Exactly! I didn't like the author's dig at rescaling algorithms, but he seems to be forgetting that pixels never looked like that! The pixel art he likes so much was never like what he does today. This article has good screenshots, although I think they're emulated:
http://www.tested.com/tech/gaming/2982-a-link-to-the-past-ho...
If you like pixel art, go ahead and make pixel art. Some of the artwork in the article is stunning, and I like the aesthetic a lot. However, don't romanticize it and claim that old games looked like that, because they just didn't.
I think better scalers and shaders that can reproduce the look of CRTs are a nice effort, since I want to play old games the way I actually remember them, not with visible pixels that were completely alien the first time I played Zelda on an emulator.
"We all get how pixels basically work. A computer divides a display into squares, and each square can be assigned one RGB value at a time. The total squares supported by the hardware is the device’s “resolution.” This square grid is the smallest possible subdivision of detail available to an artist."
This is the bit that's fundamentally wrong. Pixels are not squares. And never have been. They are "point samples". The fact that "magnified" pixel art displayed here compounds the error by displaying big squares rather than using an appropriate reconstruction filter doesn't help correct the misconception.
Here's a link to a classic paper on the topic: http://alvyray.com/Memos/CG/Microsoft/6_pixel.pdf
But... it's not pixel art anymore, it's square art. And if people want to create neo-pointilist/neo-divisionist artwork based upon a grid of coloured squares that's fine. But it's not pixels.
Here are some high quality CRT examples: http://imgur.com/a/Ad0pe
I have a theory what contributes to that 'blended' effect. Well, at least for the most part. It's the masking in-front of the beam. If you look at the sister comment here I made with portable AGS-101 screen from Gameboy SP, it's the same effect. Most prominent while moving. That (resolution) masking grid (with squares on LCD or oblongs on CRTs) somehow interacts with neighbouring pixels and blends all together. It's not from the composite signal, that's for sure. I know, because I run my consoles with RGB output and I still don't see that sharp look that doesn't look right.
What about the thousands of games for hand-held consoles, which have always used LCDs, and were using pixel art for much longer than their counterparts elsewhere out of sheer necessity?
(Especially when you're a kid and keep your nose mere inches off the screen.)
Your point stands in theory, but in practice it also doesn't look anything like pixel art on modern screens.
edit: to be clear, I'm mostly talking about the edges on the sprites. That's where it's most visible. It's not as clinical or smudged as on modern monitors / upscales.
Curse you, nostalgia. I definitely remember it being… pixel-y-ier. I stand corrected.
I think this is very insightful. I learned about this when setting up a home MAME arcade. The vector-graphic games looked perfect, but Space Harrier and other pixel-based games looked wrong to me, less impressive than I remembered as a kid. The forums told me I could try running a pixel-smudging mask to make the games look right, but it would be graphics-card-intensive. Instead, I went out and found an old used CRT monitor and everything looks great.
http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/KylePittman/20150420/241442/C...
http://i.imgur.com/Pq2Yra4.png
And if you ask how, the answer is: analog. Every transition was driven by the analog circuits, the phosphor response was analog. Analog all around, but especially to form the pixels one after another: all the transitions, response curves, persitences, dispersions working their own magic.
Great artists that worked in the medium knew how to make art within the restrictions of the medium that didn't look like it had been restricted by the medium; as great artists do in any medium.
Pixel art is a niche but it is still alive and I have been considering to investigate up-scaling methods that are more suitable for it.
For example there is a game OpenTTD (https://www.openttd.org) that is based on the pixel art and while attempts have been made to great higher resolution graphics based on the renders then most of these attempts, with some exceptions, have fallen flat. So people play with mixed graphics and such methods could make it more enjoyable if the up scaling of the lower resolution sprites would work better.
You can check out the forum https://www.tt-forums.net/viewforum.php?f=26 and mostly inactive http://www.simuscape.net/simutalk/index.php for examples of custom graphics made for this game (and older hack, TTDPatch).
But doing it on a rushed schedule is stressful and can suck.
I would love to see some more concrete examples of what you're stating as I an ignorant of that which you speak but super curious....
Can you please explain in pics what youre talking about?
There's another thing I want to mention. I have a broadcast-quality CRT with consoles of ye olde hooked up, and pixels you see on sprites, especially on the edges, aren't there on CRTs. Magical scanline blends them together and looking at the pixel art on CRT is different than on anything else. Almost like they are anti-aliased, but they're not (smudged). I think that's a key component today we are missing from enjoying pixel art. When it was dominant in game industry, you couldn't see actual pixels. Today, they are fetishised.