edit: Doing math without the real numbers is less elegant and harder, but it's philosophically more sound. It essentially means restricting yourself to math that can be described as a (possibly infinite) algorithm.
The lay person is more likely to agree with what Wildberger has to say than a mathematician. In fact, most people think that infinity in math is a process (potential infinity). But in math, we use absolute infinity. A completed infinity. 0.999... does not tend to 1, it _is_ 1. Infinity is completed.
I'm confused. My impression is that it is the other way around where irrational numbers and operations like sine, square root etc. are infinite 'algorithms'?
I'm no mathematician, so I'm not qualified to comment on this either. Would love to hear other opinions on this too.
My personal opinion on this is that his rational approach does produce beautiful math, in the sense that it is really simple and intuitive.
I think most of cases of "non acknowledging" are deeply personal aesthetic considerations. One likes to play with one set of objects and only with them.
In the widest sense existence in mathematics means that mathematical object is well-defined and the system used is consistent (you can't derive contradictions).
Of course mathematicians are free do limit themselves into any subset of axioms or concepts they feel is "natural" or "real" and work only with them. But if they make philosophical arguments against other using irrational numbers, axiom of choice etc. I think they should argue that they are not consistent or well defined.
Square roots are algebraic, not transcendental.
Lectures start out by explaining the relation between complex numbers and rotations in the 2D plane, then discuss rotations in 3D using quaternions.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uRKZnFAR7yw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_XoZc-A1HU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g22jAtg3QAk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkNfQtINEjo