News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by ljk on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:11AM (#12441399)
yup, there are a lot of re-uploaded videos and also command-line tools for downloading youtube videos
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by gioele on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:18AM (#12441421)
> yup, there are a lot of re-uploaded videos and also command-line tools for downloading youtube videos

The former _may_ classify as copyright infringement. The latter definitely does not.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by DanBC on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:24AM (#12441857)
Uploading a video to Youtube if you don't have permission of the rights holders is a very clear breach of copyright.

Downloading that video (whether by watching it on Youtube or by using a tool to download the video to watch offline) is, if you don't have the permission of the rights holder another very clear copyright breach.

There's some narrow exceptions for free use, or public domain content.

I'm surprised you think it isn't. In what country would that be true?

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by dozzie on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @06:18AM (#12442071)
E.g. in Poland. Don't be surprised, because it's not an absolute truth that you breach copyright watching something published.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by DanBC on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @07:38AM (#12442451)
Polish law is harmonised with the Copyright directive, which implements the WIPO treaty.

Watching a video on Youtube is only lawful if the rights holder has given their permission. Here, the rights holder hasnt given their permission and isn't getting compensation, thus it's not lawful in Polish law.

It might be useful if you provided a cite the the Polish law that gives this exemption.

The person uploading the video is clearly breaching copyright, and if they monetise the video that becomes criminal in most of EU. But the person downloading the video is also breaching copyright, albeit not criminally.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by zielmicha on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:39AM (#12442838)
Watching already published videos is fair use in Poland.

Art 23 Ustawa o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych

> 1. Bez zezwolenia twórcy wolno nieodpłatnie korzystać z już rozpowszechnionego utworu w zakresie własnego użytku osobistego. (...)

> 2. Zakres własnego użytku osobistego obejmuje korzystanie z pojedynczych egzemplarzy utworów przez krąg osób pozostających w związku osobistym, w szczególności pokrewieństwa, powinowactwa lub stosunku towarzyskiego.

translated:

> 1. Free usage of the already published work for personal use is allowed without a permit of authors . (...)

> 2. The scope of personal use includes the use of single copies of work by a group of individuals in personal relationships, in particular blood relation, kinship or a social relationship.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by lgieron on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:12AM (#12443521)
You've missed "within the scope of personal use" at the end of point 1 - which (IMO) means that you can only watch the video if it was posted by a friend/relative.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by saint_fiasco on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:41AM (#12443764)
Personal use just means you can't give the downloaded video to somebody else, you can't buy a giant projector and turn your house into a movie theater, that sort of thing.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by dozzie on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @11:15AM (#12444064)
I'm somewhat surprised you and DanBC show that deep understanding of Polish law despite of not living here, judging from your names.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by lgieron on Thursday September 08, 2016 @09:32AM (#12452782)
I'm Polish and live in Poland, funny to hear my name doesn't sound Polish though :)
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by kalleboo on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:09AM (#12441788)
> The latter definitely does not

Depending on what country you live in.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by Houshalter on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:22AM (#12441430)
It violates YouTube's terms of service and hurts the artists.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by pluma on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:15AM (#12441606)
> hurts the artists

... only if you use the version of youtubedl that comes with the knife-wielding robot.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by StavrosK on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @07:40AM (#12442458)
Why wouldn't you? It's free.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by ekianjo on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:55AM (#12441529)
> It violates YouTube's terms of service

Yes

> and hurts the artists.

Evidence required.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by davidiach on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:09AM (#12441577)
@spiderfarmer, the author can credit himself, all he has to do is put a "follow me on twitter @author" or something like that.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by DanBC on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:35AM (#12441900)
Videos are edited to remove that information. "Freebooting" is the term that's used.

A Facebook group will find a popular video on Youtube, then either edit out all identifying information or just remake the video, then post it to their group to get the views and ad revenue.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by eveningcoffee on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @06:37AM (#12442151)
What you describe here sounds like a real copyright piracy.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by DanBC on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @07:25AM (#12442371)
Most copyright laws make a distinction between copyright infringement done as part of trade and copyright infringement done for personal use.

EDIT: For fuck's sake, this is true, and follows from WIPO Copyright Treaty into the Copyright Directive for the EU and whatever the US equivalent is. Breaching copyright as part of trade turns it into a criminal offence, merely breaching copyright for personal use is a civil tort.

That's why in the various bit-torrent legal cases people who torrent are sued for loss by companies in courts, while people who run businesses running torrent sites are prosecuted by law enforcement.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by spiderfarmer on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:06AM (#12441562)
They get reuploaded to Facebook, where they go viral without crediting the author.

If you're a content creator trying to build an audience, it definetly hurts when people already saw your content elsewhere.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by pluma on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:19AM (#12441620)
> reuploaded

To quote your ggp:

> [re-uploading videos] _may_ classify as copyright infringement. [downloading YouTube videos] definitely does not.

And your gp:

> [Downloading YouTube videos] violates YouTube's terms of service and hurts the artists.

And your parent:

> Evidence required.

So... why are we talking about re-uploading again as if downloading was the same thing?

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by spiderfarmer on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:45AM (#12441699)
I never said all downloads are hurting content creators. I am saying if it was not possible to download them, the creators would be better off.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by pluma on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:40AM (#12441932)
Sure, and if companies wouldn't have to pay taxes, they would make more money.

If perfectly legal, permissible, expected and ethically justifiable behaviour hurts your bottom line, your business model is broken, not your customers.

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by tekromancr on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @12:06PM (#12444510)
No, because if it were not possible to download them, it wouldn't be possible to watch them in the first place.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by Houshalter on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:08PM (#12446185)
Why does HN find it so difficult to understand such a simple concept? Obviously people will download it for free that otherwise would have paid for it.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by creshal on Thursday September 08, 2016 @04:02AM (#12451120)
Free streaming does not cut into artists' sales, but downloads will, because…?
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by creshal on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:01AM (#12441547)
> hurts the artists

, because?

Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by Houshalter on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:09PM (#12446206)
Because people will download it for free, who otherwise would have paid for it. Why is this such a hard concept to understand?
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by dawnerd on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:23AM (#12441434)
youtube-dl has actually been really useful for backing up my own channel. Simply passing it a channel url and it will download everything in the best quality available.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by lern_too_spel on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:25AM (#12441632)
Google Takeout downloads the originals, which is better than the highest quality reencode.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by dawnerd on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:09AM (#12441789)
I had no idea about that, thats awesome, thanks!
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by i336_ on Thursday September 08, 2016 @12:48AM (#12450371)
Ooooh wow. That's a lot of diskspace...
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by balac on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:37AM (#12441478)
Shouldn't you already have the source videos for you channel?
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by dawnerd on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:09AM (#12441787)
For most of them no. A lot were school projects that only existed on youtube or smaller things that were uploaded from my phone etc.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:39AM (#12441485)
Backing it up from Youtube is likely a better solution since he doesn't have to upload everything twice on a (probably) slow uplink ADSL line.
Re:Pirates Plunder 4K Hateful Eight, but Did They Crack DCP? by dawnerd on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:08AM (#12441779)
Oh I have gigabit, so that's not an issue. But I can totally seeing that being an issue.