News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:52PM (#12476331)
My feeling is that Iran is a far better natural ally of the United States than Saudi Arabia. The average Iranian is probably far more amenable to western liberal values than the average person from Saudi Arabia.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by hguant on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:46PM (#12476492)
Iran was THE ally of the United States until the Revolution. We didn't trust the Israelis, who made it very clear they were in it for themselves, the Saudis in the 60's and 70's were not very amenable to US interests - Iran was a stable, regional power with a westernized populace and enough power to counterbalance Soviet influence and Middle Eastern stubbornness. They were such an important ally that when they elected a moderately socialist president who didn't want to play the Cold War game, the US and UK freaked out and installed a monarch.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by Chathamization on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:54PM (#12476727)
That's not accurate. Mohammad Reza Pahlavi became Shah in 1941, after his father was forced to abdicate by the British and Russians. The CIA certainly worked with the Shah to remove Mosaddegh from power (in 1953), but this didn't happen right after he became prime minister (he wasn't elected per se, but appointed by the Shah and approved by the legislature). Rather, this came about after a long and complex political struggle (both internal and external), the end of which saw Mosaddegh dissolving the legislature and gaining emergency powers including the power to personally create laws by fiat.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by eternalban on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:26PM (#12476822)
> The US and UK freaked out and installed a monarch.

This propaganda story of the West needs to die. (They never forgave the Shah for being critical of them in the 70s and to this date their media lists this poor man as one of the "worst tyrants of 20th century". Same century that gave us Stalin, Hitler, Mao, PolPot, .... The man was a saint compared to most world leaders, then and now.)

No one installed a monarch in Iran. The late Shah of Iran, who very much cared for Iran, was indeed permitted to succeed his father, Reza Shah ("the great"), by the occupying Alied powers (who had invaded the neutral Iran). This 'transition' to nominal power 'permitted' by external powers that occupied the entirety of Iran is a fact of Iranian history. (In fact, before accepting CIA/NYTimes account of '53 and the Shah of Iran, you may want to read up on the history of Iran from 1850 to 1950.)

From that date, until the counter-coup of 1953 in which US and UK participated alongside quite a substantial subset of Iranian society, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi stayed well within the limits of Iranian constitution's limits on royal power. One noteworthy aspect of being the Shah of Iran under the constitutional regime was the ability to appoint and dismiss the Prime Minister.

Dr. Mossadegh, a member of the Majlis (people's assembly) was indeed put forward by that body as the Prime Minister and the Shah did formally appoint him. After the good Dr. managed to alienate most of his internal allies -- the Mullahs and the Communist Party of Iran -- he assumed dictatorial powers. He even ran an election with "99%" yes vote for his assuming such powers. That is the famous "election" the propaganda organs of the West keep mentioning.

The Shah dismissed the Dr. from his office. The Dr. refused to accept this, contrary to the constitution of Iran. The Shah feared for his life, and fled. And meanwhile back in Iran, elements of Iranian military, landed gentry, Mullahs, etc. who no longer supported the (dismissed) Prime Minister organized a counter coup. So, New York Times notwithstanding, little Kermit Roosevelt did not all by his lonesome and a suitcase full of dollar bills create a coup to "install" the legal, standing, Shah of Iran.

What happend to the Shah after '53, was that he had decided to push for stability in Iran and began to overstep the constitutional limits. It was during this period that Iran went from helpless victim of the insatiable greed of the British and ambitions of the Russians to a healthy state. It was only then that Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi accepted coronation.

And the apparently alarming development of Iran actually got to the point that Iran began to loom as a strategic threat to Western hegemony in the Persian Gulf, having taken over the security role of British in the Persian Gulf with America's blessing and material support; establishing OPEC as a power player; and having publicly announced in '73 that "in 1979" when the oil contracts forced on a bankrupt Iran in '53 reached their term, that Iran would no longer accede to the aggregious demands of the Western Oil Cartel (the famous "seven sisters"). Surprisingly enough, it was precisely in 1979 that "revolution" broke out in Iran and BBC Persian service kindly began announcing the Ayatollah's messages and demonstration schedule. (Fact.)

No one installed our King. Good and bad, warts and all, he was OUR King, our Shahanshah, and we Iranians accept full responsibility for the matter.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by hguant on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:02PM (#12482642)
This was a really interesting and educational post. Thanks for taking the time to lay it all out.

