News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by andrenth on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:05AM (#12442610)
I'd like to offer some quotes from the book "Economics in one lesson", a book from the 40s that is still very relevant today. Specifically, from the chapter called "The curse of machinery":

Among the most viable of all economic delusions is the belief that machines on net balance create unemployment.

Let us turn to Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations. The first chapter [...] is called “Of the division of labor,” and on the second page of this first chapter the author tells us that a workman unacquainted with the use of machinery employed in pin-making “could scarce make one pin a day, and certainly not twenty,” but with the use of this machinery he can make 4,800 pins a day. In the pin-making industry there was already, if machines merely throw men out of jobs, 99.98 percent unemployment.

Arkwright invented his cotton-spinning machinery in 1760. At the time it was estimated that there were in England 5,200 spinners using spinning wheels, and 2,700 weavers - in all 7,900 persons engaged in the production of cotton textiles. The introduction of Arkwright’s invention was opposed on the ground that it threatened the livelihood of the workers, and the opposition had to be put down by force. Yet in 1787 [...] the number of persons actually involved in the spinning and weaving of cotton had risen from 7,900 to 320,000, an increase of 4,400 percent.

[...] Technophobes will assert: “That may have been all very well in the past, but today conditions are fundamentally different; and now we simply cannot afford to develop any more labor-saving machines.”

If it were indeed true that the introduction of labor-saving machinery is a cause of constantly mounting unemployment and misery, the logical conclusion to be drawn would be revolutionary, not only in the technical field but for our whole concept of civilization. Not only should we have to regard all further technical progress as a calamity; we should have to regard all past technical progress with equal horror.

There is also an absolute sense in which machines may be said to have enormously increased the number of jobs. The population of the world today is four times as great as in the middle of the 18th century, before the Industrial Revolution had got well under way. Machines may be said to have given birth to this increased population; for without the machines, the world would not have been able to support it. Three out of every four of us, therefore, may be said to owe not only our jobs but our very lives to the machines.

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by js8 on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:44AM (#12443284)
This is a pretty good theory but it lies on certain implicit assumptions that are becoming untrue. One is that there is abundance of energy and resources to exploit, so there is always more to be done (demand for labor) to transform it. But with automatization, we are coming to a state where limitation of economic activity is not labor, but resource consumption (mainly energy).

Also, what is the definition of job? But what the people worrying about automation are saying, there will not be more jobs that satisfy both of these conditions:

(1) Economic efficiency - the job is required to sustain the same level of production.

(2) Sustenance - the job must be capable to give person doing it enough money so he can live on it and participate in society.

For instance, we can always create jobs that break the condition (1), because we can always have more people being security guards or checking expense reports. Or we can always create jobs that break the condition (2), you know, you can always be a personal servant to somebody for really miserable pay.

I would actually argue that we are well past the point where (1) is true. But since our societies are so obsessed with jobs, we cannot really openly admit it.

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by andrenth on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:57AM (#12443390)
I'm not sure if I understood your points correctly. There is always more to be done. There is not a fixed set of things humanity needs that will one day be fulfilled. We didn't know we wanted cars, computers and smartphones until they were invented. This is regardless of scarcity, possibly even because of it (scarcity of resources will drive the need to be more efficient handling them).

I also don't understand your two points since (1) automation increases efficiency and thus production levels and (2) as a result of that increased productivity, there is a raise in wages.

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by Animats on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:53PM (#12448160)
"(2) as a result of that increased productivity, there is a raise in wages."

That stopped years ago. Ask any auto worker.

There's no economic reason that increased productivity should lead to an increase in wages. The benefits of increased productivity accrue to capital, not labor. What produced the increase in wages with productivity was labor activism, and fear of government intervention.

It's hard to imagine now, but there was a time when American companies were seriously afraid of what workers could do, both through unions and politics. Communism was considered a serious competitor to capitalism from about 1930 to 1980. That's what kept wages rising.

Once Ronald Reagan successfully made the case for unbridled capitalism, that ended. Now the US has "just in time" workers, few unions in the private sector, and weak worker protections. Competition between employees keeps wages down.

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by andrenth on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @06:26PM (#12448455)
Of course there are economic reasons for wage increases with productivity. They are the same reasons that explain any other increase in prices.

First, employers don't want to lose their more productive employees, and they have to compete with other employers offering jobs at higher pays. Second, once productivity rises, employers increase their earnings and can therefore hire more. This creates more demand for employees, and the price of work rises.

It's in fact the view that companies should be "afraid" that create regulations and restrictions that are usually what's responsible for reduction of wages and quality of life in general for workers.

See also: http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2013/07/productivit...

Finally, I find it really unbelievable that someone can claim in a serious conversation that the US have anything remotely similar to "unbridled capitalism".

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by Animats on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:29PM (#12445795)
There may "always be more to be done" (even that is questionable) but demand is limited by personal income.
Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by andrenth on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:13PM (#12446274)
I don't see your point? Some demand may be limited by personal income, while some is limited by corporate income and so on. This will cause producers to focus on things that are more in demand, while bringing down the price of lower demand products.

But this is just demand/supply dynamics. I don't see how automation is relevant here since that is valid with or without it.

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by AstralStorm on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @11:02AM (#12443957)
The part you're missing is that a higher wage is given to one person rather than many people, that you need capital to produce (hey, we need more chips, so now everyone with a hammer makes one).

Can you actually make a car? How many people are involved in making a Honda Civic vs Ford Model T?

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by andrenth on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:58PM (#12445548)
See the quote above. Automation has historically increased wages AND the number of available jobs.

No, I can't make a car, and have no interest whatsoever in making one. I could, however, buy a Honda Civic today in the US for more or less the same price (adjusted for inflation) as a Model T, but thanks in no small part to automation, it's a much more efficient, safe and comfortable car. And still the auto industry directly employs 1.5 million Americans now vs. 450k in the late 20s.

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by mandem on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:39AM (#12442843)
Greater abundance devalues the relative productivity of labour to machinery. But in the contemporary case, there is not enough demand (ie. low/no economic/population growth in the rich world) to valorise the greater abundance, hence the relative devaluation of labour is to a much greater extent.

In the same way that computers can beat the best human chess and go players, machines are beating a large (and ever increasing) proportion of human labour. This is lost ground. We will end up doing labour for 'fun' (ie. non-economic ends) since we cannot compete on economic grounds.

Re:Robot Macroeconomics: What can theory and economic histor... by andrenth on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:06AM (#12443048)
But in the contemporary case, there is not enough demand

This is a strong assertion to be made, especially in general like that. There is not enough demand of what, specifically? I agree that current interventionist economic policies are restricting growth, but to conclude from this that "there's not enough demand" is incorrect in my opinion.

machines are beating a large (and ever increasing) proportion of human labour

Just like the cotton-spinning machinery did in the past. We could not compete with it either, and yet the result has been more productivity, hence more jobs, better wages and the ability to support a larger world population.

I think a big part of this misunderstanding comes from the idea that we are competing with the machines when we are in fact making use of them.