1. He picks the absolute bottom price.
2. Calls up the area dealerships within 50 miles
3. Tells them the model, price and his phone number to call back when they are ready to give him at his price
He totally shuts off any attempts by the sales people to erase my Dad's first number with their own by insisting he does not care about any extra features and other bs. His number is also terribly low(ALMOST but not totally in the you're joking category) so typically he can get the car within $500 of his quoted number. What does work for him is he communicates certainty of his decision to buy a car which is a tad easier because he is a surgeon.
If someone asks for a few grand more than what I was thinking, I think we can work something out and start negotiating. If someone asks for more than twice what I was thinking I may just keep looking.
I do think there is an upper limit which if you cross, you risk getting the other party to TOTALLY ignore it as a joke. I came pretty close to doing that with our PT person.