News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by GoToRO on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:17PM (#12456341)
I often wonder how would these people hire soldiers? "So I see you have no previous experience in killing people... We are looking for people that have at least 5 years of experience in killing people."

My point is you need smart enough people for your job and nothing more. You do an IQ test, a personality one and that's all. The rest can be learned.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by rifung on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:45PM (#12456613)
Not that I disagree with you, but sadly, most companies don't seem to want to train people anymore. They rather push that responsibility to either universities or the applicants themselves.

In fairness, I do think that someone who is very comfortable with a language or framework will be able to do things much faster than someone who isn't. Considering how quickly people change jobs nowadays, I can also see how companies don't want to train people only so they will leave shortly after or even before they're useful.

Obviously this is just based on my own experience in the US.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Spooky23 on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:35PM (#12458022)
15 years ago, my employer easily invested $15-20k in training into me and most of the other techs. It was a major factor in me sticking around vs taking a raise at another employer.

We've reverted to the mean in recent years unfortunately. No training, and lots of nickel and dime bullshit. Today, if I found the right role, it would just be a matter of finding the right number.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by sidlls on Thursday September 08, 2016 @04:51PM (#12457203)
Define "much faster." I am seriously trying to think of a developer I'd describe as competent and smart who could not pick up a new language or framework with sufficient understanding to be minimally productive (fixing minor to moderate bugs, contributing to new if simple features) inside a week or two. If that's not fast enough, something has gone terribly wrong planning the project.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by rifung on Thursday September 08, 2016 @08:28PM (#12458760)
I actually didn't mean the time it took for them to start contributing, I meant the time it would take for them to complete the same task.

Someone who knows the ins and outs of their language won't have to look up or learn new stuff as they go for example. This isn't even necessarily restricted to languages or frameworks, if you've done something similar to an assigned task, you would likely have already encountered certain pitfalls and know the best way to complete the task.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by GoToRO on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:49PM (#12456647)
I agree with you about the training. However if the stack is too specific, then the stack it's like a fingerprint and they are looking for somebody with the same fingerprint...
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Jemmeh on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:58PM (#12456730)
This is actually one of my interview red flags. For example if I say "I've worked with VB.NET 5 years, but not much C#" and they want 1 year C# experience. If they say that's a problem most of the time they don't know what they're talking about or they're not a company willing to invest in training their employees. I want a job that lets me learn.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by GoToRO on Thursday September 08, 2016 @04:06PM (#12456800)
@Jemmeh I "failed" a similar interview (VB, C#) Don't they know that the VB and C# examples are shown on Microsoft's site side by side?!

The only conclusion I reached is that one should navigate in life in such a way that your well being should not depend on people that are less smart, less experienced, less curious than yourself.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by sshumaker on Friday September 09, 2016 @11:21AM (#12463027)
I think this is probably because there is still a stigma associated with being a VB programmer. If you knew F# instead you might have been hired anyway.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by morgante on Thursday September 08, 2016 @08:43PM (#12458847)
What do you define as "training?"

Personally I don't think companies should be paying for specific training because as a developer you can learn anything you need online.

On the other hand, my experience is that many/most companies are willing to hire a senior developer even if they don't have experience with the company's specific stack. They rightly assume that any developer can pick up a new stack quickly enough.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by vonmoltke on Thursday September 08, 2016 @09:56PM (#12459162)
My experience has been that most companies aren't even willing to talk to me if I don't have experience in their specific stack. That's probably the downside of liking embedded/systems level development much more than webdev.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by civilian on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:33PM (#12456489)
I think the personalty trait we call "grit" or "stick-to-it-ive-ness" is hard to test for. And I think the best way to test for it is by looking at someone's track record. And it's one of the big three requirements. (which are: smart, works hard, someone you want to work with. )
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by GoToRO on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:39PM (#12456557)
Don't test then. Have somebody with real life experience judge the candidate. And by real life experience I don't mean 10 years in the same job...

Anyway the interview process is so broken that they could actually improve it by just flipping a coin.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Jemmeh on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:50PM (#12456654)
If I am a business owner, and I need someone to create a website for me to do something, the first thing I will reach for is someone who has already done similar projects and has a track record of getting it done. Teaching people is expensive, takes time (my website could be making me money -right now-) and doesn't always pay off. Whenever possible, it's often preferred to grab someone who can just hit the ground running.

I'm not saying this is perfect, just that's why experience is sought after. We have an annoying problem of way too many job ads being for seniors and very few for entry level. People have to get their foot in the door to ever become senior.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by vonmoltke on Thursday September 08, 2016 @04:44PM (#12457118)
> If I am a business owner, and I need someone to create a website for me to do something, the first thing I will reach for is someone who has already done similar projects and has a track record of getting it done.