Yes, you are right that I glossed over a lot of the details of what happened in 1953. I thought this was appropriate given the context of the broader point I was trying to address - namely, the huge strategic importance of Iran to the West.

This is kind of a big problem I have with talking about politics and history - either you gloss over important details to make a point, or you have to write a book. I think the myth of Kermit Roosevelt and his bag of money endures, not (just) because of propaganda, but because it is 'true enough' - it serves to put a national event within the regional context of the decline of British/rise of American influence, and the global narrative of the Cold War.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by pawadu on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:36AM (#12478065)
What a load of crap! Seems like this poor king of yours didn't do much wrong. I wonder why wikipedia claims the whole country united to get rid of him:

On March 30 and 31 (Farvardin 10, 11) a referendum was held over whether to replace the monarchy with an "Islamic Republic" – a term not defined on the ballot. Khomeini called for a massive turnout[193] and only the National Democratic Front, Fadayan, and several Kurdish parties opposed the vote.[193] It was announced that 98.2% had voted in favor.[193]

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by fit2rule on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:10AM (#12478990)
History is written by the winners. Perhaps the OP you're responding to, actually lived through these events and have their own opinion on the matter, not derived from a dubious collective source but rather through personal observation.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by pawadu on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:47AM (#12479200)
edit: here is the wikipedia article about the coup, see how bad it aligns with eternalban's view of the events https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Mosaddegh
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by eternalban on Friday September 16, 2016 @02:19AM (#12512211)
Part 4 [4] of this series directly discusses the propaganda regarding these events. Unlike pawadu, I do not consider wikipedia to be a definitive source, but the talk page [5] should provide some insight regarding the tug of war that this page must have gone through! ;)

[1]: http://iranian.com/main/2010/jul/all-shahs-men-0.html

[2]: http://iranian.com/main/2010/aug/all-shahs-men-2.html

[3]: http://iranian.com/main/2010/aug/all-shahs-men-3.html

[4]: http://iranian.com/main/2010/aug/all-shahs-men-part-4-1.html

[5]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Mohammad_Mosaddegh

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by tamana on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:01PM (#12476540)
So, Iran was more trustworthy, even though the US felt it necessary to depose their leader? How does that make sense?
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by spikels on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:18PM (#12476603)
That was in 1953 and lead by the British, not the U.S.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dredmorbius on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:11AM (#12477135)
Lead by the Brits, yes, but the US were in deep. Rather too deep as it turned out.

Damnit, Kermit!

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIpm_8v80hw&t=4m38s

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by karma_vaccum123 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:36PM (#12476652)
Not necessarily true. The United States was indeed involved, orchestrated in part by the grandson of a former US President.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by spikels on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:50PM (#12476711)
What part of my comment is "Not necessarily true"? Seems you did not know that the coup was lead by the British.

From the Wikipedia article you linked:

"Classified documents show that British intelligence officials played a pivotal role in initiating and planning the coup"

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dredmorbius on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:20AM (#12477164)
If you're agreeing that the US was involved in the Mossedegh coup, it's only sufficient to say so. Not to insist in apparent contradiction of that fact that the effort was led by what Noam Chomsky calls the junior partner in the Middle East, Britain.

Yes, Britain precipitated the effort. The US, however, enabled its success.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by spikels on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:19AM (#12477600)
Everyone already "knows" the US was "involved" in the 1953 coup but very little more. Britain was not the junior partner - as you say Chomsky thinks - but the instigator of the entire operation.

Britain has been deeply involved in the Persia/Iran for hundreds of years including multiple occupations and coups. In 1921 the British installed original Shah Pahlavi, father of the Shah Pahlavi deposed in the 1979 revolution. And before Pearl Harbor brought the US into WWII the British - in cooperation with the Soviet Union! - occupied Iran.

If Britian had not been weakened by WWII and terrible economic policy it is unlikely that they would have spent a year begging the US to assist them in Iran. Until this time the US had little involvement in the region.

We luckily live in a time (post 2013) when you can read the CIA's own fascinating history of the event:

http://nsarchive.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB435/

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dredmorbius on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:48PM (#12481900)
I'd slightly misspoken: it's not Chomsky, but the British foreign office itself which coined the "junior partner" label, Chomsky merely notes the fact:

"Well, the US took over from Britain in the Middle East and, in fact, much of the world, after the Second World War. In fact actually, replaced Britain and France. France was summarily expelled— they weren’t given the time of day. Britain however, was given a role. It was given the role of “junior partner”, as the British foreign office rather ruefully described it, accurately. Britain was going to be our lieutenant— the fashionable word is “partner”— as they were described by a senior adviser in the Kennedy administration. That’s reasonably accurate— you’re seeing an example of it right now. The lieutenant is doing its job— the attack-dog, maybe."

https://chomsky.info/19990404/

"U.S. Middle East Policy", Noam Chomsky (1999).

