The point is that there now exists backchannels between governments and corporations who control modern communication, and those backchannels are being used to censor anything.
The content of the messages does not matter one iota, they could have the best intentions in the world. The slippery slope is that we have people in power making decisions without checks and balances, and especially without the checks and balances we already have in place. Even assuming intentions pure as driven snow eventually those backchannels will be abused. It is a matter of when, not if.
That is the slippery slope.
1. Israel isn't censoring anything. They are offering to help Facebook identify content that FB already determined they will remove(inciting violence.)
2. Governments in every country already control communication, Working directly with Facebook is a step towards less government control, not more.
3. The article mentions that hate speech is a slippery topic, not slope. The article is NOT saying abuse might happen in the future, it is saying that determining what is hate speech or inciting violence is slippery implying its arbitrary and subjective...but inciting violence is not subjective at all IMHO, which all that is being discussed.
4. This idea that slippery slope and the importance of free speech is absolute is ridiculous! In my opinion, that all flies out the window when someones life is at stake. Period. Saving a Life is more important than theoretical slippery slopes.
Yes, abuse is always a risk, but in my opinion, I would rather elected officials, we can vote out, be the ones who we are trusting over a corporation that we have absolutely no say or control over.
Facebook's ability to manipulate, control and influence the world is WAY MORE TROUBLING TO ME THAN AN ELECTED (AND ACCOUNTABLE) OFFICIAL's ability to potentially abuse power!
Edit: added the word NOT to point 3.
This is a very sad thing, assuming that a life itself is the most valuable thing in the world.
The truth is: if you value your life more than your freedom then sooner or later you'll be made slave.
-Harriet Tubman
Perhaps if I experienced slavery, I would prefer death, but from where I sit now, I would rather be alive than dead, even if it meant not being free.
I can't imagine what my grandparents went through in concentration camps, but it seems to me that they did everything they could to survive...and I am grateful for that, otherwise, I wouldn't be here today!
I mentioned my grandparents in the context of freedom vs. dying...a very relevant point.
I wasnt talking about Israel in that comment nor did I invoke Judaism or the holocaust in its defense anywhere else.
However, considering how you went on the defensive to a point that wasnt relevant at all (this post isnt about liking Israel, it is about censorship and the limits of free speech)...
It really does beg the question if you dislike Israel for reasons other than the moral standards to invoke from your high horse...I dont know you so I have no opinions about your own prejudices, but I think you should take a hard look in the mirror...if only to be truthful to yourself.
Talk about slippery slope! Pulling the ideological taser the way you did is not just libelous, it is intellectually dishonest.
My comment was intended to be a real world example of someone choosing life in slavery over dying in response to the idea of "give me liberty or give me death"...
I reread my comment and can see how someone might misinterpret it as invoking the holocaust to defend the state of Israel. That was never my intention and does not reflect my viewpoints on Israel. I dont believe the holocaust or antisemitism has anything to do with the right of the state of Israel to exist.
I do however believe in Good and Evil.
You do however still need to apologize for accusing me of criticizing Israel out of antisemitism. You did it implicitly ("...reasons other...hard look in the mirror..") but it was clear enough that one other commenter has independently criticized you for it. It is for that reason that I have used the rather impolite adjective "deluded" in reference to you -- it's of course extremely common for supporters of Israel to accuse their critics of antisemitism, aiming that accusation at young western liberals who don't even remember the times when antisemitism was an issue in their societies. Those accusations are delusional, or just cynical deliberate inaccuracy; one or the other.
All that being said, to your point of delusion... > "when antisemitism was an issue in their societies"
Antisemitism IS STILL very much a problem today, even in the US.
Here is a quote from the FBI's Websites most recent hate crime statistics (2014)
Religious bias Of the 1,140 victims of anti-religious hate crimes:
56.8 percent were victims of crimes motivated by their offenders’ anti-Jewish bias.
https://ucr.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/hate-crime/2014/topic-...
---------------- > "it's of course extremely common for supporters of Israel to accuse their critics of antisemitism, aiming that accusation at young western liberals who don't even remember the times when antisemitism was an issue in their societies. Those accusations are delusional, or just cynical deliberate inaccuracy; one or the other."
The way I feel is that the belief that anti-semitism isn't relevant and tangled into peoples perception of Israel warrants the same criticism..." Those accusations are delusional, or just cynical deliberate inaccuracy; one or the other." ------------- Regardless, all things being equal...give two conflicting positions, both legitimate views based on how the issues are framed and perceived by each side, I would always err on the side of caution and saving a life...
