News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by aero142 on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:18PM (#1248185)
It seems the article misses the point of outings with the boys. Men tend not to bring things up unless there is some discussion about how to fix it. 4 dudes can't fix someone's health problems, but they can go fishing, which at least makes the now pretty good, even though the immediate future might not be. Having good people around you reminds you that if you did come across something that could be fixed, the guy next to you in the fishing boat would help out.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by yalurker on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:31PM (#1248213)
Exactly! If the wife in the story wanted to know why her husband didn't talk about any of the various men's problems on their fishing trip, she could have just asked the rhetorical question "how would talking about the problem while fishing make the problem go away?"

I will talk to a friend about a problem only if they can help solve it. I have absolutely no desire to try to get empathy or sympathy.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by callahad on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:11PM (#1248306)
I will talk to a friend about a problem only if they can help solve it.

Huh. I find that talking to many and sundry friends about problems helps me to understand the problem. Something about refining how I articulate the issue helps me organize it in my mind, which in turn informs any action I may take.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by cwp on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:22PM (#1248598)
Wouldn't that qualify as "only if they can help solve it?"
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by roundsquare on Thursday April 08, 2010 @12:50AM (#1249166)
Exactly. If its "I'm trying to find a new job but I don't get past the resume point" your friends can help.

If its "I have bone cancer and I'm doing to die in a few years" there's nothing your friends can do to solve the problem.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by dgabriel on Thursday April 08, 2010 @06:20AM (#1249538)
They can't solve the cancer, but there are a plethora of other problems they can help solve on the way. Having a terminal illness introduces a great number of issues, and sometimes just talking helps determine the problem space.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:37PM (#1248382)
Based on your last line, I am 99% certain you are male.

I'm much the same way. It can make relationships hard. I have to remember that women typically get mad at me if they tell me of troubles and I try to help them solve them. I have to remember they only want sympathy, not a solution, no matter how simple the solution might be.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by UmYeah on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:56PM (#1248426)
I never realized this until I was living in a house with 3 girls. One day, one of them walks in a starts telling me about some problems she was having with her boyfriend. I gave her my advice on the situation.

She responded by telling me that whenever anyone comes to me with problems, I try to give them an answer (why else would they be coming to me, right?!?). She told me people don't always want solutions to their problems, they just want someone to listen to them. She didn't apply this to only girls, as some guys I know seem to deal with their problems in the same way. This is something I still don't really understand but this article sheds a little light on the subject.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by DaniFong on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:18PM (#1248474)
I think one of the problems is that the solutions people offer usually don't make sense for some reason, possibly complex, emotion driven, with a lot of past history that's difficult to reveal, and difficult to communicate. Offering a solution that ignores all of these issues, which are likely present but would take days to untangle, seems slightly arrogant and ignorant, and thus annoying. Often times the advisees are too nice to explicitly say that the solution doesn't make sense, or are too reserved to explain the reasons why it doesn't make sense, so they just get annoyed. This annoys the advisors, who just want to help.

This isn't confined to boys and girls. Imagine parents saying -- "Kids! Do X! It is good for you!" The response is of course "but you don't understand me!"

This is the problem. It's hard to hear advice from someone you don't think understands you. For whatever reason, boys in this culture have a lower threshold for giving advice (though who knows who's more likely to actually take it).

The process of being listened to isn't mere venting. Being able to tell your story helps you to understand it. The solutions you come to will be your own, and you'll feel more confident about enacting them. Hardly anyone follows advice anyway; the storytelling and listening process seems just as a effective as a collective decision making strategy as giving advice directly.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by joelhaus on Thursday April 08, 2010 @01:02AM (#1249181)
Well put.

To take this a step further, one can actively listen. By asking the right questions (frequently, posing them in an open ended way; using the word "how" is effective), you can encourage the person to examine their problem from a different perspective. The other benefit is that you gain a better understanding as a result.

Therapists commonly use this approach.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by stavrianos on Friday April 09, 2010 @12:18AM (#1251854)
It's terrifically easy to solve a problem you know next-to-nothing about.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by mattm on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @09:05PM (#1248858)
This is pretty typical with women from my experience. What many women fail to realise is that few things are more frustrating to a guy than being presented with a problem and not being given the opportunity to solve it. If a women does this too many times to a guy, eventually the guy will avoid talking to her because she is making him feel useless.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by ajuc on Thursday April 08, 2010 @01:41PM (#1250326)
If guy understand that women needs this he can manage to listen and not give advices, and to not become frustrated with all these "unsolvable" problems.

This is a matter of points of view - for men (esp. programmers) problem solving POV is the default, but they can switch to just listening from time to time, if the women doesn't charge them responsible for these problems.

It works the other way too - if some "on the spot advice" slips from me when I listen to my wife she shouldn't be angry - I didn't meant to dismiss her, sometimes I just can't help it.

A little understanding and everything is much simpler.

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by dkarl on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @10:29PM (#1248976)
Heh, that's the simple case. The weird cases are when there's no literal truth that will properly reflect their feelings, so they just start saying whatever random stuff reflects their feelings. For example, I was talking about people at work and happened to mention a female name, so my girlfriend said, "Does she make more money than me? Did you sleep with her?" That meant she was a little insecure about being unemployed, and I should try to support her by not making any reference to the fact that there are, in fact, women with jobs.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by TheSOB88 on Friday April 09, 2010 @10:47AM (#1252804)
Seriously, if she's so insecure about being unemployed, she should maybe get a job, not try to control what you talk about. Am I missing something here?
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by TheSOB88 on Thursday April 08, 2010 @12:58AM (#1249177)
What a crazy bint.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by AndrewDucker on Thursday April 08, 2010 @09:32AM (#1249779)
People mostly know the answers to their problems already. Certainly with social ones, they mostly know what they ought to be doing, but they don't necessarily have the emotional strength to actually do it. Feeling listened to and supported helps them to feel more comfortable and motivated so that they can then get out there and do it.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by dkarl on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @10:30PM (#1248979)
Heh, that's the simple case. The weird cases are when there's no literal truth that will properly reflect their feelings, so they just start saying whatever random stuff reflects their feelings. For example, I was talking about people at work and happened to mention a female name, so my girlfriend said, "Does she make more money than me? Did you sleep with her?" That meant she was a little insecure about being unemployed, and I should try to support her by not making any reference to the fact that there are, in fact, women with jobs.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by Dellort on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:02PM (#1248441)
They want me to listen, I want them to shut the hell up. I think they should compromise and shut the hell up.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by cubix on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @08:20PM (#1248788)
I will talk to a friend about a problem only if they can help solve it.

How can you determine if he can solve it without talking to him about it first?

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by teuobk on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:38PM (#1248384)
Interesting that you should mention the "everything is a problem to be solved" point. I had always considered that to be just "an engineer thing," but now that I think about it, most of my male friends are engineers, and most of my engineer friends are male.

Also, are you implying that you'd like to work out a solution for your broken fishing boat? :)

Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by kowen on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:09PM (#1248458)
The female engineers I know seem to approach "everything as a problem to be solved" too.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by sigstoat on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:39PM (#1248509)
engineering school tends to fix you like that.
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by carterschonwald on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:18PM (#1248326)
this problem solving motivated sharing is more accurately the key difference! What I wonder is why is not more often the focus of these articles?
Re:Why Men's Friendships Are Different by afterburner on Thursday April 08, 2010 @03:50AM (#1249392)
At least stand-up comics got the message long ago.