Your CIA reference supports my and others' in this thread essential claim: "Recently, the CIA has declassified a number of records relating to the 1953 coup, including a version of an internal history that specifically states the agency planned and helped implement the coup."

The matter of the British instigating the action isn't in question, and hasn't been questioned. The relative roles of the US and British -- applied, again, to the middle east as a whole, by the British foreign office itself, is. You have been profoundly insensitive to this distinction.

I do appreciate the CIA document reference.

You seem to think you're arguing with me over something. Unfortunately, half of what you're arguing is over things I didn't say or misreadings of things I did say. The other half is over points of agreement.

Both are tiresome.

I doubt this conversation will progress, so will leave this as my final comment.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by banku_brougham on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:03PM (#12476548)
one of the greatest failings of the US 'intelligence' aparatus.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by ionised on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @10:42AM (#12488654)
In a long and prolific history of failings.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by ars on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:00PM (#12476355)
> My feeling is that Iran is a far better natural ally of the United States than Saudi Arabia.

That's probably true except for Israel. The government of SA is more or less neutral toward Israel, not so the government of Iran.

Interestingly the exact opposite is true of the people of Iran vs SA. I believe the average person in Iran hates Israel less than the average person in SA.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by handedness on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:50PM (#12476506)
> That's probably true except for Israel.

Jews and Persians are natural allies, and have been allied in the past: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran–Israel_relations

It's not out of the realm of possibility that as shale production diminishes the importance of both the House of Saud and the declining declining value of Russian energy exports, Israel pivots back to Iran. Many sharp analysts predicted the US's pivot to Iran for over half a decade before it visibly started to happen, and many of those same analysts don't subscribe to the prevailing media narrative that Iran's religion necessarily constrains it to alignment with Arab nations, rather than Israel or the US.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by tamana on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:03PM (#12476547)
Alliances from kingdoms of 2000 years ago aren't very useful.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by labster on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:51PM (#12476714)
I know 2000 years ago was so different, let's see:

- China was run by the Han, and trade with China was very important for the West.

- Western Europe was part of a large power bloc, using the same money (with border struggles in Britannia).

- Judea was a gyre of instability that bedeviled the West and sucked them into middle east conflicts.

- Egypt had the strongest military in all of Africa.

Physical geography determines a lot of cultural geography; similar power dynamics replay over generations.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by M2Ys4U on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:08PM (#12476942)
"History doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme".
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by labster on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:25AM (#12477177)
Actually rhyming is a question I don't know the answer to: is the character for Han dynasty the same as for what are called Han Chinese people today? I'm not sure if I was punning or describing the same ethnic group.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by gfaure on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:35AM (#12477217)
Yes -- the name of the Han people and the name of the logographic script Hanzi are both meant to recall the golden age of the Han dynasty.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by asolove on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:48PM (#12476701)
No, but the pattern is: if you and I live on both sides of a troublesome neighbor, we will probably get along.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by handedness on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:14AM (#12494751)
I disagree with that, but no matter: Iran and Israel have allied as recently as the 20th century, right up until the end of the Pahlavi dynasty in 1979.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by ekianjo on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:22PM (#12476422)
Funny how the whole agenda for the region is set by Israel and not the US themselves.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by cobookman on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:29PM (#12476439)
Disagree. Its a complex game. If the US pisses off Israel there one true friendly in the middle east is gone. Israel's presence and allegance in the middle east gives the US a bigger military influence into the region.

In regards to game theory it's better for the US to have Israel as an ally and make an enemy of Iran than the opposite. Don't forget that Israel has nuclear weapons and the country would not hesitate to use them in self defense. Also while the Saudi's are scum, you'd have a situation worse than Iraq if you removed them from power.

In the end there's no great answer, just one that has a not as worse outcome.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by enraged_camel on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:51PM (#12476507)
>>If the US pisses off Israel there one true friendly in the middle east is gone.