This might be an unfair characterization or comparison(regardless, I ackowledge my own bias on this point)...but given the choice between wrongly accusing someone who is anti israel as antisemitic, versus the alternative of blindly ignoring signs that can lead to antisemitic violent hate crimes, such as we see over 500 times a year in the US alone (much worse in Europe), the choice to me is obvious...Hope for the best, but be prepared for the worst.
That might sound delusional and paranoid...and I can't disagree with that position from a logical standpoint...but, that doesn't change the reality that there were warning signs for years before the Holocaust, and it took years for the US to intervene despite reports about concentration camps...so, even if the position is seen by the world as crazy and that "the holocaust" could never happen again... forgive us paranoid Jews, from having a plan B...and trying to stop Anti-Semitism proactively, to the point of offending some liberals sensitivities about being accused of being a racist. ---------------------- All of this being said, I do apologize for implying your position against Israel is anti-semitic, clearly that isn't the case with you and maybe even with most liberals...but it's a mistake to think it's not the case with others, just because you are more sensible and reasonable.
----------------------- For what it's worth, the sooner both sides learn to recognize the sincerity and legitimacy of the other sides conflicting perspective, peace will never be achieved. We are all humans, we all have our biases, many of which we are not aware of...and there is a lot to improve on all sides... Israel is not above reproach, and the people who throw out antisemitic accusations against anyone who disagrees with Israel, is delusional...but that doesn't mean they aren't right some of the time...
Reminds me of the saying, "Just because I am paranoid, doesn't mean people aren't after me."
I am of course perplexed how you perceived that as libel, dishonest, and a slippery slope.
If you knew me, you would know that I was withholding judgement, just encouraging honest introspection...something I try to do constantly.
My value system puts human life above all else.
The only possible way to value and protect human life is to value and protect human rights, and that includes free speech. The minute you subsume those for safety (or as you put it, "human life", but we've also heard "for the kids", "terrorism", "immigrants", "communists", "monarchists", etc. etc.) you have not only given up your rights, but your life to the powers that be. And those powers do not have your best interests in mind.
These things are not separate, please do not turn this into a false dichotomy. We must protect both human rights and human life, but only by the acquiescence of our rights may they take our lives.
But, maybe I am just an evil person sacrificing the rights of the masses...
Which life?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_policy_doctrines_for_th...
Here, just concerning no 3:
There are different mechanisms by which speech is regulated. It's well accepted that you can be held responsible for your speech if it's illegal (i.e. defamation or the "FIRE!"-yelling classic).
This is different from censorship in that speech is regulated after it's published, not before.
It's also a widely-held misconception that life is more important than anything. Quick thought experiment:
- Current estimates are that costs about 38,000$ to save a life for the most efficient NGOs.
- Say the US presidential election costs about 5 billion.
=> Should we cancel the election or let those 125,000 people die?
These backchannels exist between all governments and all media outlets.
Wasting my breath because this comes up so often, but this is not in any way true.
I agree with you though.
Even that is arguably not true. The only real responsibility of a director is to not act in his or her own self interest to the detriment of the company.
http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/8146/are-u-s-com...
I guess my first point would be that I said, "fiduciary responsibility" not legal obligation.
I really loved this quote at the end... "the idea that good decisions are the product of orderly processes – is more alive than ever in public affairs. ...There is not, and never will be, such a science. Our objectives are typically imprecise, multifaceted and change as we progress towards them – and properly so. Our decisions depend on the responses of others, and on what we anticipate these responses will be. The world is complex and imperfectly known, and this will remain true however much we analyse it."
https://www.hillaryclinton.com/post/donald-trump-pepe-the-fr...
Real hate speech and real inciting of violence is obvious to the naked eye. It doesn't need a house of cards built under it to come into focus.
Edit: Just to be clear, the original article says nothing about Israel helping censor hate speech, just speech that incites violence. There is nothing slippery or subjective about "calling on the public to stab Israeli's and Jews in the streets"
naive
It's not naive, but a well-executed damage-control move to detract attention away from Mrs Clinton's health problems. The ludicrousness of discussing frogs close to the election of the world's sole superpower is part of the effectiveness of the move.
This story does everything other than show a single example of hate speech and inciting violence posts being a "slippery concept" or a single example of Israel asking for something to be removed that doesnt directly incite violence.
I cant imagine someone thinking a video of a cleric waving a knife telling his followers to stab Jews or of little kids being taught to stab jews as being slippery or possibly interpreted as not inciting violence.
The only thing mentioned is that Israel will help Facebook identify violence inciting posts...not hate speech, not political speech, strictly violence inciting posts...and the Author goes out on a massive limb to paint a picture of censorship and abuse of power and finger pointing at other offenders... remove any calls to violence...especially when you can directly link it to actual violence!
Edit: updated quotes