If that is the case, what you need is a contractor, not an employee, and you should hire accordingly.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Jemmeh on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:02PM (#12457751)
I get what you're saying, but in this case the end result is still that the overall field is has high demands for people who already know how to do what they need done.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by red_blobs on Thursday September 08, 2016 @05:22PM (#12457463)
I disagree. Aside from an entry level position, you want someone with previous experience.

Google wouldn't hire someone to manage their datacenter with no previous experience managing anything like it.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Filligree on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:55PM (#12458164)
> Google wouldn't hire someone to manage their datacenter with no previous experience managing anything like it.

That's exactly what they do. The interviews test for basic skills — an understanding of TCP/IP, unix, programming ability and intelligence — and all the rest is on-the-job training.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by jameshart on Thursday September 08, 2016 @10:02PM (#12459181)
Your challenge there would be finding anything remotely like Google's datacenter.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by solipsism on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:34PM (#12458007)
Voted down for being about as wrong as possible about Google's hiring practices.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by GoToRO on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:58PM (#12456735)
Trust me, if you have a passionate non-web developer he can do the job just fine. And he/she applied for the job so they are interested to learn something new, maybe already started doing so but there is nothing to put down in a CV. They will read the tutorials, the documentation and they will deliver. I feel that nobody wants to give a chance to anybody.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by sotojuan on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:04PM (#12457766)
The business owner's response is that the experienced person won't take time reading tutorials or asking questions and thus get it done faster.

FWIW I agree most companies should train.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Jemmeh on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:12PM (#12457853)
I totally agree that they -can- do the job. The most important thing for a software developer is the ability to learn. We need to give people chances so that they even even enter the field to one day become senior level.

But I also understand how a lot of business owners feel about it. It takes time to learn these things vs someone who has basically already done this project before in this stack before. A business in a hurry (most of them) would rather have someone who already knows how to do it.

Look at Stack Overflow Careers. Look how many more ads there are asking for senior devs.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Apocryphon on Thursday September 08, 2016 @07:16PM (#12458306)
I think what you're getting at taps into the heart of the issue- it's not just that the software industry is fast-paced in terms of innovation, it's fast-paced in terms of business requirements, in getting products out of market to scramble for users, which translates to higher valuation, and more VC dumb money. So in SV we kinda have a HFT-type situation where companies have to continuously get more and more speedy and optimize greater, even if it comes at a human cost- i.e., everyone's hiring only for senior engineers and there's not enough openings for junior developers, much less the resources to train juniors.

As an aside, it's paradoxical that the industry simultaneously desires 10x seniors, while prizes youth (who they don't have to pay at senior salaries). So the true profile of a unicorn coder is basically a 10x dev with 10+ years of experience who is also a new grad that requires no training. Keeps down the cost, all around.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by Jemmeh on Friday September 09, 2016 @09:41AM (#12462060)
Right. It's that dream candidate who started programming at 9 and has no other hobbies besides coding.

Even jobs that don't really need developers of that caliber will hire like they do. I need someone to yet another billing app? Let me just hire one rockstar genius and squeeze the life out of them instead of two regular developers because it's cheaper.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by knz on Thursday September 08, 2016 @04:21PM (#12456924)
> My point is you need smart enough people for your job and nothing more. You do an IQ test, a personality one and that's all. The rest can be learned.

Company culture matters. Even the most intelligent people that are willing to grow will fizzle if they are in an environment that isn't productive.

Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by ng12 on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:25PM (#12456422)
There's a line there somewhere. Hiring someone for knowing Node is pretty silly, but hiring someone who's spent 5 years developing web apps is a useful metric.
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by GoToRO on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:31PM (#12456469)
In my experience, not that much. The 5 years experience might mean one year repeated 5 times. The person might be bored but he has no choice but to continue with web development and so on. Get somebody who is interested and smart enough for the job. Note I didn't say "the smartest".
Re:People are still bad at gauging their own interview perfo... by red_blobs on Thursday September 08, 2016 @05:30PM (#12457528)
5 years of 1 year experience repeated 5 times is better than someone that will introduce spaghetti code and security flaws simply because they've never experienced it.

It takes years to figure out patterns (when to use and not use them), good coding practices, avoiding newbie mistakes like sql injection and xss and how to actually make a deadline (its not easy to finish a project when you also have to learn the language and other skills in addition to the task at hand).

As a business owner, I don't want someone learning the above on the job and on my dime.

There is a company in MI that tried this called Compuware back in the 90s. It was a complete and utter disaster.