I'm not sure I'd call Israel a "true friend." At a high level they may be ideologically aligned with the West, but they're simply using the USA to advance their own interests.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by tamana on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:04PM (#12476549)
Which countries are true friends of any other? Is US true friends of any?
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by mangeletti on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:22PM (#12476615)
Good question :/
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by ionised on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @10:46AM (#12488704)
No.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by forgotpwtomain on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:35PM (#12476461)
> Don't forget that Israel has nuclear weapons and the country would not hesitate to use them in self defense.

Pakistan also has nuclear weapons, Israel's use as such is probably mutually assured destruction, not 'self-defense'.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by mhluongo on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:38PM (#12476469)
Didn't the US originally provide those nuclear weapons?
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dtnewman on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:50PM (#12476503)
Actually, the US didn't have much to do with Israel's early development of nuclear weapons. It was the French who helped them setup a nuclear reactor originally. They also had many (Jewish) former Soviet scientists who fled to Israel. The strong US-Israel military relationship is a more recent development.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by mhluongo on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:32AM (#12479961)
I should've included a "I have no idea what I'm talking about" disclaimer. Thanks for the info, just read a bit more about it.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by sangnoir on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:15AM (#12477147)
> Didn't the US originally provide those nuclear weapons?

Developed independently of the US[1], in cooperation with the apartheid government of South Africa. South Africa went on to become the first (if not only) country to voluntarily give up it's nuclear weapons program, right on the cusp of black rule.

Officially, the US does not/will not acknowledge Israel's nuclear capability.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by mhluongo on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:35AM (#12479999)
It sounds like France and the UK both played a part in early nuclear weapons development in Israel as well.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by astrodust on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:26PM (#12476432)
If there was no oil in the region the US wouldn't care and Israel would be a non-factor.

Since there is oil, the US needs reliable partners. Saudi Arabia (totalitarian regime with an abysmal human rights record) and Israel (actively engaging in war crimes and apartheid) are the best America can manage.

Saudi Arabia has more money than they know what to do with, and they're easily placated by selling them advanced weapons. Israel is on a much tighter budget and is more militarily vulnerable so they need a lot more help. That they've pissed off everyone in their immediate environment doesn't help, either.

Sadly, pre-revolution Iran and pre-civil war Lebanon were vibrant, flourishing countries. Then some geo-political meddling went down and here we are, a total mess.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by slv77 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:22PM (#12476809)
Israel has an outsized role in US politics for reasons that have nothing to do with oil. In fact the US ability to maneuver in the Middle East would have been significantly less constrained with oil producing countries if Israel wasn't an ally.

The US was initially a reluctant ally with Israel. The Soviet Union was actively arming Israel's Arab neighbors and fanning the flames of war to win influence with oil producing Arab states. At the same time the US had embargoes on selling arms to Israel because it was reluctant to fan the flames of war and also to antagonize Israel's Arab neighbors.

Unbeknownst to the US Israel had developed a nuclear weapons capability and at the start of the Six Day war Israel felt threatened enough to deploy them. In what must have been an interesting phone call Israel informed the US both of their nuclear weapons capability and that they were going to nuke Cairo. In order to dissuade Israel from this course of action the US promised swift delivery of modern anti-tank weapons and depleted their Western European inventory of these weapons. This helped turn the tide of the conflict and reduce potential of a nuclear exhange in the Middle East.

The result of the Six Day War was that the US committed to keeping Israel at par with its Arab neighbors conventional military capabilities if Israel would keep its nuclear capability in check.

A great writeup of the history is here:

http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/cpc-pubs/farr.htm

This still plays an active role in the US and Israeli relationship and was even a factor in the negotiations over the Iranian nuclear program but the nuances are rarely picked up by the US press.

Israel also plays an outsized role in US politics because it is an influential issue with Jewish voters and also, oddly, Evangelicals. Evangelicals see the establishment of a Jewish State in Israel as a prerequisite to the rapture and the Second Coming of Jesus Christ.

Great article on how the delicate compromises in the Middle East were almost toppled by a cow:

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/apocalypse/rea...

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dogma1138 on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:49AM (#12479628)
If you are going to post so much material read it at least, it wasn't until the after the Six Day war when Israel had even began to build it's nuclear arsenal, by 67 it barely had amassed enough plutonium to build even a single weapon.

Also there was no need for Israel to use it's nuclear weapons during the Six Day war, it destroyed the Egyptian Air Force within the first 5 hours of the war.

I think you are confusing a lot of "facts" here, your story might fit more with the 1973 war, but during that war if were the soviets who've actively moved theater level nuclear weapons into Egypt and the US had put pressure on Israel to stop it's advancement.

