Re:Six big economic ideas [pdf]
by humanrebar on Saturday September 10, 2016 @03:24PM
(#12470535)
Roberts' willingness to provide airtime, even if by proxy, for opposing viewpoints is exemplary. It's rare to see the strong, compelling cases for various viewpoints presented in the same program, even when considering otherwise intelligent programming like we see on NPR and various opinionated podcasts.
It really strengthens all arguments since more of the discussion is reason-based. When programming ignores the good arguments from other perspectives, the programming is not much better than sophistry, in my opinion.
> that kind of self-processed humility could be a really dangerous manipulation technique :)
I just don't see that.
"I believe these things are true, but I acknowledge that I am, like everyone else, subject to unconscious biases."
"Well, that's exactly what a hyper-manipulative sociopath would say"
Re:Six big economic ideas [pdf]
by icebraining on Saturday September 10, 2016 @02:02PM
(#12470256)
Like I said, I don't think Russ Roberts is being manipulative, let alone an "hyper-manipulative sociopath". All I'm saying is that I find myself accepting his position more easily due to it being colored by my sympathy for his humility.
Intellectual honesty and humility is a good heuristic to look for if one is blindly assessing arguments. Even though there's a chance he could be dead wrong on a given topic, the fact that a person with those traits has arrived at a conclusion tends to suggest there's an honest case to be made for it. In other words, you could do worse than finding honest people and listening to them.
Well it's one of those things...
http://mediarelations.cornell.edu/2016/06/21/in-doctors-we-t...
Disclosing bias makes you sound "more trustworthy" or something so people discount the bias.
I really like Econtalk and I don't really have any reason to doubt his sincerity, but I've realized that to people like me who dislike pundits, that kind of self-processed humility could be a really dangerous manipulation technique :)