:55PM (#12536430)
Doesn't this get said every single election, though?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by takeda on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:28PM (#12536809)
Yep, the thing different about this election that is that we really have two bad candidates that is hard to like. With previous elections even the candidates that were disliked and lost didn't seem as bad:

- Obama vs Romney

- Obama vs McCain

- Bush Jr vs Kerry

- Bush Jr vs Gore

- Clinton vs Dole

- Clinton vs Bush Sr

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by int_19h on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:30AM (#12537289)
Yes, it does. The difference is that this time it's actually true. And I say this as someone who was rooting for Ron Paul back in 2012.

Unfortunately, because this argument was abused so many times before, it's hard to convince people that this time is different.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jlj on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:33AM (#12537087)
I'm with you, Johnson all the way. Voting for someone who's positions I mostly align with, who would do the best job for our country with the least amount of drama. Not for the lesser of two evils, or to make sure the "other guy" doesn't win. That's not a protest vote.

If you haven't heard of Johnson Weld, please hear them out and at least watch their 60 Minutes interview from last night: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/60-minutes-libertarian-candidate...

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by monochromatic on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:49PM (#12536397)
I usually do like the Libertarian candidate better than the other options... but not this year.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mi100hael on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:51PM (#12536650)
What's not to like about "What's Aleppo?" Gary and his RINO running mate?
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jpfed on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:59PM (#12536948)
While he should have known, I actually think that asking that question was more admirable than attempting to BS his way through something he didn't know about.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mindcrime on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:31PM (#12536820)
That Aleppo thing is a total joke. If our foreign policy wasn't a complete joke, there would be no need for the President to know anything about Aleppo. As it is, it's still questionable if there's any reason for him/her to do so.

Keep in mind, Johnson is running for President, not Chief Cartographer.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mi100hael on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @11:15AM (#12540142)
The civil war in Syria has been one of the most critical situations in US foreign policy for several years now. It has consequences for the stability of the region and the rise or fall of IS, it has consequences for the security of Israel, a key ally, and it has consequences for how our modern relationship with Russia continues to develop.

You can call our foreign policy a joke, but it's inexcusable for someone running for the most powerful office in the world to not have even a cursory knowledge of it.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by plandis on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:25AM (#12537268)
There's just something off putting about having a president that doesn't keep up with current events.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by witty_username on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:27AM (#12538387)
The president can just lookup what Aleppo is.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jpfed on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:22PM (#12536541)
Easy- Duverger's Law. One of Clinton or Trump will be president. If you vote for one of those two people, you get to influence that outcome. I view voting as a strategic act, not a moral stand.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by mindcrime on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:29PM (#12536815)
Easy- Duverger's Law.

Keep in mind, "Duverger's Law" isn't a law in the same sense that gravity is. That is, it's more of an observation of how things usually are... it's not an inviolable fundamental principle of the universe.

If you vote for one of those two people, you get to influence that outcome.

You're not influencing the outcome when the outcome is the same in both cases.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by jpfed on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:57PM (#12536940)
Obviously the outcome won't literally be exactly the same. Whether we consider them to be "the same" in a practical sense depends on what we care about. Different people care about different things, so different people will disagree about how different the candidates are.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by tanderson92 on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @12:11AM (#12536990)
Unless the vote is decided by a handful of ballots, one must consider whether their vote has more utility as a protest ballot against the status quo.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by icantdrive55 on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:07PM (#12536484)
I really wanted to like Gary Johnson, but didn't.

I was going to vote for Hillary, but after Sander's success, she started making promises that just mimicked his. She is not going to bring jobs back to the United States.

I might not vote for a president this year. I feel kinda dizzy just writing that last sentance.

There's a small part of me that thinks if the right third party candidate/person, back by a ton of money, jumped into the race this week, he/she might win.

At this point, if Bill Maher jumped in; I would vote for him. Hell--if Jimmy Kimmel jumped in, I would vote for him.

I don't even know these two guys, but I trust they would try to do the right thing, or at least delegate to the right people.

I rember feeling a sence of doom when Regan was running, but the world was so different, and I was in high school.

As someone said before, this election is beyond weird.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by Pxtl on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:26PM (#12536557)
Bill Maher is an antivaxxer. Sorry.
Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by witty_username on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:23AM (#12538369)
> She is not going to bring jobs back to the United States.

And why is that important? The government can always lower the minimum wage to adjust the number of jobs if it decreases.

Re:House panel looking into Reddit post about Clinton's emai... by throwaway2016b on Monday September 19, 2016 @10:32PM (#12536580)
What is Aleppo?