Overall if you read slightly better sources you would see that the Six Day war actually pushed the Israeli weapon program back, France have stopped the cooperation with Israel and the knock-out victory that the Israelis have dealt to the combined forces of Egypt, Jordan and Syria as as gaining control over the Sinai Peninsula which meant that Egypt can no longer blockade Israel as it lost the controls over the straits of Tiran made the need for a bomb not as urgent.

The nuclear program has really stepped up after the 1973 war both because Israel decided that the added geographical depth of the Sinai wasn't sufficient and because the Soviets have actually pushed weapons into the theater which meant that Israel needed a MAD option and quickly.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by slv77 on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:37PM (#12482948)
It has been a couple of years since I last read through the material and confused the Six Day War with the Yom Kippur War. Another correction is that while the Soviet Union was supplying Syrian and Egyptian forces it wasn't a war that the Soviet Union instigated (unlike the Six Day War).

For those who don't want to wade through the bulk of the material (which is still fascinating) the relevant history begins is Section III of the document and relevant sections condensed below:

Defense Minister Moshe Dayan, obviously not at his best at a press briefing, was, according to Time magazine, rattled enough to later tell the prime minister that “this is the end of the third temple,” referring to an impending collapse of the state of Israel. “Temple” was also the code word for nuclear weapons... The Israelis assembled 13 twenty-kiloton atomic bombs. U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger was notified of the alert several hours later on the morning of 9 October....

Israeli commandos flew to Fort Benning, Georgia to train with the new American TOW anti-tank missiles and return with a C-130 Hercules aircraft full of them in time for the decisive Golan battle. American commanders in Germany depleted their stocks of missiles, at that time only shared with the British and West Germans, and sent them forward to Israel.

Thus started the subtle, opaque use of the Israeli bomb to ensure that the United States kept its pledge to maintain Israel's conventional weapons edge over its foes. There is significant anecdotal evidence that Henry Kissinger told President of Egypt, Anwar Sadat, that the reason for the U.S. airlift was that the Israelis were close to “going nuclear.”

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dogma1138 on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:42PM (#12482992)
If you relying on the USAF document don't, it's not even that well researched, the fact that it was published in a USAF publication doesn't mean much, this is editorial/thesis level of analysis not a policy paper or official NSC briefing.

The timeline of all of these events do not make any sense and are with odds with official declassified Israeli and US documents.

The TOW missile part is especially humourous.

P.S. By the time the first US airlift has landed in Israel, the Israelis have already broken through the Egyptian lines, the 2nd Egyptian army was surrounded and cut off and the Israelites crossed the Suez canal. Overall the reason the US agreed for the airlift was because the soviets were already running airlifts into Egypt and the US did not want to risk the soviets deciding to commit troops (well other than "advisers").

Recent declassified documents about the CIA briefings to Nixon also show that the Soviet actually transported nuclear material into Egypt during the 1973 war, this was what put the US on high alert, and it's also the reason why they sent their SR-71's over Israel and the Sinai and the pressing the Israeli government to hold their advance or they'll release the photographs to the UN. http://edition.cnn.com/2016/08/26/opinions/secret-briefings-...

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by astrodust on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:46PM (#12476872)
"...for reasons that have nothing to do with oil"

"...win influence with oil producing Arab states..."

Yeah, nothing to do with oil.

It's all about oil. That whole area is about oil. A case could be made that World War I was about oil, that British naval supremacy depended on it, and everything since then is a mostly direct cascade from that.

Also don't forget that the extreme Evangelicals believe that the establishment of and subsequent destruction of Israel is a necessary precursor to the Rapture. What a psychotic viewpoint.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by alnoxs on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:19AM (#12477162)

  "...for reasons that have nothing to do with oil"
  "...win influence with oil producing Arab states..."
This is cherry picking sentence fragments to produce a misleading statement. The GP clearly states that US involvement in Israel was to avoid Israel using a nuclear weapon, not because of any interest in oil.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by astrodust on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:39AM (#12477424)
The US has had an interest in Israel long before nuclear weapons were a factor.

