News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Quaternions encode rotations: derivation and sample code by llamaz on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:18AM (#12443574)
The general consensus is that his videos are very good. It's just his insistence that the real numbers shouldn't be used that is not accepted. Some mathematicians (1% of 1% of mathematicians) agree with him, most don't.

edit: Doing math without the real numbers is less elegant and harder, but it's philosophically more sound. It essentially means restricting yourself to math that can be described as a (possibly infinite) algorithm.

The lay person is more likely to agree with what Wildberger has to say than a mathematician. In fact, most people think that infinity in math is a process (potential infinity). But in math, we use absolute infinity. A completed infinity. 0.999... does not tend to 1, it _is_ 1. Infinity is completed.

Re:How Quaternions encode rotations: derivation and sample code by blux on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:34AM (#12443708)
> It essentially means restricting yourself to math that can be described as a (possibly infinite) algorithm.

I'm confused. My impression is that it is the other way around where irrational numbers and operations like sine, square root etc. are infinite 'algorithms'?

Re:How Quaternions encode rotations: derivation and sample code by empath75 on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:14PM (#12445188)
Yeah, but there's a difference between saying there exists in reality some exact value for the square root of 2, and saying that it's possible to calculate the square root of 2 to arbitrary precision.