His discussion of core CPI and the remark that "average consumers who quickly point to the fact the food and energy are big part of their daily lives" is also wrong, and the reason for using core CPI is usually discussed in textbooks (e.g., http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/26/core-logic/). It has to do with the fact that people need to predict future price levels when signing current contracts, and thus having a volatile measure of inflation would not be a good thing.
For an example of how methodological issues can remain for a long time without being fixed, consider that the Dow Jones Industrial Average index is still an arithmetic average of share prices, not weighted by market capitalization like other indices. So fixing methodological issues is something worthwhile, and should be rewarded, not denounced as some kind of political manipulation.
Btw, here's a particularly egregious use of the logic: "oh, your cost of living isn't going up, because iPads are faster." http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-fed-dudley-ipad-idUSTR...
Incidentally, the larger category encompassing computers is 0.29% of the calculation of CPI, and it has only dropped to about 44% of prices in 2007.
There absolutely are problems with policy makers trying to starve the statistical agencies of funding for political reasons, but the actual public servants and economists conducting the work are pretty boring about just trying to model and describe the real economy.
It's even worth noting that possible improvements to the accuracy of CPI have been aborted due to political reasons, but the problem was that people's social security checks would have been revised down unless the existing law was changed.
In theory, yes. It takes a little more sophistication to realize that, in practice, "the iPad being faster" doesn't actually cancel the burden of higher food prices.
It seems unavoidable that how much nonfood I get per dollar affects the burden incurred by a dollar spent on food.
One could consider how spending on different areas has changed over time. In nominal terms, while we make about 48 times what we did in 1955, we now spend about 17 times what we did on food and on clothing, 56 times what we did on housing, and well over 200 times on healthcare. [1]
Considering that we spend about 70 times what we did on large entertainment goods such as televisions and sailboats, does that mean we are able to spend less on other areas? Does it mean that even though we used to have to spend a lot more of our income to own a TV we need to buy more stuff to be entertained?
Anyway, I don't really understand what the crowd in the article really wanted. Are they ultimately arguing that he should vote to raise rates, because there is inflation that he's missing by using the wrong indicators? I'm guessing that they're populists since an explanation made them angry, but googling doesn't tell me that populists have a consensus opinion about raising or lowering rates.
If they want another indicator to be used as a basis for official cost of living calculations for things like federal wages and social security payment increases, they're getting worked up at the wrong person.
So, to rephrase the point one other way, can you walk me through a scenario in which someone "came out even" because iPad speed went up as much as their food prices (with adjustment for value weight etc)? If you can't, then we're basically in agreement.
Yes, the Fed should treat differently-caused price drops differently. Velocity-related deflation is not the same as technological deflation, and central banks should be more concerned with the former.
If some miracle technology makes clothes require half the inputs, the Fed should not take it as a signal to debase the dollar that much more to accelerate spending, so yeah, if they're thinking inflation is low because there was iPad technological deflation, that does sound very much like "doing it wrong". Why do you disagree?
The cynic in me says that they simply record fractional portions of FTE and FTE takes on different values over time and across industries.
http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/lance-roberts/inf...
This is a natural consequence of tying social security (and other benefits) to inflation and Goodhart's Law:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
I've been meaning to do an analysis of inflation based on hours worked. It;s hard to redefine hours but I'm sure politicians will find a way!