Stability is only a concern because of the critical suppliers there. Notice how little interest is paid to places like central Africa where, apart from Nigeria, there's no productive oil fields.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by maxthegeek1 on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:41AM (#12477860)
It's not as if we care about war crimes. The US has, and continues to commit greater war crimes than Israel could ever hope to.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by rbanffy on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:29AM (#12478035)
Sadly, it's evident they are working hard o that.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by wcummings on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:48PM (#12476700)
>The government of SA is more or less neutral toward Israel

And SA opposes Hezbollah.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:30PM (#12476444)
Iran is the inverse of most middle eastern countries. The elites in Iran hold anti-western sentiments while the common people are a little more liberal in their views towards America. Most middle eastern countries have the situation reversed.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by Camillo on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:43PM (#12476680)
Not quite. Fundamentally, pre-revolutionary Iran had (and modern Iran still seems to have) the same pattern as other middle-eastern countries: a Westernized, liberal-friendly urban middle-upper class, and a traditionalist, Islam-focused lower-class and rural population. And, as is also typical, the westernized component overestimated its own strength. Many of them actually supported the revolution, expecting that it would bring a democratic or perhaps socialist government (remember, socialism is also a Western ideology). Instead they got swept over by the Islamist faction, which had the support of the masses.

This happens over and over in the Middle East. Syria is the most recent example. The urban middle class revolted against Assad hoping for democracy, but instead their war got completely taken over by the much more powerful islamists. Now they are between a rock and a hard place.

If you have any middle eastern friends, they are probably quite modern, liberal and friendly to Western values. I know mine are. But there is a strong selection bias there. The real "common people" don't go to study in a European university.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by amckinlay on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:52PM (#12476512)
Iran is effectively our ally already. Both of us are aiding the same Shia militias in Iraq (the US through the Iraqi government).
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by lottin on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:10PM (#12476384)
I have the same impression. Unfortunately the Saudis have the oil and that makes them valuable allies. Whereas Iran is basically at war with Israel, which means the US will never be able to be in good terms with them.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:26PM (#12476431)
To be fair, Iran is the largest exporter of religiously inspired terrorism in the world, bar none. No other country has a deep institutional commitment to cultivating and supplying terrorism that can match Iran.

Edit: I'd encourage all the downvotes butt hurt by this truth to learn a little more about the Iranian Revolutionary Guard and the Quuds forces. No other country has a special forces dedicated to cultivating, training and supply in terrorists worldwide (groups like Hamas and Hezbollah are only two examples out of many). We're not talking a one-off phenomena, rather a multi-decade program that has split the world into sectors and has dedicated special forces in each area. This is why you have IRG trying to cultivate Islamic extremism in Venezuela, and bombings of Jewish community centers in Argentina. It's literally not a contest; Iran has been the most skilled and successful sponsor of religious terrorism in the world.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by xenadu02 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:28PM (#12477003)
That's a bit glib; much like the USA there are a wide variety of opinions and what the conservative-leaning government chooses to do doesn't necessarily align with what the people want.

In Iran that is due to the Ayatollah Khomeini and his crew. (Nominally he isn't a dictator, in theory he is, in reality there are politics and practical considerations.)

In the USA, it is due to Republican gerrymandering (total votes cast for Senate and House slightly favor Democrats, but they don't hold majorities in either house. Same for state legislatures - half of the republican controlled states had majority votes for Democrats).

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:59AM (#12477290)
I was responding to the notion that the US doesn't like Iran, I was hoping to elucidate some reasons as to why.
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by tomjen3 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:54PM (#12476899)
That's extremely hard to believe given that 9/11 was most likely paid for by official Saudi money and that it is well known that they have exported tons of people to Syria and Isis
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:18AM (#12477356)
I disagree with the supposition 9/11 was proven to be a state sponsored attack, showing that individuals inside the Saudi government funneled money to terrorism isn't equivalent to saying that Saudi government planned the attack.

You're ignoring the main thrust of my argument, that the Iranian government is dominated by religious extremists who sincerely believe it is their religious duty to spread their theocratic revolution across the world.

To this end the Iranian government has been closely involved in cultivating religious terrorism across the world for decades. You say that people expelled from Saudi Arabia end up in IS, this claim pales in comparison to the training, logistical support and technical expertise Iran directs to groups it helped create like Hamas and hezbollah. When american soldiers are killed by an IED in Iraq, it is most likely Iranian special forces that taught those terrorists how to make the IED, supplied the materials for it, and work closely with said groups to track their lethality and suggest improvements. They've literally dedicated engineers to inventing new IEDs to help penetrate American personnel carriers and kill more American troops.

Again, the difference here is everything I just said is the Iranian government formally coordinating with terrorists across the world in order to improve their lethality, not some rogue faction.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by fit2rule on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:16AM (#12479015)
> the Iranian government is dominated by religious extremists who sincerely believe it is their religious duty to spread their theocratic revolution across the world.

