Sounds like a way to prevent having to completely rewrite from the ground-up to keep up with the web a la angularjs.
I like React because it's a lot smaller but I totally see the advantages of Angular 2 and I kinda dig the major release cycle.
As soon as you rely on packages that support Angular 2, the 'good and ready' argument breaks, since you can't start till all the packages you rely upon have already made the upgrade, and you can't take to long either, because you can't expect further work or fixes to be made to older versions of the packages.
12-month breaking changes, that would have made sense.
That said, breaking changes every six months seems to be commonplace in major open source packages. My initial reaction was 'OMG, now they want to repeat the Angular 2 debacle every 6 months?!?', which doesn't seem to be the case.
The scope of the breaking changes matter more, and that story has yet to be told.
When? Can you cite an example? Keep in mind that for most breaking changes React typically goes to a deprecation warning for the duration of a major release instead of hard-breaking changes, so in reality you have roughly double the time between truly breaking releases, generally speaking.
That is true about the deprecation, although some of the earmarked breaking changes have been quite painful too.
Hopefully the Angular team takes this route for planned breaking changes & apply engineering to ease compatibility.
The more I reflect, the more I see this as about poor expectation management and messaging from the Angular team than an actual story.
http://tech.shantanugoel.com/2008/05/21/ubuntu-what-exactly-...
React releases every 6 months or so, and puts deprecation warning on anything that is breaking in the next update, so you have a full year between any breaking features, and six months for everyone to update before they land.
>Angular 2 is going to have breaking changes only every 6 months from now on. So the next one would be around February with Angular 3. Yes exactly, they’re also finally switching to semantic versioning which is a huge win in my opinion.
IMHO, breaking changes every six months is the recipe for an shitshow of an ecosystem.
http://juristr.com/blog/2016/09/ng2-released/