Re:The Zen of Passive Solar Heating Panel Design (2010)
by nkurz on Sunday September 18, 2016 @11:45PM
(#12528718)
It depends on your goals. One saying is that "a good window is still a poor wall". A quality double glazed window still has about 10x the heatloss of a well built wall. Here's a summary with a link to more: http://www.energyvanguard.com/blog-building-science-HERS-BPI...
Shades can help with privacy, but what if you want the privacy at the same time you want to be capturing heat? And if requires active control --- well, that's by definition not passive. Interestingly, the new movement in high efficiency houses is frequently for low solar gain windows: well insulated windows with special coatings to admit less heat while still admitting light.
From another standpoint, gigantic expanses of windows are rarely the best way to build a pleasant room. As well as being a rare crossover between Computer Science and Building Architecture, Christopher Alexander's "A Pattern Language" has lots to say on this. Some excerpts here: http://kk.org/cooltools/a-pattern-language/
Which is to say that opaque heat-gathering walls serve a purpose that is separate than that served by windows. Both have their place, and they don't tend to replace each other directly.
Shades can help with privacy, but what if you want the privacy at the same time you want to be capturing heat? And if requires active control --- well, that's by definition not passive. Interestingly, the new movement in high efficiency houses is frequently for low solar gain windows: well insulated windows with special coatings to admit less heat while still admitting light.
From another standpoint, gigantic expanses of windows are rarely the best way to build a pleasant room. As well as being a rare crossover between Computer Science and Building Architecture, Christopher Alexander's "A Pattern Language" has lots to say on this. Some excerpts here: http://kk.org/cooltools/a-pattern-language/
Which is to say that opaque heat-gathering walls serve a purpose that is separate than that served by windows. Both have their place, and they don't tend to replace each other directly.