The same is true of the USA. Whether you agree with them or not is highly dependent on whether you stand to be a beneficiary of the spoils of their wars, or not.

And, btw, the CIA has exported far, far more terror than the IRG ever has.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Monday September 12, 2016 @10:35AM (#12479998)
I personally find the subject-changing 'what-aboutism'of Chomsky-ists tiring and repitive, but I'll bite.

Iran is currently the largest exporter of religiously inspired extremism, bar none. They are not engaged in short-term realpolitik that installs favorable governments in previously unfavorable countries. The IRG and Quds forces are true believers who see it as their duty to cultivate religious extremism across the world, and have been practicing their trade for the past several _decades_. There is no other country in the world that has been as deeply committed at all levels of government to fomenting sectarian violence throughout the world for nearly as long, and this is why Iran has such a powerful sphere of influence. These groups see the success of clients like Hamas and Hezbollah as their crowning achievements, and have been actively cultivating similar groups for the past several decades.

Again, the indisputable fact that I keep harping on is that Iran is the largest exporter of religiously inspired violence, bar none.

If the same was true of Saudi Arabia there is no doubt western liberals would have no problem publicly flagellating themselves, but since America is currently hostile towards Iran there are inevitably 'what-abouters' who will pop up and defend the propagation of violent interpretations of Shia ideology.

If you would like to contradict this fact, you could probably start by naming the US forces that Christian theology using torture, bombings, and creation of fundamentalist Christian terror groups. Until then, Iran is the largest exporter of religiously inspired violence, bar none.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by fit2rule on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:16PM (#12480966)
>There is no other country in the world that has been as deeply committed at all levels of government to fomenting sectarian violence throughout the world for nearly as long

The USA is just as guilty of this as any other nation. You're just not as willing to see it, since it doesn't fit your anti-Islam, pro-Christian narrative.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dragonwriter on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:22PM (#12481009)
I don't even see how an "anti-Islam, pro-Christian" bias justifies the mistake here; the US government is, historically pretty high on the list of nations fomenting specifically Islamic sectarian violence.

The motivation for doing so may be geopolitical rather than religious on the part of decisionmakers, but then, that's hardly unique among nations fomenting sectarian violence, Islamic or otherwise.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by fit2rule on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:28PM (#12481074)
It is far more religiously-motivated than you seem to care to admit. There are very, very few atheists in Congress calling for the bombing of Iran, and far, far more Christians who seem to be utterly okay with demolishing the Middle East in order to bring about Armageddon. Is that not clear to you, at this point?
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by dragonwriter on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:34PM (#12481141)
All I'm saying is a bias against Islam in considering sectarian violence and its sources shouldn't be sufficient to blind oneself to the US role in fomenting sectarian violence, given that the US role has been particularly prominent in directly fomenting Islamic sectarian violence, both directly and through proxies.

> There are very, very few atheists in Congress calling for the bombing of Iran,

There are very, very few open atheists in Congress, whether or not they are calling for the bombing of Iran.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:17PM (#12481595)
The last I checked I was an atheist, so I'm not sure how I'm pushing a Christian narrative. Furthermore, you mean my anti-Shia narrative, since nothing I've indicated so far has anything to do with Sunni's, seeing as Iran is a Shia nation. If anything, my claims lend credence to Sunni victimhood, but while I am very sympathetic to the Sunnis caught between ISIL on one side and scared of a Shia government in the other, I think Sunni Wahhabism has much to answer for.

But the difference in current geopolitics is that KSA is more fearful of, and has more to lose from ISIL than any other middle eastern country while Iran greatly benefits from the spread of their religious extremism. ISIL would greatly like to supplant KSA as the keeper of Mecca, Medina, and the Qabaa, while extremist Shia groups look to the Ayatollah as their spiritual leader. Can you see the distinction there?

Furthermore, I think your assertions overstate the actual history. Nixons alliance with the Saudis didn't ease any fears of sectarianism, but again the Saudi theocratic rentier government has been trying to tamp down on extremism since their legitimacy was threatened in 1979. The deposing of the Shah wasn't intended to stoke religious extremism, but it did and that is our legacy. The Neocons flirted with fomenting sectarian violence against the USSR in supporting the mujahideen, especially with logistical support and surface-to-air missiles. The Bush administration helped Iran inadvertently through beaurucratic incompetence and replacing a secular leader with a Shia dominated government who informally looks to Iran as its ally. But you also have to acknowledge that the removal of a secular dictator in favor of a Shia government has done more to balance the scales of power in favor of the Shia and lessened the power of our Saudi (Sunni) allies. This has a net effect of leveling the playing field between the two sides - while increasing the paranoia of Sunnis, it also gives the Iranians greater leverage in the region (giving them a greater stick in which to force Saudi cooperation). The Obama administration has flirted in small scales with supporting Syrian Sunni fighters and has prolonged the conflict by refusing to negotiate with Assad. The US has played an outsized role in the Middle East and must answer for it.

But again, these pale in comparison to the level of _sustained_ investment the Iranian government has made over the past 30+ years. We're not talking about a series of one-off realpolitik maneuvers. Iran is universally recognized as the most skilled operator in the region for good reason - no other country has operated in these areas for as long, or understands the culture or motivations as well. No other country is coordinating bombings in South America, and no other is trying to cultivate fundamentalist extremism there.

Lastly, I'd duspute the idea that I'm biased against Iran. I think the Persian people are probably the most amenable to western values out of any in the region, and current geopolitics notwithstanding they are probably the best hope for America to secure a long term peace in the region. I hope the moderate factions continue to achieve more successes as they have done with the nuclear accords, and there may even be a chance to end the heartbreaking tragedy in Syria by acknowledging their regional influence.

But I feel compelled to tell the truth as I see it, and to me that is acknowledging the fact that Iran is currently the worlds leading cultivator of fundamentalist terror. That doesn't mean I conflate the Ayatollah with the Persian people, that means the government of Iran is the central coordinator of Shia extremism throughout the world today, their spiritual leader. As with any government there are factions, but Irans hardliners came to power in the revolution and maintain power to this day. If moderates succeed in gaining more ground the region will be much safer overall.

Lastly, you again dodged my point. America is not cultivating Christian terror groups that look to Obama as their spiritual leader.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by karma_vaccum123 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:51PM (#12476712)
You are correct and this comments section (and it modding) demonstrates a fantastically shallow understanding of the Middle East that is easily addressed by airport bookstores.

Surely some of you know someone who has served in the US armed forces in the Middle East. Ask them who the "good guys" and "bad guys" are...

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by FireBeyond on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:05PM (#12476765)
Not that our military aren't intelligent and capable of cultivating their own opinions, but their training and ongoing survival in the arena of combat depends on identification of people as the enemy as 'will they put a bullet in you?' rather than the 'righteousness' of their beliefs or ideology.

This is a similarly shallow response.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:19PM (#12476799)
It's less of 'will they put a bullet in you' and more of 'Iran is the worlds greatest expert in the development and use of IEDs explicitly designed to maim and murder American forces, as in they have engineering staff embedded with insurgent groups teaching new ways of piercing American armored personnel carriers.'
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by FireBeyond on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:27PM (#12476825)
That wasn't a literalism. Of course I'm aware of the use of IEDs as a contrast to the traditional firefight.

But saying that forces on the ground are the best and most objective at assessing who is in the right and the wrong in these conflicts, who is 'good' and 'bad' is simply farcical, because all of the indoctrination and (indeed necessary) biases ("identify this person/group as bad, as they are a direct threat to my life, even though their overarching motivations may be the most noble") warp their perspective.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by travmatt on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:49PM (#12476880)
I can understand the notion that there is enough fault to go around, and that every group is incentivized to see the fault in every other group.

But my point is that Iran is unique in that it foments religious terrorism as matter of state policy unmatched in the world. Quds forces aren't exploiting religious people for their ends, they are true believers who are actively trying to bring their Islamist revolution to the rest of the world in a systematic and patient way.

A subjective and clearheaded analysis of available facts must lead to the conclusion that it's a literal terrorist state, and I think the poster you responded to is trying to dispel the false equivalency and 'what-aboutism' so prevalent in this thread and Chomsky-ist worldviews.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by flukus on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:05PM (#12476930)
> Surely some of you know someone who has served in the US armed forces in the Middle East. Ask them who the "good guys" and "bad guys" are...

I doubt they would recognize themselves as the bad guys.

Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by srhdmdndtjeyn on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:39PM (#12476476)
Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia
Re:Iran’s exceptional reaction to 9/11 attacks (2015) by madengr on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:26PM (#12476821)
I agree. I got along fine with the Iranians in school. The Saudis were lazy and worthless.